Mafiascum.net

Fidget is probably scum imo.

Just based on her reads and presentation.

We have a lot of lurkers though so this is going to be a pain.

I guess this is a request to scrutinize her posts more.

In post 3498, Noraa wrote: sorries:(
I'll .... maybe read it later.

Is fine, that post is only because Hopkirk wanted a response.

Of course shelly comes in to dishonestly accuse me of filling space even though I am literally just replying to someone and would not have bothered if they did not ask.

In post 3500, Bell wrote:Fidget is probably scum imo.

Just based on her reads and presentation.

We have a lot of lurkers though so this is going to be a pain.

I guess this is a request to scrutinize her posts more.

That is disappointing to hear

Fidget still town

I’m sorry.
You’re thinking out loud a lot and spending more time trying to look town than be town. You’re a little more down to earth and matter of fact when you’re town imo.

In post 3503, MURDERCAT wrote:Fidget still town

Probably not?

I’d prefer lld/other people look at their posts when they have time.

In post 3504, Bell wrote:I’m sorry.
You’re thinking out loud a lot and spending more time trying to look town than be town. You’re a little more down to earth and matter of fact when you’re town imo.

Writing down what I think as I think it is a huge characteristic of my play, as I feel it's the most effective way to prove you are town, since it would be difficult to write stream of consciousness as scum. Hurts my scum play because I cannot replicate it, but I do not mind.

Not sure if I do it as much on this account or not, my voice is somewhat different and my playstyle was originally intended to be as well. But if that's what you're noticing, well, you're noticing my town play. I'm not sure what you mean by I'm more down to earth / matter of fact as town, or how that conflicts with thinking out loud.

Have you played with me before or did you really read my games?

Fidget prob flips scum here too

We've played a few times.

I think there’s just less thinking out loud and more engagement in a clear manner toward other players?
Not saying you’re not engaged just that you seem to be engaging people less and thinking out loud more.

In post 3508, Bell wrote:Have you played with me before or did you really read my games?

Why are you asking this?

Oh.

Well I guess that explains why you addressed my concerns directly rather than asking for clarification.

It’s not a voting phase, so relax.

In post 3512, Vaxkiller wrote:

In post 3508, Bell wrote:Have you played with me before or did you really read my games?

Why are you asking this?

@Bell, like I really want to know why you are asking this.

In post 3512, Vaxkiller wrote:

In post 3508, Bell wrote:Have you played with me before or did you really read my games?

Why are you asking this?

When people talk to each other usually there’s more of a request to explain what someone means, but they just outright answered me like I was speaking clear as a bell. It made me think they must know me.
I don’t mean to alt hunt. I just noticed it.

Uncontroversial townreads

Hopkirk
MUSH
Lady
Murdercat
Gloria
Taylor
Adorable
Theta

More controversial townreads

Pooky
Shelly
Noraa
Zdenek

3 scum in (Fidget,Flea,Titus,Unowen,Bell,Vaxkiller,Lapsa)

Vax-Fidget preference I think?
Titus needs more looking at.

In post 3511, Bell wrote:I think there’s just less thinking out loud and more engagement in a clear manner toward other players?
Not saying you’re not engaged just that you seem to be engaging people less and thinking out loud more.

In post 3514, Bell wrote:Well I guess that explains why you addressed my concerns directly rather than asking for clarification.

It’s not a voting phase, so relax.

I'm not really sure what we're referring to anymore.

In any case, I'm only disappointed because I feel pretty good about you being town and I was hoping we had something special with the shelly read.

3-4 would make def make any analysis more meaningful.

Hopkirk, how easily would you say you find it to try hard or have high WIM as scum?

They kind of directly tripped me up and I’ve immediately started doubting myself.
That’s not hard to do though lol.

In post 3521, Bell wrote:They kind of directly tripped me up and I’ve immediately started doubting myself.
That’s not hard to do though lol.

Feel like you do that a lot. In fact, I feel like I've tripped you up on complete accident in a past game, having no idea what I said. I think you're referring to me, anyway.

You'd be correct to do so in this case, but still.

In post 3516, Bell wrote:

In post 3512, Vaxkiller wrote:

In post 3508, Bell wrote:Have you played with me before or did you really read my games?

Why are you asking this?

When people talk to each other usually there’s more of a request to explain what someone means, but they just outright answered me like I was speaking clear as a bell. It made me think they must know me.
I don’t mean to alt hunt. I just noticed it.

Oh. I was thinking something else.

It come of incredibly overly defensive for fidget not really scum reading you (as far as I can tell).

But your explanation fits better.

I changed my mind.
And retract the scum read given brazen confidence.