In post 3497, Something_Smart wrote:So... what do you think happened to the neighborizer role then? She admitted that she was aware it was often hotly contested, but she would gamble her life on nobody having chosen it?
oh come on >_> that is what i was thinking about, but i thought there would be value in skitter coming to that conclusion on her own, why did you spell it out
Like if its known it has to be in the game i'd be a lot less sus but as of right now i dont know that
yeah, but if scum hasn't chosen the neighborizer they don't know it either
do you think it's likely scum!mare took a shot in the dark that nobody in town claimed neighborizer when she herself would have no clue whether that's the case?
Like if its known it has to be in the game i'd be a lot less sus but as of right now i dont know that
yeah, but if scum hasn't chosen the neighborizer they don't know it either
do you think it's likely scum!mare took a shot in the dark that nobody in town claimed neighborizer when she herself would have no clue whether that's the case?
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:14 am
by Something_Smart
Neighborizer has never been missed in any PYP game.
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:15 am
by Datisi
In post 3502, Something_Smart wrote:I don't like to sit and watch people be wrong, especially people who are way more persuasive than me in general
letting them be wrong for a little while can be alignment telling >_>
tldr of your thoughts on the game atm? still want andante dead?
Like if its known it has to be in the game i'd be a lot less sus but as of right now i dont know that
yeah, but if scum hasn't chosen the neighborizer they don't know it either
do you think it's likely scum!mare took a shot in the dark that nobody in town claimed neighborizer when she herself would have no clue whether that's the case?
Admittedly not super likely but i have a hard time swallowing that explanation ...
I recognize that scum-mare has to be gambling on nobody else having the slot and cc-ing her, but i find missing neighborizer/proveable night actions in this setup to be very suspicious
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:18 am
by Something_Smart
In post 3507, Datisi wrote:I AM AWARE I WANTED TO HEAR WHAT SHE HAD TO SAY
This is really irritating, we clearly have different goals here.
I'm trying to, like, actually talk to skitter and level with her and you're like the cop with dark shades in the interrogation room telling her her partners have already confessed
In post 3470, catboi wrote:I think midwaybear's posting right now is fine. Him going "idk" to my question about why he was voting Datisi raised some alarm but right now he doesn't seem uncomfortable responding to things where generally he struggles to interact in realtime as scum
In post 3471, catboi wrote:went and looked at datisi's iso because I wasn't sure about him and came away thinking he's probably town
can you give me a tl;dr of your thought processes behind these two posts? for midway specifically, what about his realtime interactions here struck you as difficult to fake?
I think midwaybear's posts are difficult to fake
for him
in that he has trouble doing that stuff
at all
as scum and having a thought, being able to pull up something to justify it, and re-evaluating and not locking up like a deer in headlights. It all felt natural enough.
The super boring answer is I went over your ISO and was looking through and remembered solvy analysis posts that I had forgotten about, and it all felt real enough that I'm not going to start tinfoiling you on day 2
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:19 am
by skitter30
In post 3509, skitter30 wrote:but i find missing neighborizer/proveable night actions in this setup to be very suspicious
Also i suppoze less so now that i remember scum have multitasking too
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:20 am
by Datisi
In post 3510, Something_Smart wrote:I'm trying to, like, actually talk to skitter and level with her and you're like the cop with dark shades in the interrogation room telling her her partners have already confessed
i was about to say "ngl skitt might as well be scummy for the naked vote and 'lol idk i want to sort you' but not asking any questions because there's no way she actually thought that would lead to sorting and obviously her vote on catboi was supposed to just be ez racking up of votes"
but then i went to actually check the last time i remembered her doing that and
In post 755, Bridgeburners wrote:dats i feel like i don't have such a good read on u and i kinda want to sort u
ok
what is it that you want / need from me here
and also why do you think naked voting is like, gonna help you here
(i am also specifically still interested in mena's reasons for that vote)
i don't know!!!! i feel like having some sort of dialogue with you would help, and was kinda hoping that by voting you you'd go: 'omg skitter why are you voting me' and then we could have a nice convo about idk something that would give me more to sort you with than i currently have
i feel like a lot of what you're doing is just kinda NAI? Or at least i don't see the obvtowniness that everyone is citing and like i feel like a lot of what you're doing can be said/posted by scum-you?
do you think you ought to be townread here as much as you have been?
i'm also not really sure i follow your 'evil vibes from isis wagon' -> aaron vote -> isis vote
or why you were scumreading aaron in the first place
~ skitter
she did the very similar "idk i wanna sort you i'm just gonna naked vote you lole" so i gUESS it's not as scum indicative as i thought
well I didn't mention the multitasking thing and she figured it out on her own. did you get anything from that?
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:32 am
by skitter30
That's basically exactly how i feel abt catboi rn, yeah
~
Catboi why *did* you switch to mare just before this?
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:33 am
by Something_Smart
I didn't deliberately hold that one back, though I will concede that holding it back might have been helpful. I don't think holding either of the things I said back would have helped; the first was a really obvious argument that she already considered, and the second was a stat she had no way of knowing.
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2022 3:33 am
by catboi
In post 3520, skitter30 wrote:That's basically exactly how i feel abt catboi rn, yeah
~
Catboi why *did* you switch to mare just before this?
I woke up and decided it felt like the right vote to make
