I did:
In post 3546, mastina wrote:Your posts seem to largely be bad takes. You may have a posting restriction that runs polar opposite to your natural playstyle, but the content within those posts is what I am finding to be forced and just radiating "bad". Not just the word count, literally all of the content.
These are the non-tonal reasons, the non-tone, non-feeling things. The only thing I didn't do was quote them to show them off. And that'd be these:
In post 3468, WindowsXP wrote:I see BM vote on me which is kinda hilarious considering the previous. Big ping seeing that coming in.
In post 3472, WindowsXP wrote:i think taly is scum based on my initial rereads of n1 and based on results of n1 being that i was sabo'd. also the purple text gimmick shit sounds like a faked task to me. shits too easy. both my tasks are fairly difficult things. bouncing off this logic i think flea is real bc who the fuck is gonna extract vowels for a mafia games. fuck that noise.
also mastina did the cursed coffee scumtell!! I'm goign to dive into their iso but holy shit like coffee is acutally legit a pretty weird thing like that does catch scum(its sorta a small complacency tell where ur like "oh im sorry im not performing bc no coffee)
im looking at a PoE of taly/mastina/battle mage rn based on my gut tells. im going to dive into the game much more in a bit and analyze actions and such but i wanna go over night PTs first since i cant view them for too long.
In post 3476, WindowsXP wrote:but taly just sorta pings me all over the place with subtle tells, such as a word mismash in a post they corrected later(scum are more likely to reedit posts to make sure they look towny and then leave a glaring grammatical error.) and alisae even pointed out how taly's reads just were so mismatched to eir own and thats a huge thing u can see with scum is that even if they're mimicking their townplay well, their reads will slip which i think is what happened to taly there.
id like to hear the case on HC because my vibe is that its probably a comfort LHF wagon. OW is also now on my radar based on what i saw in N1 PT>
id say blitzo town.
since HC was MIA from both nights im not gonna discount them being a major suspect.
Literally the only takes here that aren't bad are the Blitzo take (which I can see as a good take even if most would count it as a bad take) and the second-Haschel take which contradicts with the Haschel take earlier in the post. (You literally said opposite things about Haschel in the same post. Most people would say that's cognitive dissonance.) And even the Blitzo take which wasn't bad...
In post 3480, WindowsXP wrote:i rescind my townread on you until you can explain. i feel like this post could be a scumslip and im not vibing with it at all.
this post like completely feels off and now im feeling suspicious.
...You take back here.
The Titus townread is the next take of yours which isn't a bad one.
Your takes on BM, me, Taly, Haschel, and Blitzo are, overall: shit. They are objectively bad takes backed by objectively bad reasons. No amount of subjective tone to them, no amount of subjective "I think this tone is faked/forced" to them. They are so unbelievably awful and fundamentally out of touch with reality (and I imagine literally every slot in the game will back me up here in this assessment--how many of the alive players affirming my statement that your posts are out of touch with reality will it take for you to agree that my statement of them being so is not subjective? Five? Eight? Because I mean it when I say this aint subjective, it is pretty damn objective) that I don't see how they actually come from scum.
I'm not going to break down the specifics of every post you made and what in them I feel looks scummy--if I were writing a case for why you're scum, then sure, I would do so! But I
don't
think you're scum, so you'd be asking me to write a case on why I think a player that I am townreading is scummy. Writing a case for why a townread of mine is scummy (what you're asking me to do) is a waste of time. I'm humoring you by doing this much, but I'd much rather focus on the "why I think WindowsXP is town" than the "why I think WindowsXP is scummy", thankyouverymuch.
On that note, I should be paying more attention to the tarot stream I'm listening to.
In post 3548, WindowsXP wrote:i want you to actually evolve this into a specific read of it so ur not allowed to backtrack later and be like "lol acktually i guess kobas entrance was scum and i should have seen it xD".
I have--I feel that your replacement is so out of touch with reality that there's no way it actually comes from scum. If you were scum, then you would have a scum PT that'd allow you to have a better grasp on the game, and yet your entrance is so flagrantly in violation of all the aspects of the game that it's either an entrance made without the aid of one or which deliberately discarded its feedback.
In the case of the latter, that'd be the realm where you'd be scum, sure...but I very much do not believe that's the world we're in. It's a world that's theoretically-possible, but in practice so outlandishly unlikely I'm calling it impossible, because it's more than just your stances and reasons which contribute. You're a slot that is under some rather decent amount of pressure. Your chosen entrance is one which is incredibly likely to increase the pressure on you, which is likely to antagonize several key figures in the town and make them your enemies. Something which is VERY bad for scum to do. So overall the radiated shitty-energy isn't "obvscum who is blatantly being scum without trying to hide it", it's "bad town that is out of touch with reality". Because if you were scum, I'd expect the pushes you were making to be more strategic, more refined, more tactical, more precise. If you were scum that felt the need to disrupt/dismantle a townbloc, you'd need to do so more subtly so, and this brazen approach is the polar opposite of it. You're being very loud and aggressive in the bad takes that run contrary to reality overall and showing such a flagrant disregard to any survivalism that it's something I can't see as coming from scum.
I can't really think of a way to more strongly, accurately, aptly describe my townread on you than that. It's about as detailed as I can get, but yes, it is still summed up as, essentially, "too scummy to be scum". The read is concrete. The reasoning, too. I've literally typed enough words on why to fulfill your posting restriction. You're literally a more detailed nuanced read than I've generated on any other player in the game.
Oh, and fun fact; my little kitteh likes to roll around in an area that has been bleached after the bleach has been removed. (She's a bit insane that way.)
In post 3548, WindowsXP wrote:Who's scum today? who are you voting? Also, what was your read on Maestro/Alisae?
I literally replaced in only two days ago--by which time, Maestro was not a player in the game. You're literally the first impression I've gotten on your slot. My read was thus, thoroughly null.
As for scum: {Flea the Magician, Pooky the Magical Bear, Haschel Cedrickson, MURDERCAT} is where I am mostly looking, with Flea being the towniest of the four.
Oh and tinny sound is annoying.
Nothing triggers my misophonia worse than popcorn tho.
