Mafiascum.net

In post 4719, skitter30 wrote:i think claiming it taht early would ultimately avoid most of the mess with my slot ... and i think it also strongly ups my odds of being, like, dead

Yes. Seeing your own death as a bad thing is precisely why you f'd up day 1 if you're town. The second Imperium revealed, as town watcher in the wrong thread, you should have hard-claimed and explained why it is mechanically *braindead obvious* that you MUST be in the forward thread. Even if you're scum and even if we think you're a scum watcher, we probably still go for it because we force you to keep nachotammy alive. You can say "oh I softed hard enough" but not in a gamestate this cluttered. If you're town, you dun goofed. Anyway yeah no point continuing this now, just think you really are not helping by haranguing your thread about their reads of you when your mech play leaves a lot to be desired in a world of town!skitter. But if you're town I'm not helping by pushing this further either so I'll go ahead and disengage now.

-E

In post 3549, Gypyx wrote:And how's he obvtown exactly?

The setup is waaaaaaaay, waaaaay, WAAY too fucking scumsided if his role is scum. Trust me on this, you do not need to actually think about brian's alignment this game. He is mason-level town.

I should have realized this day 1 but I didn't realize how quasi-bastard this setup was before I'd had a time to reflect, and how the quasi-bastard nature of the setup requires brian's role to be town.

-E

In post 4723, GFITAC wrote:Btw which of Scorpia and Entrapta is HUB? Which one wanted to be right about Flavor, as well?
-BCCorp

Entrapta is HUB and yes, Happy Unbirthday Boon is also the one that wanted to be right about Flavor

-E

Hmm, i don't find the setup to be bastard but if you say so, not gonna argue about that anyways

And yeah i agree with you on that claim now that you bring it up, like, it kind acts as a killing role

In post 4722, GFITAC wrote:But first a thing @ forwards thread, specifically HP: why am I being leashed to fire? I think he’s town, but why is he worth protecting?

Because he retracted his cop-claim, therefore you must protect the not-a-cop. :3

-E

In post 3553, Gypyx wrote:Hmm, i don't find the setup to be bastard but if you say so, not gonna argue about that anyways

Not actually bastard, bastard insofar as expecting the town to do things well that are against the nature of town to do well, hence quasi-bastard.

-E

Like what? (Yeah sorry i don't follow your reasoning at all there)

hmm. I'd forgotten the sequence there. In that case it was actually mechanically incorrect for Nachotammy to IC-reveal after the inverted turnstile had triggered, although I don't think they at that point had any reason to know how mechanically incorrect that was. Returning to my 'quasi-bastard' characterization...

Actually I can't even fault Cakez. There's reasons to activate day 1, and there's reasons to not activate day 1, but unfortunately activating day 1 after inverted turnstile is worst case scenario. Again, not that there's any way Nachotammy could have anticipated that. Large theme shenanigans. Meh

-E

hey spiffeh

which titus "case" from gypyx did you like again?

In post 3556, Gypyx wrote:Like what? (Yeah sorry i don't follow your reasoning at all there)

okay let me put it this way

most of town power is in the wrong timeline

the only way to change timelines is to claim you have a reason to want to change timelines

one person can turnstile a day

scum get one kill per thread per night

the reason there's ton of redundant power is because this game's premise is like... turnstiling town power just to watch them die

the only reason pooky and pisskop are still alive, if they are not both scum, is because of how widely scumread they were.

brian's role is the ONLY way that town can, IN THEORY, coordinate bringing both a protective *AND* an investigative over to the correct thread in one day

the likelihood of town actually INFERRING that that's what they were supposed to do with brian's role is like... 0% though

but brian's role actually was how this entire game was supposed to work, just not in the way I thought. It was the only way to disrupt the pattern of 1 TPR turnstile-->1 TPR night killed

that's also why it being a role that can be IC'd off setup spec is not actually an issue for game balance like I was initially worried it could be

-E

also brian is just obvious town for other reasons too but the role thing pushes him way up into mason-level town

-E

In post 4732, Something_Smart wrote:I see. I don't follow why HP thinks that's so strong.

I mean so far it seems like pretty much all of town power is f'd in its starting timeline. 6 scum is already scumsided, 6scum + almost all town power being temporally gated with 1/day turnstile is like... hyper, insanely broken scumsided bad. brian + nachotammy is only way town even has a fighting chance

-E

so gypyx appears to be following the other game

i wanna know what he thinks the original scum split was and who he thinks is actually scum

and also what connection he saw between shelly and titus that made titus scum with shelly but not scum if shelly was town

im deeply saddened that i have to be the one who asks such an obvious fucking question but apparently you all just let that one slide so i guess here we are

not to mention a connection he didn't even talk about yesterday lol

@Cabd think kindred not lovers

I don’t think it’s wise to keep going

I'm actually waffling on my Gyx read right now.

I'll probably towncase Pooky tomorrow.

Cabd I plan to try and take a look and reevaluate my conclusion tonight (depending when I get out but I am due at 830) but I felt pretty solid in my assumption- did you get a chance to review and confirm yours?

In post 3565, Annie Edison wrote:@Cabd think kindred not lovers

I don’t think it’s wise to keep going

Does it matter what thread they are in?

In post 3559, Hench Princesses wrote:

In post 3556, Gypyx wrote:Like what? (Yeah sorry i don't follow your reasoning at all there)

okay let me put it this way

most of town power is in the wrong timeline

the only way to change timelines is to claim you have a reason to want to change timelines

one person can turnstile a day

scum get one kill per thread per night

the reason there's ton of redundant power is because this game's premise is like... turnstiling town power just to watch them die

the only reason pooky and pisskop are still alive, if they are not both scum, is because of how widely scumread they were.

brian's role is the ONLY way that town can, IN THEORY, coordinate bringing both a protective *AND* an investigative over to the correct thread in one day

the likelihood of town actually INFERRING that that's what they were supposed to do with brian's role is like... 0% though

but brian's role actually was how this entire game was supposed to work, just not in the way I thought. It was the only way to disrupt the pattern of 1 TPR turnstile-->1 TPR night killed

that's also why it being a role that can be IC'd off setup spec is not actually an issue for game balance like I was initially worried it could be

-E

I don't disagree with thinking that brian is town, but:

They can simply not claim, not get turnstiled, not use their role, and then on day 4 the two threads can merge together and they can use their role. But then they don't get to use their roles on the first 3 nights? Sure, but they're not all dead or outted. And there can be other roles or mechanics in the game that can swap players around and figure out other players roles to help them

In post 3568, Dunnstral wrote:

In post 3565, Annie Edison wrote:@Cabd think kindred not lovers

I don’t think it’s wise to keep going

Does it matter what thread they are in?

Cabd and I have different views on our variables. I think Shelly was being truthful when she said what happens when they exist in the same thread.

Actually I just realized what you’re asking.

From what I asked, yes. Same thing happens

In post 3559, Hench Princesses wrote:the only way to change timelines is to claim you have a reason to want to change timelines

There's a neighborhood

You don't have to claim for the entire room to see

I'm also sort of disgruntled that people can't resist claiming before the end of day 2

guessing that's happening in the uncultured time line? how boorish