My gutreads at the moment ignoring all assocations are:
dupping/UNOwen
shelly/Plus
Dave
It's weird. duppin still pings heavily as town to me, just in all of his thoughts and the way he's pushing for stuff to happen. Plus's response to me I found fairly good. Dave just hasn't done enough today and doesn't seem to have any interest in solving this.
Now, when you add associations and potential team stuff, it gets more complicated. I'll definitely dedicate some time into rereading interactions between Noraa and co before the deadline is upon us. I suspect it'll be fruitful.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 1:36 pm
by Hectic
In post 3558, PlusJOYED wrote:shelly you agreeing/TRing me is scaring me a lil not gonna lie lol. Like your gonna flip out and tunnel me when I least expect it.
I'm just used to being mislimed by you but given way town is acting scum!shelly could pretty easily win by pushing me.
How does scum!shelly treat her partners? Have you ever seen scum!shelly treat a partner like she's treating you right now?
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 1:39 pm
by Hectic
I want to say more, but I really want to see shelly come back and confirm/deny the guilty first. Why did you drop that and then go afk and not care to reply to duppin's instant rebuttal, shelly? You were active elsewhere.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 1:43 pm
by duppin
i need to sleep now but i will get back to this but yes shelly if you are town then i hope you understand why you have to retract the claim as soon as possible because otherwise the day is stalling and youre pushing it into a tvt.
if youre scum then do whatever you feel like but i will consider it to be a scum claim if you do not retract it
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 1:59 pm
by Morning Tweet
Bat Fact #22:
Similar to how microbats use clicking sounds to echolocate, some species of flying fox can use wing noises to help find their way in the dark.
[/mech]
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 3:50 pm
by davesaz
Oh good, I'm only 2 pages behind. At the bottom of 142.
Sorry, it's been a couple rough days.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 4:13 pm
by davesaz
So Shelly's claim happened. I have no meta to evaluate it with. I'm a little worried that I'll spend a bunch of time deep diving to do that reset and it will all be for naught.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 6:18 pm
by shellyc
In post 3572, Hectic wrote:shelly, do you retract or stand by your claim?
VOTE: duppin
duppin claim now
im apathetic, this has been stalling
I bus too much by the way. i dont hard defend partners
In post 3558, PlusJOYED wrote:shelly you agreeing/TRing me is scaring me a lil not gonna lie lol. Like your gonna flip out and tunnel me when I least expect it.
I'm just used to being mislimed by you but given way town is acting scum!shelly could pretty easily win by pushing me.
How does scum!shelly treat her partners? Have you ever seen scum!shelly treat a partner like she's treating you right now?
usually early game bus a bit and try to appear townie
late game tunnel town
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 7:00 pm
by PlusJOYED
In post 3575, Hectic wrote:My gutreads at the moment ignoring all assocations are:
dupping/UNOwen
shelly/Plus
Dave
It's weird. duppin still pings heavily as town to me, just in all of his thoughts and the way he's pushing for stuff to happen. Plus's response to me I found fairly good. Dave just hasn't done enough today and doesn't seem to have any interest in solving this.
Now, when you add associations and potential team stuff, it gets more complicated. I'll definitely dedicate some time into rereading interactions between Noraa and co before the deadline is upon us. I suspect it'll be fruitful.
with that list im thinking its 100% the right play to wait a day
ignoring my shelly read, lets consider what happens when we wait
if shelly dies and flips investigative, that's an easy duppin elim.
If shelly doesn't die and is town investigative, we have a high chance of solving right there or confirming a townie. Regardless, scum is probably boned if we wait and shelly is town invest.
and if shelly is scum that puts them in an extremely akward position imo where they have to fake a solve or confirm a townie, and super qkward to fake. Why go through all that when shelly had a solid chance to elim me today if she SR me.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 7:03 pm
by PlusJOYED
shelly did a fake CC on me once in doggos as scum day 1. But in that case it went very horribly for scumteam, and I was already really scummy.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 7:14 pm
by PlusJOYED
yeah VOTE: no elimination
rn im at duppin/uno being the solve. I reconsidered dave and I think his predecessor was pretty townie, I think his catchup struggle is genuine, and the vote on mundi was extremely risky given his standing
duppins recent posts regarding shellys invest result is pretty panicky too.
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 7:15 pm
by shellyc
sigh we have to elim today
i'll tell you why
im a Night 3 investigative
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 7:16 pm
by shellyc
we wont be closer to solving if we no elim and I just die, it brings us into lylo with duppin confscum, then 3p lylo with probably {plus UNO davesaz}
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 7:23 pm
by PlusJOYED
...like night 3 only? What?
I've never seen a gate that specific. One night? And pretty late game too
It also seems convient for a claim for lylo.
Even so for reasons explained its still better to nolim for poe. I think its very unlikely your scum but still faintly possible.
In post 3572, Hectic wrote:shelly, do you retract or stand by your claim?
VOTE: duppin
duppin claim now
im apathetic, this has been stalling
I bus too much by the way. i dont hard defend partners
okay i assume you stick to your claim, which makes this a lot more simple actually
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:09 pm
by duppin
In post 3586, PlusJOYED wrote:yeah VOTE: no elimination
rn im at duppin/uno being the solve. I reconsidered dave and I think his predecessor was pretty townie, I think his catchup struggle is genuine, and the vote on mundi was extremely risky given his standing
duppins recent posts regarding shellys invest result is pretty panicky too.
plus if you are town then you really need to revaluate how you read people as your read seem to be based on conf bias because you believe shelly is town and you believe i am scum. there was nothing panicky about my reaction. If you are town then you are really being pocketed. I think you need to ask yourself why you townread shelly and why you scumread me independently instead of being pushed into reads. If you still reach the same conclusion it is what it is
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:18 pm
by duppin
okay so seeing as shelly seems to commit to her claim, it should honestly be rather obvious that this is a fake claim
In post 3560, shellyc wrote:Okay I've been thinking about this and I think this is the right move atm...
The Revelation!
the reason why I'm currently town on plus is because
I have a GUILTY result on duppin
, and I know the world they're pushing is at least halfway correct.
I am a
Town [REDACTED]
. I am an investigative and may or may not be gated with one incriminating result (on duppin) and no clears. I can think some instances however that this result occurs when I check a town. I'm not claiming the exact investigative until duppin claims as to give a scum!duppin less information to make their fakeclaim.
@duppin, please claim now.
first of all she has not claimed what her role is or what her result is, but she claims she could think of a reason "this result might be town". There is nothing about my role and it should be fairly obvious due to my reaction what my role is actually, that should lead her to believe it is scum no matter what her role is. It looked like an obvious reaction test due to the vague and careful claim
however now she seems to claim that i am "conf scum" without elaborating on her claim, this is an inconsistensy that honestly makes no sense. also if I was confirmed scum to her, why would my claim even matter?
In post 3588, shellyc wrote:we wont be closer to solving if we no elim and I just die, it brings us into lylo with duppin confscum, then 3p lylo with probably {plus UNO davesaz}
these are also super questionable because as plus just said it should be obvious that if shelly was indeed a tpr and i was scum then it would not make any sense for me to lim her in the night
the "night 3" investigative claim is also convenient in the sense it means that she does not need to provide any other results
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:26 pm
by shellyc
you said you could only be miller
im tracker and tracked you to the nightkill
I'm on mobile but I have crumbed my role here
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:27 pm
by shellyc
In post 3592, duppin wrote:however now she seems to claim that i am "conf scum" without elaborating on her claim, this is an inconsistensy that honestly makes no sense. also if I was confirmed scum to her, why would my claim even matter?
I plan this claim since I got the result
I ask you to claim
you say you can only be miller
you're not PR who visited the nightkill
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:31 pm
by shellyc
as scum there is no reason to be vague with a guilty claim other than losing cred...
duppin I withheld the info to make you not get info to make a fakeclaim
you assumed this was a cop guilty and I didn't know about meta = miller claims d1
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:32 pm
by duppin
lol shelly, i said i could only be miller which i thought was unlikely for you to have any kind of result on me
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:33 pm
by shellyc
In post 3596, duppin wrote:lol shelly, i said i could only be miller which i thought was unlikely for you to have any kind of result on me
are you the fucking track miller
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:33 pm
by duppin
in other words there is nothing else i could have done that could lead you to believe i was scum which was why I said it was a fake claim.
Anyway this is actually a bad fake claim as scum
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2020 10:34 pm
by shellyc
I will rage about this setup if you're really a track miller btw.
