NY 213 - Game Over!

[Kublai Khan]

Oh yay, Tchill is town.

So is Creature.

What the fuck.

Do people not actually read Creature posts?

Someone needs to link me to a scum-Creature game. All game people have been saying his scum game is obvious. And if it's somehow more obvious than this game, I have to see this for myself.

[PenguinPower]

Oh yay, Tchill is town.

So is Creature.

What the fuck.

Do people not actually read Creature posts?

Someone needs to link me to a scum-Creature game. All game people have been saying his scum game is obvious. And if it's somehow more obvious than this game, I have to see this for myself.

Via a quick search.

I'm sure there are more recent examples but I don't feel like searching.

[Kublai Khan]

The ones trying to topple the WhemeStar wagon at the point where it became a legit wagon and by-passed PenguinPower were: Gamma Emerald, TehBrawlGuy, Vaxkiller, and especially Creature.

Around and posting, but not joining the WhemeStar wagon: Dunnstral and (much lesser extent) texcat.

also of note is that dunn absolutely did attempt to topple wheme wagon, so why is he in the second group?

It was almost 3 am. Brain mush for reading 50 pages in 3 hours. Yeah. Dunnstral was trying hard to un-wagon the Mafia Universal Backup.

[PenguinPower]

Have another

[Creature]

Damn, I so miss the games I got lynched only D3

[Kublai Khan]

Oh yay, Tchill is town.

So is Creature.

What the fuck.

Do people not actually read Creature posts?

Someone needs to link me to a scum-Creature game. All game people have been saying his scum game is obvious. And if it's somehow more obvious than this game, I have to see this for myself.

Via a quick search.

I'm sure there are more recent examples but I don't feel like searching.

You picked an example who nobody voted scum-Creature all game until he was caught by night-action.

Creature is obv-scum posting WIFOM.

You're calling him town. Why?

[JarJarDrinks]

I considered PP an equally bad lynch.

So...

- You townread 2 people
- one is claiming doc and one is claiming VT
- You think they both equally a bad lynch

Are any of the above points incorrect?

[PenguinPower]

You're calling him town. Why?

I feel like this has been explained to you several times now. Look at his engagement with the game.

Why do you scum read him beyond his defense of Wheme yesterday? Or is that it?

[PenguinPower]

I mean if we're lynching someone who didn't hop on Wheme quickly, I would much prefer Dunnstral.

[JarJarDrinks]

Why do you scum read him beyond his defense of Wheme yesterday? Or is that it?

"What evidence do you have the defendant committed the murder beyond him holding the murder weapon over the body?"

[PenguinPower]

Yeah, that's not even close to the same thing.

[JarJarDrinks]

Yeah, that's not even close to the same thing.

True, there may be reasonable explanation to someone holding the weapon.

[Creature]

I considered PP an equally bad lynch.

So...

- You townread 2 people
- one is claiming doc and one is claiming VT
- You think they both equally a bad lynch

Are any of the above points incorrect?

- I had more townreads, but yeah, didn't like any of the two wagons. My townread on PP felt stronger than Wheme (who mostly relied on doc claim).
- Sure.
- PP likely wasn't gonna be wagoned anymore, while Wheme might still be pushed next day.

[Creature]

Oh, we completely forgot about D1 where I was hard whiteknighting osuka and then he died the moment I softened up.

[Creature]

Yeah no, that "he defended Wheme" is shit

[Creature]

Oh yay, Tchill is town.

So is Creature.

What the fuck.

Do people not actually read Creature posts?

Someone needs to link me to a scum-Creature game. All game people have been saying his scum game is obvious. And if it's somehow more obvious than this game, I have to see this for myself.

My scum game can be boiled down to "no hard stances, just hop into whatever comes", which is completely contradictory to this game.

[JarJarDrinks]

Creature

is Scum

Lets look at all the scummy Creature Posts from the EOD wagon (this could take a while):

damn we're so screwed

I thought town could pull a scum lynch without me

also not surprised you'd try to lynch a doc

These are ATE attempts to make the town which was all excited about lynching scum doubt the wagon:

Is it too late for CFDs?

Desperate attempt to derail the wagon:

why is the claim sketchy? Then I hammer

Why would he hammer after he made the above posts? He just said he beleived the doc claim.

Oh and he certainly didnt hammer after the sketchy claim was explained to him. He very much tried and tried to do ANYTHING besides hammer wheme.

speaking of explaining why the claim was sketchy, heres his post after I did so here:

Spoiler:

for on thing, he was around purposefully avoiding the claim until as late as possible. Like he was at L-1 and were waiiting all day and he he shows up and is like "naw nobody posted intent" then intent was posted and he was all "ok but u gotta wait a few hours".

thought you had one more argument other than "took long to claim"

Trying to minimize what I wrote as "took too long"

I feel like we're probably mislynching today anyway, but not sure if I should just have scum kill me and then steamroll town for the rest of the game when town will have no clear leadership

Bwaaahaaahahhhahaa. WTF is this supposed to even mean? Is he saying that he's considering forcing a no-lynch which would make scum NK him? Whatever he's saying it makes absolutely no sense.

there's rn GR, you and me

maybe if we get plenty of more players around I can entertain a CFD

lol @ maybe I can entertain a CFD. As if he wasnt the person who suggested it.

If we hit scum most likely the wagon won't go through but then we just see who had the chance to hop him yet didn't then we can catch half of the scumteam

him talking about the CFD that I guess he decided to "entertain".

I feel like we're probably mislynching today anyway, but not sure if I should just have scum kill me and then steamroll town for the rest of the game when town will have no clear leadership

town does have clear leadership, we have masons and IC

yet we're still lynching a doctor claim

He just told us above he was about to hammer

Yeh, TehBrawlGuy looks bad

so does texcat

Same as his reads today. no reevaluation after the flip.

All wheme has been is survivalistic. He didnt give the town a reads list, didnt say "lynch X after I flip". He claimed doc cuz he thought it was the best chance of not getting roped.

Sadly this kind is common on MS

Defending whemes play.

I likely count as 4th conftown and probably the best nightkill considering the other three conftowns are all useless so let me do stuff today if we're gonna mislynch the doc claim

lol conftown OMG.

Did Vax do something?

Translation. I'm not supposed to be have been paying attention the last week so I'd like someone else to bring up the fake vig claim so I can try to wagon vax

We lynched Performer for nothing

some ATE to make the town doubt the wagon.

I may be even-night vigilante and I intend to vig Pine tonight

For mafia doctors

Hey guys why didnt anybody reply to my vax question?

JJD, GR, Wheme, Gamma and me

Maybe we can pull a CFD?

Leaving a list of good CFDs:
TehBrawlGuy
texcat
Scioness Sajj
Pine

Mmm Hmmm

Oh I forgot about Vax

Nvm, he's really the deepwolf

Lets keep bringing up Vax and hope someone mentions the vig thing.

because definitely Pine won't let me live for tomorrow

WTF is this shit?

I'm probably going to end lynching Wheme anyway because PP is also a terrible mislynch

Why is Wheme (claimed doc) better than PP (claimed VT)? He tried explaining this w/ something about Wheme getting pushed the next day. Horrible

Scum, don't kill me if you don't want to lose the game.

just dumb and pointless. There's no way creature worries about a NK w/ several outed PRs.

would be disappointing to have posted the entire scumteam on the thread, find out we mislynched the doc and afterwards town completely ignore me

more ATE nonsense

tbh Wheme and PP should like be cleared based on scum having dominance

more trying to convince town the lynch is bad.

still I may want to keep KK alive for a while to ensure my survival

If anyone is buying any of this contrived nonsense quit mafia ur terrible.

VOTE: WhemeStar

Hopefully scum spares me expecting me to get prodded again

So he ended up hammerring a doc claim that he beleived was completely legit.


This may be the most slam dunk case I've ever seen.


VOTE: creature

[JarJarDrinks]

Scumreads in order:

Creature > Dunnstral > Scioness Sajj > Ankamius > Lalendra

[Vaxkiller]

I dunno. My reflex was to think he was scum for mentioning me with no reasons, but I really liked his end of day yesterday. It's kinda cryptic and seems townie to me.

[Vaxkiller]

Yeah, dude re-read that stuff from yesterday creature posted. Who does that as scum, he looks like town with a plan.

Not supporting this creature brigade.

[JarJarDrinks]

Yeah, dude re-read that stuff from yesterday creature posted. Who does that as scum, he looks like town with a plan.

Not supporting this creature brigade.

WHat was the plan?

[JarJarDrinks]

I really liked his end of day yesterday

Spoiler:

[Creature]

Why would he hammer after he made the above posts? He just said he beleived the doc claim.

If you had something like "his predecessor claimed VT" or something that made this claim look unbelievable, then I'd change my mind.

[Creature]

Oh and he certainly didnt hammer after the sketchy claim was explained to him. He very much tried and tried to do ANYTHING besides hammer wheme.

It wasn't enough.

[Creature]

Trying to minimize what I wrote as "took too long"

3337 is pretty much it