Mafiascum.net

i'm just arguing with myself against every other elimination and i don't really think Mena is scum either.
also come to think of it skitter and others are on v/la but should hopefully be back soon.

pedit: i've thought some stuff from you was town (reaction to Norwee and Luca's votes in particular, also your early game), but Norwee has more moments like that and i'm generally more confident about the read, he's felt very good when i've talked to him in spite of Luca's read, who i townread strongly. generally i've been trying to see him as scum but i think he only is in a specific scenario with Day.

pedit: maybe? a lot of teams make sense, i'm not great with team comps even with actual flips to go off of. but i don't see why skitter would be scum.

In post 3623, Luca Blight wrote:Norwee is a decent bet. I disagree with Chara that him not reading the day stuff was townie, but his AtE felt a little townie

not the not reading specifically but how he reacted when prodded about it.

VOTE: Day
i can't make up my mind right now, i'll come back.

Think l’ll leave my vote where it is for now.

Wouldn’t mind limming Ali but I really don’t know how to read em

These are theoretical teams roughly ordered by likelihood with most likely at the top

I think a big point for me is whether norwee/Fark are scum, and separately whether ali is scum

I don’t really read ali/Fark as non-aligned with one another, and think what there has been between them is very readable as distancing

I think if norwee/Fark are just playing badly then my ali-centric teams come into focus, and something like (ali, ydra, +1-but-probably-chara) make sense

And if ali is also town then Ali’s scumteam proposals sound p good to me

With outside chances of skitt/luca who are setting up v hard to be on the right side of the my flip

Or pooky/day where day was scum all along and pooky is running a big play to save him

Chara day is never being limmed. Pooky seems very sure his role means Day is Town and I’m inclined to believe that for now at least

Likewise, for now

i know, i was going to just unvote for the moment but i thought i'd rather be on Day than not have a vote in.

Chara and Menalque are my two biggest TR’s rn so it would be good if we could agree on something

Norwee, Ali, Ydrasse - these are the three I'm considering

i’m on norwee, so

In post 3628, Luca Blight wrote:Think l’ll leave my vote where it is for now.

Wouldn’t mind limming Ali but I really don’t know how to read em

i can kind of read Ali but not on day 1. i would be okay eliminating em with how things are, though. i think e's play looks similar here regardless of eir alignment.

pedit: i will think about these three today and come back a little later.

Menalque’s obvtown based on recent posts alone

In post 3625, Chara wrote:but Norwee has more moments like that and i'm generally more confident about the read, he's felt very good when i've talked to him

Okay

Pick out the posts that he’s made that make you feel better about him than me and explain why

Pick out the posts where you’ve interacted with him and explain why they “felt very good”

In post 3633, Luca Blight wrote:Chara

Что!?

In post 3635, Ydrasse wrote:i’m on norwee, so

kinda feels like ur setting up to vote me tho

In post 3542, Alisae wrote:It's wrong because I'm town and Ydra is town.
SS is scum tho :D

I think ali is (probably?) town but i strongly dislike eir readalist on the prior page to the point i makes me wonder how ey're even approaching this thread

I'm almost at the point where i'm willing to compromise on mena (sorry)

i would have already voted you

ripping off bandaid

ali is reading me correctly but idr why

In post 3581, Luca Blight wrote:The only player who defended him was Skitter, and she could have done that as either alignment so it doesn’t help a lot

But he doesnt flip scum, just noting that

In post 3607, Menalque wrote:

@skitter you’re the only one I have any faith in to actually remember stuff on future days, so please do actually remember what I’m saying here

Ali’s push is v bad, but doesn’t necessarily make er scum

And the wagon has been pushed almost exclusively by those I’ve called scum which is making me think there’s actually quite a good chance I’m right, granted how persistent the attempt to lim me has been

Yes i'm aligned with this ^

In post 3642, skitter30 wrote:I'm almost at the point where i'm willing to compromise on mena (sorry)

y

In post 3622, Menalque wrote:(Fark, norwee, ali)
(Fark, ali, ydra)
(Fark, norwee, day)
(Ali, ydra, Chara)
(PP, S_S, Chara)
(PP, S_S, ydra)
(Pooky, day, X)
(Luca, skitt, X)

These are the teams you tuink most likely?
Like to recap your scumpool is: fark, norwee, luca, maybe ali, and then you start throwing in other names on the periphery

I’m no expert but when multiple people are going “well I think X is town but I guess I’ll vote them” maybe consider that you’ve gone wrong somewhere

In post 3646, Menalque wrote:

In post 3642, skitter30 wrote:I'm almost at the point where i'm willing to compromise on mena (sorry)

y

Sorry i'll followup tonight, i gotta get back to work

I'm very aware that we're going wrong somewhere

Fwiw i dont think luca is scum
I'm realizing i can see chara-scum too tbh

I'll bbl