also, there could have been a useful night action that we either didn't learn or didn't matter because the target was dead.
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 4:04 pm
by Lukewarm
My super paranoia brain's thoughts
Spoiler:
What if wheme fake claimed Shiro after seeing Cabd's claim in order to get the clear.
He keeps making posts that keep bringing that thought up.
Like the fact that when he was asked if he was shiro or sora, instead of just answering, he first read back to figure out why the question was asked. 3543
And that he instantly went into "I should be locktown now" mode with 3544 which did not feel like the way I would have thought about it. Like, my first thoughts would be on what that meant about Cabd instead of how it made me look I think?
And then the repeatedly going with the line that he can only be scum with cabd, 3595, 3605, 3614, 3618.
And that the "oh look, I am lock town" and the "Now I can only be scum with cabd" on repeat both came before he stopped to think about what it meant for cabd alignment, that did not come until 3607. And also, the leap from "cabd knows I am town" to "this means that cabd is lock town from my pov" is a bit dubious
But them my rational brain steps in, and tells me that it does not work, because it does fit with cabd's claim, and for that to be the world we live in, cabd just has a completely meme/red herring role.
So. I am not pushing my paranoia thoughts, but they are in the thread for the post game if I was right somehow
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 4:16 pm
by Lukewarm
Out side of the paranoia brain, because this works with or with out scum cabd.
One of my issues, is why did wheme just jump to "cabd is lock town" ? Where was the town paranoia in a game where so many town flips just happened? And they were also
all
of Cabd's scum reads flipping town?
Wasn't he just loudly touting the "sheep cabd, if he is wrong he is scum" line over and over yesterday?
But there was no paranoia, even though cabd's claim, while from a cabd pov makes wheme town, does not work in reverse.
Why would town!Wheme not be considering the scum!cabd possibility x.x
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 4:30 pm
by WhemeStar
Idk I don’t see how his role is scum unless he made up the lie about assisting me
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 4:31 pm
by WhemeStar
In post 3627, Lukewarm wrote:Out side of the paranoia brain, because this works with or with out scum cabd.
One of my issues, is why did wheme just jump to "cabd is lock town" ? Where was the town paranoia in a game where so many town flips just happened? And they were also
all
of Cabd's scum reads flipping town?
Wasn't he just loudly touting the "sheep cabd, if he is wrong he is scum" line over and over yesterday?
But there was no paranoia, even though cabd's claim, while from a cabd pov makes wheme town, does not work in reverse.
Why would town!Wheme not be considering the scum!cabd possibility x.x
What if wheme fake claimed Shiro after seeing Cabd's claim in order to get the clear.
He keeps making posts that keep bringing that thought up.
Like the fact that when he was asked if he was shiro or sora, instead of just answering, he first read back to figure out why the question was asked. 3543
And that he instantly went into "I should be locktown now" mode with 3544 which did not feel like the way I would have thought about it. Like, my first thoughts would be on what that meant about Cabd instead of how it made me look I think?
And then the repeatedly going with the line that he can only be scum with cabd, 3595, 3605, 3614, 3618.
And that the "oh look, I am lock town" and the "Now I can only be scum with cabd" on repeat both came before he stopped to think about what it meant for cabd alignment, that did not come until 3607. And also, the leap from "cabd knows I am town" to "this means that cabd is lock town from my pov" is a bit dubious
But them my rational brain steps in, and tells me that it does not work, because it does fit with cabd's claim, and for that to be the world we live in, cabd just has a completely meme/red herring role.
So. I am not pushing my paranoia thoughts, but they are in the thread for the post game if I was right somehow
This post has a lot of flaws in it that I’ll get too after I’m done working and not phone posting
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 4:33 pm
by Lukewarm
Literally all scum!cabd would have needed to make that claim is to know that there was a shiro and/or sora in the game...
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 4:55 pm
by Kate Bishop
Hey Luke, you around?
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 5:18 pm
by Lukewarm
Whats up?
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 5:21 pm
by Kate Bishop
What’s your POE looking like?
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 5:28 pm
by Lukewarm
I definitely don't want Dunn or LLD.
You, Kyoko, and Cabd are kinda in the middle.
And then I am scum reading Wheme and Gamma.
I am trying to figure out my thoughts on Wheme and Gamma, because my thoughts on both are pretty strong, but I think that it is just one of the two, not both. And then work out from there.
However, the thread will not be opening yet. In addition to the normal elimination, which will immediately follow this interlude, all living players may vote to eliminate another player via PM sent to me.
I will tally the votes either in
(expired on 2021-09-13 23:00:00)
or when all players have responded. This vote is via PM, but it will not be anonymous. All PTs are locked for this duration.
VC2.0
Player
Votes
Voters
ManateeGal
1
Accusation from Beyond
Not Voting
---
Dunnstral, ssbm_Kyouko, WhemeStar, ManateeGal, Cabd, Lady Lambdadelta, Kate Bishop, Lukewarm, Gamma Emerald
There are 9 alive. The player with the most votes will be eliminated, unless No Elimination is selected. In the case of a tie, whichever of the tieing wagons reached the highest number first will be eliminated.
Oh, and this may be due to me inheriting a part of dgb's role unless somebody else wants to claim it. I am not certain on that.
My favored lim right now is Gamma. Cabd is up there too. LLD is not. In case that wasn't apparent.
I caught the same softs you saw on day 1.
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 6:25 pm
by Lukewarm
In post 3639, Dunnstral wrote:Oh, and this may be due to me inheriting a part of dgb's role unless somebody else wants to claim it. I am not certain on that.
You were able to submit an action from DGB's ability?
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 6:26 pm
by Lukewarm
I have another theory about the extra elim, but I will hold for the mass claim. If I am right, it should come out then
In post 3639, Dunnstral wrote:Oh, and this may be due to me inheriting a part of dgb's role unless somebody else wants to claim it. I am not certain on that.
You were able to submit an action from DGB's ability?
Dunn, I would like clarification on this, and what lead you to think you could be responsible for the double vote
In post 3639, Dunnstral wrote:Oh, and this may be due to me inheriting a part of dgb's role unless somebody else wants to claim it. I am not certain on that.
You were able to submit an action from DGB's ability?
No, but it's something that happened during the day, I'm not sure if it's a passive ability I carried into day 2
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 6:41 pm
by WhemeStar
This game is so confusing holy
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 6:41 pm
by Dunnstral
Hold on, I'd have to select it during the night, so no it wasn't me.
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 7:20 pm
by Gamma Emerald
I just posted a biggol thing to my GTKAS threads for anyone who cares to see just what sort of a state I’m in.
Now to catch up on what the hell is happening.
Told my dad about some of what was happening, he suggested I tune out for a bit
Posted: Mon Sep 13, 2021 7:26 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 3504, Kate Bishop wrote:While I work on this, everyone should feel free to review how Gamma has handled us and Cabd today despite both of us being given the "You Tenet You Die" read at the start of the game!
I'm finding the chart, standby.
Cabd had been taken out of the box, you were not. This is gross misrepresentation of the highest degree.
