Thanks, and I won't assume it's right. It's probably close and that's good enough for now.
Agree with wagons on Wooper, Rautherdir, DD, and Vorkuta.
Strong disagree with TSE wagon. I can't fathom a reason for non-town to reveal that ability, even as a fakeclaim. The people who have an "awkward player" read on TSE are correct but I don't think it's AI.
Still maintain that the Amrun posts that I pointed out are town indicative. It isn't strong, but I'm gonna want to hear something rational behind the scumreads before I'd be willing to vote there.
I think Creature and Gamma are town. Not willing to vote either of them at this point. The rest of the votes are baseless as far as I remember.
There pretty much have to be scum who aren't being voted, but gotta find 'em before I can vote 'em.
VOTE: Vorkuta
Let's squeeze this one and see if it talks.
I'm flexible. Give me a reason.
First there's your simplistic understanding of mafia and how you think you get "confirmed town" if you claim/demonstrate an ability (hint: this is not how mafia works)
Second you keep sizing yourself up. "Oh I was on TOS and I was calling a dude scum, why do you play so bad/not listen to me all the time??" Like I dunno why we should be expected to BOP you/treat you as god tier?
Never said I was confirmed Town just that I have a confirmable Ability.
Never said I wanted to be treated God Tier I just want to be given a chance.
Ok I'm mafia goon and my confirmable ability is I can night kill people, let me confirm it before lynching me you boomers.
First there's your simplistic understanding of mafia and how you think you get "confirmed town" if you claim/demonstrate an ability (hint: this is not how mafia works)
Second you keep sizing yourself up. "Oh I was on TOS and I was calling a dude scum, why do you play so bad/not listen to me all the time??" Like I dunno why we should be expected to BOP you/treat you as god tier?
Never said I was confirmed Town just that I have a confirmable Ability.
Never said I wanted to be treated God Tier I just want to be given a chance.
Also it doesn't come across that way when you keep espousing how good your reads are. I don't think you realize you're doing that either.
Thanks, and I won't assume it's right. It's probably close and that's good enough for now.
Agree with wagons on Wooper, Rautherdir, DD, and Vorkuta.
Strong disagree with TSE wagon. I can't fathom a reason for non-town to reveal that ability, even as a fakeclaim. The people who have an "awkward player" read on TSE are correct but I don't think it's AI.
Still maintain that the Amrun posts that I pointed out are town indicative. It isn't strong, but I'm gonna want to hear something rational behind the scumreads before I'd be willing to vote there.
I think Creature and Gamma are town. Not willing to vote either of them at this point. The rest of the votes are baseless as far as I remember.
There pretty much have to be scum who aren't being voted, but gotta find 'em before I can vote 'em.
VOTE: Vorkuta
Let's squeeze this one and see if it talks.
I'm flexible. Give me a reason.
TSE would be likely to claim it as non-town, soooo...
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:28 am
by chennisden
It really doesn't mean anything that he's claimed it
I’m honestly not surprised that both You and Chemist vote me.
Funny enough I think you forgot you never actually scum read me, Chemist did.
Thanks for admitting your buddies with Chemist!
/Vote Chen
I'm capable of keeping track of my reads as both alignments so like, assuming I forgot I didn't scumread you instead of, you know, me scumreading you but being too lazy to say anything is really bonkers
I’m honestly not surprised that both You and Chemist vote me.
Funny enough I think you forgot you never actually scum read me, Chemist did.
Thanks for admitting your buddies with Chemist!
/Vote Chen
Sigh.
TSE is silly let's kill vorkuta instead
Yeah you're right TSE might just be town because, well, it's TSE
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:32 am
by Bingle
In post 3649, Korina wrote:Ok, that still doesn't help the fact I have 50 pages to read, plus my phone screen got cracked through my case, so I have to get it fixed, plus I have a doctors appointment today.
pedit: I'll look at Vork's iso later, since I seem to always disagree on scumreads on Vork when I'm playing with them.
The joint ISO of me/Nero from my reads wall until the functional beginning of the game isn't a bad place to start either.
Vorks ISO is roughly: I want to be governor because I want to roleplay being soviet Russia. He's done literally nothing else, AFAICT, and avoided the discussion on whether governor itself was protown entirely.
Thanks, and I won't assume it's right. It's probably close and that's good enough for now.
Agree with wagons on Wooper, Rautherdir, DD, and Vorkuta.
Strong disagree with TSE wagon. I can't fathom a reason for non-town to reveal that ability, even as a fakeclaim. The people who have an "awkward player" read on TSE are correct but I don't think it's AI.
Still maintain that the Amrun posts that I pointed out are town indicative. It isn't strong, but I'm gonna want to hear something rational behind the scumreads before I'd be willing to vote there.
I think Creature and Gamma are town. Not willing to vote either of them at this point. The rest of the votes are baseless as far as I remember.
There pretty much have to be scum who aren't being voted, but gotta find 'em before I can vote 'em.
VOTE: Vorkuta
Let's squeeze this one and see if it talks.
I'm flexible. Give me a reason.
TSE would be likely to claim it as non-town, soooo...
Do you have experience with TSE? I’ve been seriously debating between noobflail and scum. Do you think he is scum, then? Or why?
In post 3649, Korina wrote:Ok, that still doesn't help the fact I have 50 pages to read, plus my phone screen got cracked through my case, so I have to get it fixed, plus I have a doctors appointment today.
pedit: I'll look at Vork's iso later, since I seem to always disagree on scumreads on Vork when I'm playing with them.
The joint ISO of me/Nero from my reads wall until the functional beginning of the game isn't a bad place to start either.
Vorks ISO is roughly: I want to be governor because I want to roleplay being soviet Russia. He's done literally nothing else, AFAICT, and avoided the discussion on whether governor itself was protown entirely.
Vorkuta is clearly useless, but I have yet to see a convincing argument of why he is scum. Personally I’m totally null on that slot.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:39 am
by Bingle
In post 3650, davesaz wrote:Agree with wagons on Wooper, Rautherdir, DD, and Vorkuta.
Strong disagree with TSE wagon. I can't fathom a reason for non-town to reveal that ability, even as a fakeclaim. The people who have an "awkward player" read on TSE are correct but I don't think it's AI.
Still maintain that the Amrun posts that I pointed out are town indicative. It isn't strong, but I'm gonna want to hear something rational behind the scumreads before I'd be willing to vote there.
I think Creature and Gamma are town. Not willing to vote either of them at this point. The rest of the votes are baseless as far as I remember.
There pretty much have to be scum who aren't being voted, but gotta find 'em before I can vote 'em.
VOTE: Vorkuta
Let's squeeze this one and see if it talks.
I'm flexible. Give me a reason.
Vaguely agree with most of this, which gives good tingles.
I don't think the amrun quotes from you are particularly town, but given that the scumreads there are /is being very political/ and /is playing like an oldschool player/ it's not a high priority slot imo anyway. At the very least she's actively playing.
TSE's role isn't /NEVER LYNCH THIS IS TOWN/ but I definitely want to use it today to not have to get 21 votes, so...
I think hunting out new prospective wagons is a bad use of today, given that there are 40 people. Sure, there's scum outside of the group that's being voted. Consolidating on what already has support seems like a better choice, given that there's so much that I wouldn't mind seeing lynched.
Thanks, and I won't assume it's right. It's probably close and that's good enough for now.
Agree with wagons on Wooper, Rautherdir, DD, and Vorkuta.
Strong disagree with TSE wagon. I can't fathom a reason for non-town to reveal that ability, even as a fakeclaim. The people who have an "awkward player" read on TSE are correct but I don't think it's AI.
Still maintain that the Amrun posts that I pointed out are town indicative. It isn't strong, but I'm gonna want to hear something rational behind the scumreads before I'd be willing to vote there.
I think Creature and Gamma are town. Not willing to vote either of them at this point. The rest of the votes are baseless as far as I remember.
There pretty much have to be scum who aren't being voted, but gotta find 'em before I can vote 'em.
VOTE: Vorkuta
Let's squeeze this one and see if it talks.
I'm flexible. Give me a reason.
TSE would be likely to claim it as non-town, soooo...
Do you have experience with TSE? I’ve been seriously debating between noobflail and scum. Do you think he is scum, then? Or why?
Im gonna be honest it's "I think scum, but if this is noobflail I don't actually give a fuck, so I didn't actually check my work."
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:41 am
by chennisden
Like you know when you take a 5th grade math test... and you think the answer is something but like you really don't care if it's wrong
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:42 am
by Bingle
Feel pretty confident adding chenn to the townbloc rn.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:44 am
by Amrun
Chenni: yeah .... kinda same. Haha. I was hoping someone who knew him better might be able to differentiate. There is something very genuine about his flail but IMO noobflails happen a LOT more to noobscum.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:45 am
by chennisden
Also amrun i think ur town now, sorry for rando voting you at the beginning of D1
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:46 am
by Bingle
Townbloc in no particular order:
Bingle
FF
Chen
NC
BB
Gobble* (Mech based)
Mena
Ceph
dave
EP
Not really a locktown block, but definitely worth operational status for the day.
Close but not really worth being in the list yet would be GE/Creat/FB/FL
Ceph has what looks like the most real of the PRs, and has been actively solvey with 100% of his posts anyway. In addition, he's not really being agenda-y and his pop ins have all been relevant. He's not trying to take charge like in either the scumgame he had in AliPine or Fogport. I don't have a recent towngame for comparison, but I'm confident enough there for the moment.
EP has been bleeding newbtown vibes recently.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 9:53 am
by Firebringer
Is amrun catch phrase gonna be “your useless”
Seen her call 3 people that.
