Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:34 am
lolIn post 3649, Something_Smart wrote:Up to what? Claim? Why?In post 3643, OkaPoka wrote:ss and alchemist ur up
Mafiascum.net
https://forum.mafiascum-staging.net/
mini 2126: the game is OVRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Page 147 of 225
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:36 am
finding and lynching scum is, IMO, more important than "projecting town" I mean, defending yourself is p alignment null. Since I've replaced in I haven't seen Eddie doing any game solving and I'm much more interested in who his current solve is than him telling us he's town.
What did he claim, btw?
What did he claim, btw?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:37 am
In post 3625, Eddie Cane wrote:I'm obviously VT
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:38 am
I mean I see "projecting town" as more than just self-defense and rather the process of getting people to townread you. This significantly helps town find and lynch scum.In post 3651, Nero Cain wrote:finding and lynching scum is, IMO, more important than "projecting town" I mean, defending yourself is p alignment null.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:45 am
eh...you aren't totally wrong. I mean, town correctly town reading each other
DOES
help a tad but that still seems like a secondary objective to me and if you are scum hunting and active you are more times than not going to come off as town anways.Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:46 am
Who does Eddie think the 3 scum are?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:55 am
I could easily see comical hard defend idany and eddie not hammer him as both designed to be red herrings but he's unconfirmed and I ultimately don't care that much.
intent to hammer
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:05 am
While I think Dany totally deserves the lynch for not caring about the game I really can't see who his buddies be, earlier and moreso now.
I think Comical is ++town.
Eddie/iDan equity is low. Eddie's posting to defend himself as he gets pressured, why would he not do something when his partner is?
It's weird to associate them for not hammering, because it's wired to assume it's +likely he would lolhammer twice in a row.
I think Comical is ++town.
Eddie/iDan equity is low. Eddie's posting to defend himself as he gets pressured, why would he not do something when his partner is?
It's weird to associate them for not hammering, because it's wired to assume it's +likely he would lolhammer twice in a row.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:07 am
It's decently possible {Nero, Alch, NSG} are exactly the scumteam and feel free to point out evidence against it. All three have individual scum equity. No one participated in a serious wagon on the other two
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:07 am
?????In post 3657, Auro wrote:why would he not do something when his partner is?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:08 am
When his partner's getting lynched.In post 3659, Nero Cain wrote:?????In post 3657, Auro wrote:why would he not do something when his partner is?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:12 am
??????In post 3660, Auro wrote:When his partner's getting lynched.In post 3659, Nero Cain wrote:?????In post 3657, Auro wrote:why would he not do something when his partner is?
IF
If idany and Eddie are scum together then...Eddie defending himself is null, I guess. I don't really understand the point.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:31 am
In post 3651, Nero Cain wrote:finding and lynching scum is, IMO, more important than "projecting town" I mean, defending yourself is p alignment null. Since I've replaced in I haven't seen Eddie doing any game solving and I'm much more interested in who his current solve is than him telling us he's town.
What did he claim, btw?
I'm sorry dude, but you're just wrong.In post 3654, Nero Cain wrote:eh...you aren't totally wrong. I mean, town correctly town reading each otherDOEShelp a tad but that still seems like a secondary objective to me and if you are scum hunting and active you are more times than not going to come off as town anways.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:36 am
I'm sorry, but your posting makes it evident you don't understand mafia very well. Which is fine! This is a game we play for fun! Most people don't really get how to play properly, its no slight against you.In post 3661, Nero Cain wrote:??????In post 3660, Auro wrote:When his partner's getting lynched.In post 3659, Nero Cain wrote:?????In post 3657, Auro wrote:why would he not do something when his partner is?
IF
If idany and Eddie are scum together then...Eddie defending himself is null, I guess. I don't really understand the point.
Eddie "defending himself" is null, sure. Eddie would defend himself as either alignment. It is literally just creating content for you to sort. You have to look at the actual defense yourself and come to an opinion on my alignment, not just dismiss it as self defense = null.
For your specific point, Auro is correct. If I am scum with Dany, then I am defending myself, shading him, and not attempting to push the lynch on anybody else while simultaneously not trying to get credit off of his flip. It does not make sense for us to be partners with the gamestate. Its about viewing the gamestate, my independent comments towards/about him do not clear us being partners.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:37 am
UNVOTE:
Back to thinking Eddie and Oka are both Town.
Btw @Nero, Eddie is correct that Town should project Towniness.
Back to thinking Eddie and Oka are both Town.
Btw @Nero, Eddie is correct that Town should project Towniness.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:40 am
If you want to see my solving, Nero, I am voting Alchemist and deadline is near. I also pointed out his logical inconsistencies, and I am voting with the towniest player in the game. I very strongly believe sharing all of your reads at all times is both less fun and worse for town. And considering you have not read most of the game, I do not care about your solves. I think you could very well be scum (you don't seem to be as upset as a town cop-type role should be at getting pretty widely scum read, imo), but I am not pushing you today either. And your solve with me (Auro + Boon) is less terrible than Oka's (Eddie + Alch) and Alch's (Eddie + Oka), for example.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:41 am
This game is getting more interesting.In post 3664, Alchemist21 wrote:UNVOTE:
Back to thinking Eddie and Oka are both Town.
Btw @Nero, Eddie is correct that Town should project Towniness.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 10:49 am
I'm not exactly saying that town shouldn't but I think town that are town will mostly look town as the game goes along and scum are the ones that really need to try to look town. But it's not a super important point so w/e.In post 3664, Alchemist21 wrote:Btw @Nero, Eddie is correct that Town should project Towniness.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 11:05 am
I was pushing for Dannflor’s lynch until NSG replaced him.In post 3658, Auro wrote:It's decently possible {Nero, Alch, NSG} are exactly the scumteam and feel free to point out evidence against it. All three have individual scum equity. No one participated in a serious wagon on the other two
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 11:09 am
I’m VT btw. Thought that would be obvious at this point.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 1:28 pm
I want to plainly state I do not think NSG has been townie.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 2:06 pm
What’s better than catching ScumNSG?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 2:10 pm
Good post, Eddie.
“Our general agreements were that tracking votes was more important than tracking win/loss”
I vote town reads on purpose sometimes so i don’t really like this.
“Our general agreements were that tracking votes was more important than tracking win/loss”
I vote town reads on purpose sometimes so i don’t really like this.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 2:13 pm
But yeah, NSG is clearly scum based on the tether between her and I. If she were town’d she’d have faught back at me harder.
@Alchemist - you brought up she doesn’t have a presence as scum? She has literally zero presence against me in Comical vs NSG. She has a presence to you because she needed you to town read her.
She’s literally doing her scumMeta now. She temporarily broke meta so she wouldn’t get scumread but she has a hard time faking it now that I have a legit scum read on her.
I believe Alchemist is pocketed town here.
HOWEVER, it is worth noting, that Alchemist HAS been scum and town read me HARD when I was town, almost to a detriment in the hopes that would be the reason he is town read.
I still think Alch is likely town.
Idany is a mislynch there to save NSG, and has been for a while.
Dannfloor was being pushed prior to NSG replace one, and I pushed NSG as soon as they replaced in.
@Alchemist - you brought up she doesn’t have a presence as scum? She has literally zero presence against me in Comical vs NSG. She has a presence to you because she needed you to town read her.
She’s literally doing her scumMeta now. She temporarily broke meta so she wouldn’t get scumread but she has a hard time faking it now that I have a legit scum read on her.
I believe Alchemist is pocketed town here.
HOWEVER, it is worth noting, that Alchemist HAS been scum and town read me HARD when I was town, almost to a detriment in the hopes that would be the reason he is town read.
I still think Alch is likely town.
Idany is a mislynch there to save NSG, and has been for a while.
Dannfloor was being pushed prior to NSG replace one, and I pushed NSG as soon as they replaced in.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 2:14 pm
That’s an Occam’s Razor solve, but I actually feel like it’s possible NSG is the only scum here.In post 3658, Auro wrote:It's decently possible {Nero, Alch, NSG} are exactly the scumteam and feel free to point out evidence against it. All three have individual scum equity. No one participated in a serious wagon on the other two
Unfortunately, this raises an NSG/Auro team by a lot, especially if Auro switches off NSG.