Mafiascum.net

I tried to prove myself.

I should at least be given the chance to prove myself until we're at LYLO.

i mean, we are lynching me today and you tomorrow will be lylo with two scums sooo

you are getting your wish

Why do you think there are two scum?

And why are we lynching you?

i can't write

i mean, we are lynching me today and

you

tomorrow will be lylo with two scums sooo

Why'd you shoot GIF?

In post 3702, Shoshin wrote:Why do you think there are two scum?

And why are we lynching you?

idk it was always assumed to be 4-11 not 3-12. 3 scum would be nice surprise but i'm not going to be optimistic

too many players cosplaying village idiots right now

well there is wagon on me, and if we are not lynching me we are lynching you

i'm having a feeling you are looking for towncred shoshin

didn't want to shoot the most scumread people, wanted someone low activity and somehow scummy

Well, then, this game is going to be lost.

If you're town, Sajj, you should be looking at the people trying to lynch you, not the ones trying to figure this out.

the thing is i don't think it is mechanically possible for us to share alignment.

Why not?

You think if I'm town I should lynch you?

makes no sense for us to be scum together, makes no sense for both you and wisdom to be town. so the worst case scenario it is actually wisdom and not you.

if you are town your objectives in this game are to find and lynch scum to the best of your ability.

You're telling me I should be lynching you...

I hate this line of thinking. The whole "it makes no sense for X mechanic" assumes knowledge of what roles the scum have when we just don't know.

If it's 4 scum, town would need a lot of power to counterbalance the numbers.

In post 3713, Shoshin wrote:I hate this line of thinking. The whole "it makes no sense for X mechanic" assumes knowledge of what roles the scum have when we just don't know.

both you and me are confirmed to have killing and protective ability respectively.

you even more so than i but if somebody else shoot gif and they still didn't say anything then welp

Yes, our roles are confirmed. That doesn't tell us anything about what mafia have...

If anything, Wisdom's role kinda makes sense as scum when combined with Chick's role.

Like, why would mafia care what anyone's flavor is, unless they had to find (or avoid shooting) specific players (e.g. Sarah?).

I think scum redirector opens possibility for scum to redirect the vig, hence why vig is limited to 1-shot. That makes sense.

Jailkeeper/enablers plus bodyguard plus macho cop is a very reasonable amount of protection for town to have. Jailkeeper can't protect without also blocking. Jailkeepr can be disabled by killing enabler. And bodyguard can't protect without dying in the process. On top of all that, nobody can protect the macho cop. And scum have a strongman.

You'd be crazy not to believe that town has this much protection in light of scum redirector, scum strongman, and a macho cop.

In post 3717, Shoshin wrote:If anything, Wisdom's role kinda makes sense as scum when combined with Chick's role.

wat

Just think about it for a second, Sajj. Why do scum have an identity cop?

In post 3720, Shoshin wrote:Jailkeeper/enablers plus bodyguard plus macho cop is a very reasonable amount of protection for town to have. Jailkeeper can't protect without also blocking. Jailkeepr can be disabled by killing enabler. And bodyguard can't protect without dying in the process. On top of all that, nobody can protect the macho cop. And scum have a strongman.

You'd be crazy not to believe that town has this much protection in light of scum redirector, scum strongman, and a macho cop.

forgot reviver

Reviver isn't protection though I wonder if redirector could theoretically cause scum to be revived?

Also, strongman is specifically about getting through jailkeeper and bodyguard.