Okay. Let's do this.
Angelic Nero (AKA, AANero, AKA, Nero Cangel9)--increasingly a strong townread. Though their play didn't start as I would expect a town-Nero/town-Angel to, their later posting is
exactly
what I'd expect from their town selves.
AngryPidgeon--the opposite. His play started all typical AP-town, but his later posting is reminiscent of his scum-self. He's not being obvtown. He's kinda in his scum-meta of just...being there. That said--I'd rather not go through the hoops with him on D1 about this. On d2, we can talk about this more.
ANG--very little of what ANG has said seems town, and overall, he seems to be scumposting like a champ. However, I am weary of most of the names on his bandwagon (all but Nero/Angel), along with how quickly it formed. Overall, this leaves him at nullish-scum.
Bitmap--very, VERY little content, though this might make him scum. As town, I seem to recall he was among the active posters in Posh Mafia, yet this game, he's barely posted at all. Not exactly a strong read, but nullish-scum overall.
Bork--I'll be honest, he's kinda a forgettable poster. I know he's posted a lot, but I kinda have trouble remembering he's even in the game. Reading him in iso, it looks like he's town, though, since he's definitely showing signs of thinking for himself and certainly not going with popular opinion (for instance--his doubting ANG-scum). Overall, nullish-town.
Colonel Guile (AKA, UberNinja-guille hydra)--given pretty much nothing this game. I guess they could be town; I'd sort-of expect a scum-UN/guile to try and establish towncred early-on and cruise later-game, which is kinda UN's scum-MO; they're not doing so.
But then again, they're pretty much not giving anything, which has me worried. A lot. Ambivalent overall; I want UN to read and give me scum. He's an effective scumhunter when he puts his mind into the game.
CryoNudist--I'm pretty much with Slandaar, here; their posts scream scum to me.
GuyInFreezer--if this game is multiscum, he's scum. If this game isn't multiscum, he's town. Simple as that; we'll need a scumflip to tell for certain.
Jal--I have zero confidence in my ability to read her, but my read IS a scumread.
KoC--while I see the point that his posts aren't too hard to fake as scum, they still overall come across as being town, so he's a weak townread.
Mac--I liked his entrance and his overall posting feels town. He looks like he's scumhunting, he seems to be bringing good and unique opinions to the table, his thoughts kinda mirror my own at those points in the game, and basically an air of confidence and relaxation; he doesn't feel like he's worried. Soyeah, that's why he's a pretty decent townread of mine.
Majiffy--dude looks kinda bad, to be honest. Not as bad as AP does (and AP doesn't look too bad--see above), but still not great, either. I don't have confidence in my ability to read him, though.
Messiah--pretty decent scumread. Votes CryoNudist in the RVS (kinda looks like a RVS-vote-buddy), bandwagons ANG, general bad overall vibe to his posts that feel sheepish and parrotish, overall not seeming to actually be interested in scumhunting, a bit wishy-washy, white knighting The Goat, OMGUS'ing me, weak attack against MS Marangal, and overall just not seeming town.
MS Marangal--if AP is scum, 208 is all I'd need to lynch MS Marangal as a scumbuddy. Vice-versa, too, for if MS is scum. Little bit wishy-washy overall. Defends Jiffy as well, which is similar to AP. Overall doesn't seem to have actually done much scumhunting. Hasn't even placed a vote yet in the game. Basically, there's a whole lotta nothing, except for defending players. I don't see actual scumhunting.
Overall, nullish-scum. (More scum than null.)
PeregrineV--not many posts, but the posts he's got look town.
Piratecat--As I said, I've played with both players before, but I'm not too familiar with either their town or scum play. Overall, I'd say they do give off town vibes, though, so I'd place them as town.
Qwints--ambivalent. Entirely. He could be scum, because his posting's not hard to fake, he's kinda sheepish and bandwagoning, and not contributing much. But he could be town, because what content he
does
have seems good, with what looks like good reads and decent reasoning.
If you put a gun to my head, I'd call him town ('specially with all the null-scum I have already
), but I'm not ready to commit to that call.
Slandaar--this seems like his town-self, and I feel he's right on the money with CryoNudist.
The Goat--as covered earlier, I've been a bit on the fence with him. He seems more accustomed to this environment than he lets on to be, which is kinda scummish. However, his overall posting
does
read as town, so he gets a null-town read.
Those I haven't mentioned simply don't have content to be read one way or the other, and are therefore null.
I'll compile this list into a reads-list in a sec.
, You are 
, and UN's hydra is 
