Posted: Mon Aug 26, 2013 5:23 pm
I'm fine with Phok. Titus is the bigger threat, that's why I was making sure.
phok is scum, titus dies.In post 375, Bert wrote:I'm fine with Phok. Titus is the bigger threat, that's why I was making sure.
That post referred to phokthepolice, not Bert.In post 371, Nachomamma8 wrote:Bert isn't scum. Give me a scumteam that you can believe in with that knowledge in mind.In post 370, Titus wrote:I am thinking this guy is an epicly bad newbie but it seems like it's him or no lynch. This doesn't read newbie scum though. I will hammer when I leave to go to bed. I won't be back before then and we need a day 1 lynch.
I am fine with this. If fuck flips scum, we have a mislynch on me. I wouldn't be thrilled with it but the town wouldn't be able to trust me.In post 377, Nachomamma8 wrote:phok is scum, titus dies.In post 375, Bert wrote:I'm fine with Phok. Titus is the bigger threat, that's why I was making sure.
phok is town, reanalyze.
bert isn't scum, try again.In post 378, Titus wrote:I know you don't like Bert as scum but he hasn't done anything that would distinguish himself from JKM other than repeatedly say he's town.
Hypothetically, Verbs and Brian Skies.In post 380, Nachomamma8 wrote:bert isn't scum, try again.In post 378, Titus wrote:I know you don't like Bert as scum but he hasn't done anything that would distinguish himself from JKM other than repeatedly say he's town.
if you need me to say this is a "hypothetical" then consider it said.
just because they are your two remaining suspects, or is there a logic to that?In post 384, Titus wrote:Hypothetically, Verbs and Brian Skies.
Nacho, this post by Titus sorta hints to me that Titus knows Phok will flip town. That's why I got second thoughts for a minute thereIn post 370, Titus wrote:I am thinking this guy is an epicly bad newbie but it seems like it's him or no lynch. This doesn't read newbie scum though. I will hammer when I leave to go to bed. I won't be back before then and we need a day 1 lynch.
i picked up on that too and it made me a bit afraid.In post 387, Bert wrote:Nacho, this post by Titus sorta hints to me that Titus knows Phok will flip town. That's why I got second thoughts for a minute thereIn post 370, Titus wrote:I am thinking this guy is an epicly bad newbie but it seems like it's him or no lynch. This doesn't read newbie scum though. I will hammer when I leave to go to bed. I won't be back before then and we need a day 1 lynch.
Titus this is your last mention of Brian. Why is Brian scum - what's the reasoning behind your scumread of him??In post 234, Titus wrote:I am really liking Flammus's recent posts. In particular his response to my 218 and 232. I like 218 because I sometimes can be very dismissive of behaviors when I feel there is no evidence there. It's a flaw that I do need to work on. 232 has a good chunk of theory but it also gives a decent explanation of how Flammus feels about the gambit and the theory cannot be separated from the explanation so it is excusable.
Brian's comments about both himself and Letters Garden seem to be coming from a place similar to my own, like I expected. I would cede the points I know must be ceded and he has done so before even being attacked for his perceived lack of inactivity. That being said, neither of the players seem that inactive to me, so Brian's argument is valid but not sound. I'm much more worried about Verbs's disappearing act.Mod, can we get a prod?
Shiidaji seems to have a set of expectations for normal and abnormal play. That might be a problem. I do proceed logically but I tend not to always follow social norms. I'm leaning town here.
@JKM, That was a pretty big overreaction to me giving a slight town read to M-M's slot if you never had any intention of getting M-M lynched.
Half a vouch, meaningless content.In post 322, Bert wrote:Hi everyone!
It is always darkest before dawn...
Let's find scum!
Image Redacted
Self vouch.In post 325, Bert wrote:I'm Bert and I've been on Amrun's replacement waiting list for a while now.
I was hoping to play scum against Nacho, but NOOOOOOOO.... I had to replace into a townslot where I cannot torment Nacho with my evil-tacular ways
GIF Redacted
Nothing in that post says Brian is town, just that we reached a pair of mutual reads. He hasn't posted at all with phok. My last post hadn't mentioned him and he hadn't generated new content in awhile. The last part makes me suspicious.In post 392, Bert wrote:Titus this is your last mention of Brian. Why is Brian scum - what's the reasoning behind your scumread of him??In post 234, Titus wrote:I am really liking Flammus's recent posts. In particular his response to my 218 and 232. I like 218 because I sometimes can be very dismissive of behaviors when I feel there is no evidence there. It's a flaw that I do need to work on. 232 has a good chunk of theory but it also gives a decent explanation of how Flammus feels about the gambit and the theory cannot be separated from the explanation so it is excusable.
Brian's comments about both himself and Letters Garden seem to be coming from a place similar to my own, like I expected. I would cede the points I know must be ceded and he has done so before even being attacked for his perceived lack of inactivity. That being said, neither of the players seem that inactive to me, so Brian's argument is valid but not sound. I'm much more worried about Verbs's disappearing act.Mod, can we get a prod?
Shiidaji seems to have a set of expectations for normal and abnormal play. That might be a problem. I do proceed logically but I tend not to always follow social norms. I'm leaning town here.
@JKM, That was a pretty big overreaction to me giving a slight town read to M-M's slot if you never had any intention of getting M-M lynched.
So why did you feel the need to self-vouch before even reading the game? Only scum need to self-vouch so fast.In post 394, Bert wrote:Are you kidding me
Those were my two opening posts before I even read the game
Now tell me why Brian is a scumread