Mafiascum.net

Okay. Who DO you scumread, though?

I'm willing to jump on the DDL wagon (when/if he comes back) even though it doesn't really make sense to me..

In post 374, BrightEyedFish wrote:I don't know if he is trying to use AtE to get people off of him and its having the opposite effect or what

Pretty much this- I think scum is way too classy to AtE, especially come D1...

And how is NC obv scum?

In post 348, Nero Cain wrote:Dual ISO us and tell me what you think.

TvT

In post 376, Vorkuta wrote:Pretty much this- I think scum is way too classy to AtE, especially come D1..

they aren't

I'd like to push for a Yyotta D-1 lynch.

-She'll basically only stop by to prod dodge
-Completely refuse to interact with us
-and If she says LITERALLY ANYTHING in her defense I'll drop it.

It's an extremely frustrating slot to deal with, and if anything the support for/against her will give town something to go on.

In post 180, OkaPoka wrote:where did YyottaCat go

In post 338, OkaPoka wrote:Yyotta could you walk me through your thought process?

In post 292, OkaPoka wrote:Yyotta how are you feeling about this game?

In post 376, Vorkuta wrote:I'm willing to jump on the DDL wagon (when/if he comes back) even though it doesn't really make sense to me..

y would u?

I could lynch every one of the posters from the last two pages, this is going to be a long game.

Vorkuta: who is scum?

I'm willing to jump on the DDL wagon (when/if he comes back) even though

it doesn't really make sense to me

..

TvT

-and If she says LITERALLY ANYTHING in her defense I'll drop it.

The third quote is the most important because it means you're pushing YYotta on policy rather than scumhunting principles. Nothing inherently wrong with that nor am I against a policy on her as I've stated, but your push that you'd "like to do" is not somebody you scumread as you handwave away the current 1v1 going on. I have not mentioned that you are currently voting Suka, the person you're dismissing as town, and not YYotta, the person you'd like to lynch supposedly.

In post 354, Nero Cain wrote:I rather lynch Suka or Mbaki

u wanna talk about this supposed scum read on me?

If Suka is scum, I don't believe its from anything to do with why Nero Cain is scumreading them.

My townreads that I have any confidence in right now are KMD, Creature, and RB. I state this to make it clear Suka does not fall into the townread category. If Suka does end up being scum, at least in Nero Cain's case it will be caught for the wrong reasons though.

In post 382, mbaki wrote:YYotta on policy rather than scumhunting principles.

And I don't claim otherwise. It's just as you say-

In post 381, mbaki wrote:I could lynch every one of the posters from the last two pages

I could dig up quotes that dinged my scum radar on almost every player here and that just makes this game waay too hard to figure out. I don't see the grounds or the foundations for the nc, suka, DDL, and fish, scum accusations. Maybe there's way too much friendly/meta interaction going on (disclaimer- played only with varsoon and yyotta here in newbie games before before) but I can't find anyone to build up my town core with.
So I'd like to get a quick lynch and move on to night stage for when PRs can truly shine.

Bring the hate

In post 382, mbaki wrote:you are currently voting Suka, the person you're dismissing as town, and not YYotta

Sorry, that was just me wagon hopping.

If I can get a Yyotta wagon going, then I'll get on it.
Otherwise I'll just park my vote nowhere until someone registers on my scum radar beyond a reasonable doubt.
UNVOTE:

Can’t you start the policy wagon yourself?

Will you join me on it, or would you rather let the game play out and scumhunt?
I'm worried that I just won't have any takers as the veteran players here are getting quite heated.

Also- I'm just curious as to whether she'll even ACKNOWLEDGE this without being at L-2 or L-1.

Probably wouldn’t. But you can try!

Reassuring.
Any other takers (aside from the 2 already on it?)

mbaki, why don't you townread me despite having the same reaction to Nero's posting?

Creature is right. This is a newbie game.

Okay, that means I won’t have to argue against more experienced people as much! Yes!

but I'm the IC. What are we going to argue about?

So I vote Suka in 47. It was a blank vote but my reasoning was that she had laid down two naked RVS type votes and I felt she was a little scummy for them.

Suka calls me, DDL and Oka scum in post 82

DDL naked votes me in 55. Then reaffirms his scum read in 108

Suka votes me in 114. Still no justification for why she's scum reading me.

In post 137, Suka wrote:

In post 118, Varsoon wrote:VOTE: DrDolittle

Also a good vote.

Why not Nero?

my first response to this was that she can't believe that DDL is scum if she's trying to get votes off him and onto me. Regardless its a weird reaction to seeing someone you think is scum getting voted.

Continues to call me scum in 279 and 300.

Creature's content is terrible but I assume that Suka and mbaki are meta reading him as town b/c he has a string of posts.

In post 311, Suka wrote:nd his follow-up misread

This is kinda TMIy.

So, she hasn't justified why she was scum reading me pre-114 and she hasn't explained why if she was scumreading both me and DDL she wanted Varsoon to vote me instead of DDL.So I vote Suka in 47. It was a blank vote but my reasoning was that she had laid down two naked RVS type RVS and I felt she was a little scummy for them,

Suka calls me, DDL and Oka scum in post 82

DDL naked votes me in 55. Then reaffirms his scum read in 108

Suka votes me in 114. Still no justification for why she's scum reading me.

In post 137, Suka wrote:

In post 118, Varsoon wrote:VOTE: DrDolittle

Also a good vote.

Why not Nero?

my first response to this was that she can't believe that DDL is scum if she's trying to get votes off him and onto me. Regardless its a wierd reaction to seeing someone you think is scum getting voted.

Continues to call me scum in 279 and 300.

Creature's content is terrible but I assume that Suka and mbaki are meta reading him as town b/c he has a string of posts.

In post 311, Suka wrote:nd his follow-up

misread

This is kinda TMIy and chainsawy. Town misread each other all the time so why am I scummy for it?

So, she hasn't justified why she was scum reading me pre-114 and she hasn't explained why if she was scumreading both me and DDL she wanted Varsoon to vote me instead of DDL. So yeah, I'm ok with this lynch.

I just think Suka has a scum mindset of being not transparent and overly conf-biasing.
I don't think there needs to be more reason than that.

but cool post nonetheless

that kinda fucked up a little, i'll fix it in a bit

What's wrong with TMIy tho?

im saying that her restounding town read of Creature is b/c she's scum that knows he's town.