Mafiascum.net

In post 372, Ame wrote:

In post 355, insomnia wrote:I don't get it. Luca's voting for aaron and I don't really see them scum together? Can you elaborate a bit?

I felt they were both suspicious, but unlikely scum together. Wanted to suss out which direction to go. Also wanted for Chara to commit to an Aaron read, but after review, I think he's probably not scum.

After review, I'm sticking with Aaron. #288 is especially scummy.

What's scummy about that?

In post 367, Egix96 wrote:Probably Luca if I had to guess, but that's only because he vibed to me as the townier of the two in the Luca/Aaron exchange.

I'm assuming the others are null for now.

In post 376, AaronFrost wrote:What's scummy about that?

Don't fuck with that confusing ass crow.

i've been annoyingly busy, but is my Aaron read relevant to the Luca/Aaron issue, Ame?
i'm also assuming Luca is the one you meant probably isn't scum, given both your eye for detail (pronoun) and what's definitely some suspicion of me.

i don't find anything the bird has posted confusing. wrong, sure, but not confusing.

I still think birdman is best lynch.

I don’t understand the aaron wagon.

Actually the bird might have a point about wimpy and alch.

I think my PoE that hits 2 scum and has a town is something like Aaron > Alch > profii

I really don't wanna lynch outside of that, unless someone presents a really compelling case on someone.

The bird is town and you need to start actually scum hunting Wimpy or my town read on you and perhaps everyone else's will fade real quick. I already have you trending down massively.

For someone that presents himself as a person that pushes his reads with conviction and is always looking to debate, you sure as hell are not doing a thing in this game. You're just sitting on a lynch because "he speaks weird".

There's 16 pages of content, I'll eventually read you as scum that struggles with manufacturing fake scum reads.

In post 376, AaronFrost wrote:

In post 372, Ame wrote:

In post 355, insomnia wrote:I don't get it. Luca's voting for aaron and I don't really see them scum together? Can you elaborate a bit?

I felt they were both suspicious, but unlikely scum together. Wanted to suss out which direction to go. Also wanted for Chara to commit to an Aaron read, but after review, I think he's probably not scum.

After review, I'm sticking with Aaron. #288 is especially scummy.

What's scummy about that?

i dont think thats particularly scummy either at this point in time. seems a bit forced

In post 382, insomnia wrote:The bird is town and you need to start actually scum hunting Wimpy or my town read on you and perhaps everyone else's will fade real quick. I already have you trending down massively.

Until he’s gone I’m not doing anything else. I can’t read/understand his posts nor can i read/understand responses to them. To me there is no town reason to ignore a reasonable request and drop the fake restriction. To keep it going is scum motivated and he’s my top scum read.

I don’t give a rats ass about yours or anyone else’s town read on me. I play to find scum and win. He’s scum to me. Now if he wants to drop the restriction so he can be readable, maybe I’ll change my mind but as long as be posts the restriction he’s scum

You guys may as well just Lynch me cause my vote will forever stay on macabre until he speaks normal. I have no clue what he’s saying and it’s hard enough playing this game trying read people as it is. Now add in I need a fucking decoder ring, which I don’t have, to read one person’s posts makes this game impossible. I don’t want to replace out either so you’re going to either have to appease me, ignore me, or lynch me. Either way I don’t care. He’s completely unreadable and that’s scum motivated point blank period.

That's not even remotely a town attitude to have. Like I understand that you find Macabre hard to read, but there's also like 11 other slots for you to sort through so maybe just ignore him for now a focus on those?

What makes you think I’m not sorting people?

^
you could let other players read Macabre if you can't. gimmick alts (or gimmick accounts) are common enough they're hard to avoid.
you can't, unfortunately, force anyone to play how you think they should play, and that applies to any aspect of mafia.

if you have a good TR on one or two players, you could sheep their read on the crow.

I stil don’t trust alchemist. Insomnia is kind of scummy also. Out of then three, I’m voting the scummiest

I’m not stopping anyone from reading him.

In post 388, Chara wrote:you could sheep their read on the crow.

Gross. Sheeping is terrible. Nobody should sheep

really hoping i have time tonight to go through this on my laptop. normally mobile suffices but Ame's style is pushing me in the direction of more focused analysis. not a bad thing, except that it forces me not to be lazy. i haven't forgotten questions directed at me.

pedit: we can agree to disagree. it's useful enough if i can't understand someone at all. if there's someone i both TR strongly and also trust the judgement of on a particular issue, it's fine with me.

In post 387, Wimpy wrote:What makes you think I’m not sorting people?

The fact that the majority of your ISO is talking about how annoying you find Macabre's posting.

There have been two major wagons this day phase in profii and myself. profii wagon seems to have dissipated (which I'm not sure how to feel about) and you mentioned earlier you don't understand the wagon on me. Can we get more of your thoughts on that?

I don’t have any town reads though. That’s the one thing I struggle with. If I had known there was a guy going to fake post restriction and be unreadable I’d have not even joined.

This is a normal game. That means people should play normally. No hydras. No post restrictions no bastards.

So he needs to drop it.

I didn’t understand why either wagon formed. There wasn’t good reason for either.

no hydras, and playing to win condition is required. posting in a strange way isn't a rule break and he doesn't really need to do anything.

Okay but what I don't get is why does your annoyance with Macabre's posting style affect your ability to read the other 11 players in the game?

In post 397, AaronFrost wrote:Okay but what I don't get is why does your annoyance with Macabre's posting style affect your ability to read the other 11 players in the game?

It’s not. I already said I had reads

In post 396, Chara wrote:no hydras, and playing to win condition is required. posting in a strange way isn't a rule break and he doesn't really need to do anything.

Well personally I think post restrictions real or fake shouldn’t be allowed. So if he wants to fake one then he has to be prepared to be scum read for it.