Mafiascum.net

(cont) It's hard to explain but some of his reasoning really ~pulls me in~ and from past experience, I think it means someone is town. Maybe I should rethink Ico

In post 336, clidd wrote:

In post 331, Kanna wrote:@clidd; so what are your thoughts on playing scum? do you really not like it or were you busy in your scumgames/some other reason?

The two games were coincidental, I had outstanding issues to resolve.

you said you have 2 games; can you link the other one?

nevermind I found it: it's here if anyone wants to see

Clidd *can* do wallpost analysis posts as scum

Huh ok, actually I have to think about clidd again.

@Luca, what makes you so sure clidd is town if you've seen him do posts like this as scum?

In post 357, Luca Blight wrote:

In post 328, Kanna wrote:

In post 215, Ame wrote:

In post 178, Ame wrote:@Kanna, why a strong 7?

was just feeling a ~7

In post 216, Ame wrote:Also current reads?

Right now it's

<Compath, Ame, Ico>

<Hectic, DDL, Clidd> ---null
<Slaxx>
<Luca>

Slaxx was scummy before Luca's push, but the reasoning for Luca's push felt weird to me. If it's TvS, scum is Luca imo

You ignored my response to your reason for SR’ing me in 217. Why is that?

Is there anything you want to engage me about regarding the Slaxx push?

Also for this, I didn't ignore that reasoning, my reasoning for SRing you was because of your reasoning wrt to the Slaxx push. Don't have any questions for you about that though.

As a data nerd, I really enjoy what you’re doing Ame. I’d be careful doing any retroactive fitting of your model, it needs predictive validity.

That being said, I think there’s something to that graph about number distributions (though I don’t think the takeaway has anything to do with a specific number, ie4, as much as it does the shape of the curve overall). I don’t want to derail discussion too much (I don’t believe this will drive the game forward) but after the game is over I’d like you to share the dataset with me.

You wouldn’t catch me at a concert with more than 50 participants (I get iffy with crowds). Mafia is more up my alley.

In post 358, Hectic wrote: Inform Conniver Kanna that I saw things I disliked and was asking whether she disliked the same things or something else not considered by Mass Spec Analytical Unit.

but officer! Didn't you say you generally liked slaxx's takes?

In post 81, Hectic wrote:trainee "trainee" trainee here because Officer "Officer" Officer is now off duty!

normally i'm just assigned to do paperwork and file cabinets around here, so i'm looking forward to doing some real field work! first, props to the mod for 4 PageTop VCs in a row! secondly, i find Ame intentionally ignoring questions regarding Compath very strange, but i think i can see where she's going with her RQS thing which might be civilian-indicative. we shall see!

slaxx has had good takes so far

other than his DDL read where it didn't look like to me that DDL was frustrated from that post.
DDL, so was your original vote on compath serious or not?

that's all for now!

I don't think I saw any takes that you thought he was trying hard or not liking him before that.

Thanks @ Clidd!

@hectic I made them myself

In post 371, Hectic wrote:it's me!

also, i'll be honest, i was expecting you take a completely different approach with the RQS

i thought you were gonna focus on how willing people were to answer and whether they gave in to answer or remained stubborn when you persisted in making them answer. thought that approach would be kinda civiliany if i was correct about it. never expected you to actually have an answer key

For the record, I was completely aware that you thought this

Ame's wall is v interesting but I have to go so I'll digest it later

p-edit: hi ame

Kanna the issue I have with Luca-scum is at the time, Clidd and I were both fairly vulnerable in our positions. He seemed to arbitrate and intervene early into our 1v1 spat. If we are both town, and Luca is scum, what motivation does he have to do that?

I still get the vibe Ame believes what she’s saying. Now, what’s up for debate is how much they are applying it to move the game forward. Obviously it’s easy to tell the truth as mafia if you talk about non-game related things.

I think, though, that there is enough “this-game” content wrapped up in that analysis to not give me much pause on sustaining a town read.

I’d like to see more from DDL. My town pool is too big at this point.

I still am really not a fan of Hectic’s posting. When you distill it, there isn’t a lot of original content. Very safe posting / posturing.

Sorry I switched from gender neutral to gendered terms back and forth. I’m working on it.

trainee "trainee" trainee will step in for Officer "Officer" Officer!

Kanna:

>see slaxx' takes
>hey, i agree with Icon being towny for that push, and Compath's 8 and 9 do feel like filler (which can be a good scumtell), DDL i disagree with but whatever
>like these takes overall
>see you say you're getting bad vibes
>recheck his posts
>realise that the Icon and Compath takes aren't difficult or nuanced ones to make and so feel somewhat forced
>see his "die on this hill" post which feels a little over the top stubborn
>reply to you about these things

now if you'll me, i'm getting back to watching Knives Out

In post 208, Hectic wrote:

In post 128, DrDolittle wrote:VOTE: luca blight
this is the way to go

please share with the class, Doctor! what did you see?

basically what someone else said that luca was a bit too eager to answer that rvs, with very unspiring answers. PS hectic I do find you over the top this game even for hectic standards.

In post 223, Slaxx wrote:
I don't know if scum-DDl pushes on me out of the gate though. The most memorable game I had with him was on my lolwagons alt where I stomped scum out early, and I know was scum I wouldn't immediately push on someone the way he did. Not saying he wouldn't push on me at all, just not for sure he goes this ham with it out the gate as scum. So I think I feel alright about DDL now as well.

I didn't know you were lolwagons. Lolwagons was excellent, but I'm not going ham at all and just tossing my votes around? I think you've put weird justifications on my vote twice (once being i was angry or was that soemone else)

In post 231, Slaxx wrote: (Ame, Compath, DDL, Icon)-Slight Town
(Luca, Kanna)-Null
(Hectic)- Slight Scum
(Clidd)- Scum

This list seems "too listy" to be a list?

You’re gonna have to elaborate on too listy to be a list.

DDL, if you don’t want someone interpreting your votes, maybe you should flesh out the reasoning more. I’m not saying I didn’t misinterpret your tone or even misrepresent you (albeit not purposefully) but you’re not exactly verbose.

oh, couple more things!

In post 384, Ame wrote:For the record, I was completely aware that you thought this

goddamn you, well played

In post 388, Slaxx wrote:I still am really not a fan of Hectic’s posting. When you distill it, there isn’t a lot of original content. Very safe posting / posturing.

what about Officer/my reads on Ame aren't original? i don't think i have or have tried to be safe

not sure where to put my vote right now, i should really stop posting until i've actually properly read pages 9 to 14

In post 237, clidd wrote:

In post 231, Slaxx wrote:Also can't really describe it but Icon is giving me decent town feelz. I think my list is probably

(Ame, Compath, DDL, Icon)-Slight Town
(Luca, Kanna)-Null
(Hectic)- Slight Scum
(Clidd)- Scum

You remind me a lot of a player called Espeonage from a past game (he was

scum

).

what do you see in this clid?

Going ham was tongue in cheek @ your very punctuated style of early play.

In post 392, Slaxx wrote:You’re gonna have to elaborate on too listy to be a list.

like, you know when you ask people to give a random string of numbers, it turns out to have a lot of patterns than hit actually is suppose to? this list is very clean, with the 4 town, 2 null, 2 scum "read", and it looks fake? I could just be wrong though

I'll try to do better at fleshing out my thoughts.

In post 241, Slaxx wrote:I consider myself to be one of the more cocky town players on the site,

i might just BOP you