Mafiascum.net

In post 373, LegoLucy wrote:

In post 370, Menalque wrote:But it’s fun and I’m enjoying it tho

You said you had a dance PT? You could post in there. I bet it is fun too.

Alas, it is a dance PT of my dreams

Tread softly, because you tread on my dreams

In post 372, Menalque wrote:

In post 368, skitter30 wrote:You had half the game pocketed for like 4 phases

It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she

just lost

where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

Do you think skitter is maybe faking her investigation?

In post 372, Menalque wrote:

In post 368, skitter30 wrote:You had half the game pocketed for like 4 phases

It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she

just lost

where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

1. Refuge in Audacity

2. If it doesn't work, try try again.

3. She's like really good at it.

4. WIFOM

In post 372, Menalque wrote:It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she just lost where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

It is much less insane if that behavior is also something she has done or clearly would do as town.

In post 376, LegoLucy wrote:

In post 372, Menalque wrote:

In post 368, skitter30 wrote:You had half the game pocketed for like 4 phases

It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she

just lost

where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

Do you think skitter is maybe faking her investigation?

That’s not the vibe I get, I think she’s serious

In post 374, Menalque wrote:I am very confident on ydrasse town

this is like the last nail in ydra's coffin lol

VOTE: Ydrasse

I just woke up and there’s 16 pages

In post 377, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 372, Menalque wrote:

In post 368, skitter30 wrote:You had half the game pocketed for like 4 phases

It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she

just lost

where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

1. Refuge in Audacity

2. If it doesn't work, try try again.

3. She's like really good at it.

4. WIFOM

(1) that’s not necessarily a feature I’d expect from ydra’s scumgame

(2) this is not a good plan when you’re with the same people who already busted you up

(3) this is maybe a point but only valid if you think she’s not equally/also talented at playing scum in other ways (she is)

(4) literally an answer for anything

In post 378, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 372, Menalque wrote:It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she just lost where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

It is much less insane if that behavior is also something she has done or clearly would do as town.

I’ll be back later

Pooky and Ydrasse both don't seem very serious about the game but my feelings feel like Ydrasse is more scared to be serious.

Fuck, @S_S, no it would still be foolish to do it as scum right after doing it in front of someone who caught you for it and knows you just did that as scum

I feel unsure

In post 380, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 374, Menalque wrote:I am very confident on ydrasse town

this is like the last nail in ydra's coffin lol

VOTE: Ydrasse

There’s no need to be rude

In post 372, Menalque wrote:

In post 368, skitter30 wrote:You had half the game pocketed for like 4 phases

It is mildly insane that you think she would replicate behaviour from a game she

just lost

where it’s only utility would be negated by the presence of people from that game in this one

Idk. Like i said i dont know what her scumrange is. For all i know this is how she approaches *every* scumgame.

But the key thing here for me is not the fact that it looks so similar, but that she got really, really defensive when i called her out on it

In post 385, Menalque wrote:Fuck, @S_S, no it would still be foolish to do it as scum right after doing it in front of someone who caught you for it and knows you just did that as scum

I mean I've literally done it.

replicate parts of my scum game in order to get townread

with people who just saw my scum game.

In post 387, Menalque wrote:There’s no need to be rude

oh cmon you know that was a reaction test right?

It’s not unless she’s radically changed her scumgame as I’m aware of it

And like, I think I would also be defensive if u stated scumreading me for things that would be mildly insane for scum!me to do? Like I can’t remember what the thing you said I scumtold on from that game that just finished was, but if I could remember it and did it again this game, that would be mental, right? I don’t think this is v different from that

In post 390, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 387, Menalque wrote:There’s no need to be rude

oh cmon you know that was a reaction test right?

>.>

In post 389, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 385, Menalque wrote:Fuck, @S_S, no it would still be foolish to do it as scum right after doing it in front of someone who caught you for it and knows you just did that as scum

I mean I've literally done it.

replicate parts of my scum game in order to get townread

with people who just saw my scum game.

You are you and ydrasse is ydrasse

In post 393, Menalque wrote:You are you and ydrasse is ydrasse

I'm only using it to refute the idea that it's insane to do it.

Maybe Ydrasse likes playing mafia that way regardless of her alignment

maybe she has fun playing mafia that way.

regardless - it's not her playing that way that's the scumtell

it's her reaction after being called out on it that's scummy.

Pooky seems more like a bear than a wolf to me because he is thinking hard about Ydrasse's behaviour

I never said it was insane to do it

I said it would be insane to think that’s what ydrasse is doing

Subtle but important difference, and I already addressed why the defensiveness isn’t really AI in this case

In post 395, LegoLucy wrote:Pooky seems more like a bear than a wolf to me because he is thinking hard about Ydrasse's behaviour

I mean
He’s pookythemagicalbear not Pookythemagicalwolf for a reason

In post 385, Menalque wrote:@S_S, no it would still be foolish to do it as scum right after doing it in front of someone who caught you for it and knows you just did that as scum

That's definitely not true when it comes to extremely ordinary behaviors that people do every game. Like, hey look, I'm playing devil's advocate. I did that the last time I was scum against you, wouldn't it be foolish for me to do it here as scum? No, because it's what I always do.

There probably are times where it is true, especially for more self-conscious players, but this seems pretty typical of her personality which makes me doubt it in this case.