Mafiascum.net

I was floating the idea earlier that bubba was a 1-shot pgo and not a bomb. He was very clear about his role, imo, and it what he's described is exactly what I assumed he had claimed during day 1. My PGO theory assumes that he was lying about his role, not that he was some strange interpretation of a bomb.

I don't think that's the case given that he asked yukari if stuff could be stolen from him. While his reasoning for why this is important is completely ridiculous, I have a hard time imagining that it isn't coming from town. I am very much against a bubba lynch, though I do think it's bizarre that he considers his "crumb" to be an actual crumb.

I want GCBC to come and tell me what he thinks about the dramonic slot.

Also, I find it reasonable that the scumteam killed Serene on the basis of his suspicion about the CoK. The kaze kill is less clear.

Wasn't Serene a claimed Mason? i'd think that'd be enough of a reason to kill someone.

no, serene was not claimed, only pie was.

Ok then N1 kills are making me go even more wtf now.

Let's just lynch all suspects.
Can that be a thing?
Lynch All Suspects?
LAS?

In post 3798, Sakura Hana wrote:

In post 3797, Messiah Complex wrote:Never played that set up, no.

Oh then that makes sense.
Duck Duck Goose every townie is a 1-shot PGO, but they decide whether to activate themselves during any given night or not. If 1 of them activates himself for example N1, then any actions on him N1 will kill the visitor.
So im guessing bubba's ability works the same way, which means he could've killed during N1.

Kagami I love you.

I'd be fine with dramonic

I haven't looked into it much but it looked like on D1 he was just sitting there and trying to get Kaze and Varsoon lynched

inb4 prod dodge.

In post 3809, Kagami wrote:

@Yukari: GCBC is due for a good, hard prodding

I see, the turtle thing.

Ok, well I'm sufficiently bothered by GCBC's deficiency of suspicion toward dramonic even without him saying anything. If there were two scum on varsoon's wagon, as we'd expect, then it has to be GCBC or dram (unless mac lucked out that I'm macho as a red herring), so I would think he'd be all for a dram lynch if he were town. He's avoiding the thread too.

VOTE: GCBC

there's still an SK and I probably was the 2nd NK last night (and then it failed cause kagami). GIF likes SKs and we're probably dealing with a 15-5-1 setup given GIF likes high scum ratios (he did 2 games that were 9-3-1)

here's my reads bc I'm starting to forget some of them o.o

town
1. Kagami
2. pieguyn
3. bubbajack8
4. Jaqen Hghar
5. Katarina LeBlanc
6. ActionDan
7. Kise

null-town
8. Mac
9. Varsoon
10. Messiah Complex

11. Nachomamma8
12. GoodCop_BadCop
13. Saki
14. Sakura
15. dramonic
16. zMuffinMan

^ not in order btw

In post 3813, pieguyn wrote:GIF likes SKs and we're probably dealing with a 15-5-1 setup given GIF likes high scum ratios (he did 2 games that were 9-3-1)

What makes you think he'd do a ratio like that given how much flak he was given about the 1-shot BP ninja 1-shot dayvig SK in 9-3-1, and Nati even told him post game that 9-3-1 was horribad.

i always thought 15-5-1 was more acceptable than 9-3-1

especially given this is almost role madness

i'm really worn out

i'd still say it's zmuffin but GCBC avoiding the thread is p telling so i'd be fine with either one

i get the feeling one of my townreads is wrong. who do you think it is?

pieguyn

Do you guys think that there are goons in the game?

if it's a 4 man scumteam probably not. if it's a 5 man scumteam i have no idea

In post 3819, Saki wrote:pieguyn

tht was directed towards sakura but it looks like she ditchedm e

In post 3813, pieguyn wrote:4. Jaqen Hghar

^
This townread is totes wrong.

On other news idk really, i got a pretty low ammount of townreads and that's bothering me.

what do you make of nacho's defense of zmuffin?

also I wanna know this bc generally when I start to feel my reads aren't adding up, or if i keep getting town vibes from my scumreads, it's bc one of my townreads is dead wrong. and i don't want that to happen here. it's happened in just about every game i've played (zmuffin and my entire null-town pile in imperishable night, kalimar in AA:MFA). so i don't wanna get blindsided