Mafiascum.net

In post 3808, Serene wrote:I agree with his scum reads except for Cephrir.

also me?

In post 3823, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:hmm.

Want to talk about reads lists?

In post 3826, Rift Adrift wrote:

In post 3823, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:hmm.

Want to talk about reads lists?

maybe later

are you still comfortable with cabd

In post 3827, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

In post 3826, Rift Adrift wrote:

In post 3823, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:hmm.

Want to talk about reads lists?

maybe later

are you still comfortable with cabd

It's day three, orcinus. I'm not comfortable with anything. I'm holding it together because a number of my day 1 town reads (even some shaky ones) have flipped town and I want to believe that I'm right about the other ones.

Cabd's play has been pretty solid IMO. We've seen both the facade and the background discussion in AMOL and the mafia QT, though it's a different hydra.

I'm here. My shadi read has gone into higher town, upon re-reading day two interactions. Orci, I know you want him dead, so talk to me.

Worth taking a look at bulba's reads?

In post 3831, Rift Adrift wrote:Worth taking a look at bulba's reads?

I'd say so. Too bad he didn't do vote analysis for any other wagons.

He did a metric fuckton after he was lynched. We'll make do.

In post 3828, Rift Adrift wrote:

In post 3827, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

In post 3826, Rift Adrift wrote:

In post 3823, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:hmm.

Want to talk about reads lists?

maybe later

are you still comfortable with cabd

It's day three, orcinus. I'm not comfortable with anything. I'm holding it together because a number of my day 1 town reads (even some shaky ones) have flipped town and I want to believe that I'm right about the other ones.

Cabd's play has been pretty solid IMO. We've seen both the facade and the background discussion in AMOL and the mafia QT, though it's a different hydra.

The night kills worry me.

In post 3830, KingCrabd wrote:I'm here. My shadi read has gone into higher town, upon re-reading day two interactions. Orci, I know you want him dead, so talk to me.

much more passive than in goonies, completely different attitude to the game

i also will read rev's scumgame today

In post 3834, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

In post 3828, Rift Adrift wrote:

In post 3827, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:

In post 3826, Rift Adrift wrote:

In post 3823, orcinus_theoriginal wrote:hmm.

Want to talk about reads lists?

maybe later

are you still comfortable with cabd

It's day three, orcinus. I'm not comfortable with anything. I'm holding it together because a number of my day 1 town reads (even some shaky ones) have flipped town and I want to believe that I'm right about the other ones.

Cabd's play has been pretty solid IMO. We've seen both the facade and the background discussion in AMOL and the mafia QT, though it's a different hydra.

The night kills worry me.

Me too.

I've reread the last half or so of bulba's ISO. His scum reads line up so much with my town reads. I think that's part of the reason I couldn't see a town mindset. Syr and I have talked about DOMO and our feeling right now is that we eventually moved him into our town pile for good reason.

Well, I can't say that guilty surprises me a great deal. And given how well it lines up with Ank's stated investigation philosophy, well, he's either the ballsiest scum on the face of the earth and it's multiball, or he's town.

I'll refrain from voting letters for the time being, but I may start analyzing under the assumption he's scum.

In post 3838, Cephrir wrote:Well, I can't say that guilty surprises me a great deal. And given how well it lines up with Ank's stated investigation philosophy, well, he's either the ballsiest scum on the face of the earth and it's multiball, or he's town.

I'll refrain from voting letters for the time being, but I may start analyzing under the assumption he's scum.

Lolscum. Put this on the viglist, koopa.

Holy shit Stevie flipped town. I'm stunned.

Anyways today's lynch is easy as fuck, no need to restate what we're doing. Not going to drop my vote down until we have time to discuss things, though, since ending days early with guilty investigates can hurt town in the long-run (*coughXenobladecough*).

Orc what worries you about the flips?

I'm game ffery. We gotta tackle that sooner or later. Might as well do it now.

It does worry me that we didn't see a NK on either the cop claim or the vig claim, however. There's a non-zero percent chance ank is a rolecop for the opposite scumteam as letters. Ffery, I know you love NK analysis. What do these say?

Can I get a definition of multiball?

In post 3842, KingCrabd wrote:It does worry me that we didn't see a NK on either the cop claim or the vig claim, however. There's a non-zero percent chance ank is a rolecop for the opposite scumteam as letters. Ffery, I know you love NK analysis. What do these say?

With those claims, it was virtually guaranteed that a doctor would not have been protecting a lot of players. I think the scum/SK/whatever picked targets they were sure would go through. Whether they were hunting each other vs going for town I dunno. IMO it's early for scum to be hunting each other in a multiball set up. But, calicfer in particular was looking like they could be vulnerable to lynch. But, mastin came out in twilight and towned all over the thread, so maybe they were looking like a threat.

If TMT flips scum and something other than goon, then role cup is a distinct possibility.

In post 3843, Shadi1337 wrote:Can I get a definition of multiball?

more than one scum faction.

I dislike Cabd

His questioning+discussion driving seems a tad less coherent than xenoblade

What about Cephrir?

Tmt's ISO looks pretty worthless

In post 3847, StubbsKVM wrote:What about Cephrir?

The post that Syr called out is just about the most awkward thing I've ever seen in a mafia game.