Posted: Tue May 18, 2021 2:39 pm
i disagreeIn post 3834, Disaster Cartel wrote:I'm pretty sure it was, I'll try to find quotes in a bitIn post 3766, SirCakez wrote:I don't think this is true though
but I think the only one who was like particularly opposed was notsci and even that only came after like.. a while of wanting bulge dead
like put it this way: most of the voters on the bulge wagon probably would still have voted bulge the next day anyway, and those on the NM wagon I think wanted NM more but I don't think there was anyone screaming that bulge was town there
i completely disagree; tonally I think it makes senseIn post 3840, Disaster Cartel wrote:she's acting here like she's just had this big revelation that "oh my god holy shit, it's VFT/DC!!!" but like... this shouldn't be shocking if her prior post was genuine because that's what she was supposedly already thinking. like the only thing that made her not commit to it was bc she needs to do "due diligence" on the skitt iverson thing, but the "I CAN SEE IT" is just so performative. that's like the most blatant bit where it comes through but the whole post reads in the same way
also this reminds me of posts I've seen scum make beforeIn post 3842, Disaster Cartel wrote:like ur buddy is putting in so much effort here! you can do better than that
if NM had been yeeted I think Bulge would have been off the table because he was the counterwagon to scumIn post 3852, Disaster Cartel wrote:SCENARIO 1: we bus NM. the next day, we lim bulge. mom leaves. we're in mylo with two town gone and 3 scum gone. we look p good for having bussed NM all the way through and the day probably goes smoothly.
SCENARIO 2: we kill bulge. NM leaves. mom is limmed. we're in mylo with two town gone and 3 scum gone. the game is a horrible fucking shitfest because our correct push on NM is undermined by having jumped off him to vote bulge despite there being exactly no need to.
let me be very clear: unless you think that we couldn't lim bulge the next day in scenario (1) the two worlds are functionally no different in terms of who is alive. the basically ONLY difference is how we're perceived. so do you disagree that bulge would have been very limmable the next day, or do you not? and if you don't, why did ydra vote bulge? just to make this fun game a little bit extra challenging because it was too easy
If this ain’t a fucking moodIn post 3880, SirCakez wrote:i get so pumped playing other games and feel good about mafia and then I remember this game exists and it just drains my soul
I’m gonna go back to try and pull quotes tomo but this is not how I remember it at allIn post 3878, SirCakez wrote:i disagree
no one was saying it was S/S
some people just thought one or the other was scummier
ex; notsci
I don’t get itIn post 3878, SirCakez wrote:i completely disagree; tonally I think it makes sense
*shrug*In post 3878, SirCakez wrote:also this reminds me of posts I've seen scum make before
But like I don’t think whether you would have voted him matters hugely, no offenceIn post 3878, SirCakez wrote:if NM had been yeeted I think Bulge would have been off the table because he was the counterwagon to scum
I know I wouldn't have voted him after that
Town loses if we get flipped, this is lylo, which I’m p sure ur aware ofIn post 3863, Morning Tweet wrote:Oh but if Disaster is town i dont think there's any hope for me anymore so there's that
I mean an additional scum had to go, right? Like inevitably another scum was leavingIn post 3864, Infinity 324 wrote:This incorrectly assumes that the mom lim was a foregone conclusion from scum's PoV at the time. Bork was TRing her and others were trusting his reasoning.In post 3852, Disaster Cartel wrote:SCENARIO 1: we bus NM. the next day, we lim bulge. mom leaves. we're in mylo with two town gone and 3 scum gone. we look p good for having bussed NM all the way through and the day probably goes smoothly.
SCENARIO 2: we kill bulge. NM leaves. mom is limmed. we're in mylo with two town gone and 3 scum gone. the game is a horrible fucking shitfest because our correct push on NM is undermined by having jumped off him to vote bulge despite there being exactly no need to.
let me be very clear: unless you think that we couldn't lim bulge the next day in scenario (1) the two worlds are functionally no different in terms of who is alive. the basically ONLY difference is how we're perceived. so do you disagree that bulge would have been very limmable the next day, or do you not? and if you don't, why did ydra vote bulge? just to make this fun game a little bit extra challenging because it was too easy
I can’t stay long today but I think this is a very weird thing to have in the middle of a post on why it’s DC/VftIn post 3872, Morning Tweet wrote:Ydrasse leans against Iverson....
so at this point in the day I dont think pushing Iverson is ever a winning plan. Was there another point in the day though, ill keep reading..
Yes but what I'm saying is that scum would much rather safehouse NM than mom because NM will always get limmed later but mom will not necessarily.In post 3889, Disaster Cartel wrote:I mean an additional scum had to go, right? Like inevitably another scum was leaving
Given how fucking brutal this game is and that mom was relatively consensus, I don’t think that’s a wrong assumption to make
They were always both gonna die infinity holy shitIn post 3893, Infinity 324 wrote:Yes but what I'm saying is that scum would much rather safehouse NM than mom because NM will always get limmed later but mom will not necessarily.In post 3889, Disaster Cartel wrote:I mean an additional scum had to go, right? Like inevitably another scum was leaving
Given how fucking brutal this game is and that mom was relatively consensus, I don’t think that’s a wrong assumption to make