Mafiascum.net

cool.

so like, we don't have any other unaccounted for kills.
that said, it's 8 people left and we've only seen one mafia flip. this may well be mylo, yeah?

hell, it's PROBABLY mylo, discounting any potential ability we have to stop the kills.

titus i wasn't really following that whole thing with u and shaz arguing about softs or w/e but now with the knowledge that he's an SK, do you know wtf he was talking about?

also: why on EARTH did mafia kill a rolestopper over a roleblocker? especially considering UT had no reads. unless Titus is REEEEEEEEEEEAAAALLY wrong on just about everything, she's quite possibly scum here.

ok so working under the assumption it's 5-3 here:

i'm town, zakk is town, egg is town. i think.

one of liger/MoI is town. probably not both?

projectmatt, titus, cythefly remain. 2/3 scum in there.

i hipster townread cy early on but eh. pjm and titus could totally be scum together so i mighta been right on that.

In post 3904, Nahdia wrote:also: why on EARTH did mafia kill a rolestopper over a roleblocker? especially considering UT had no reads. unless Titus is REEEEEEEEEEEAAAALLY wrong on just about everything, she's quite possibly scum here.

actually do we have a roleblocker? for some reason i thought we had a roleblocker i might be mixing it up with a diff game. titus is a neapolitan right?

ok still tho point remains why kill rolestopper over neapolitan. that's bad. that's real bad.

right ok i'm getting a grip.

titus has cy as conftown. so either titus is scum or my reads are wrong somewhere else. either way projectmatt is totally definitely scum probably.

ok i remember where i got confused shotty thoguht he was a roleblocker but he was a rolestopper. and titus was always a neapolitan.

we gucci.

inclined to not like titus rn but like, are there any other investigative claims? bc if not titus being the sole investigative role makes her more believable from a setup speculation pov. but maybe no town investigative was exactly what sircakez was going for.

lemme know if i missed anything

Liger_Zero: Neighbor
MagnaOfIllusion: Neighbor
Titus: Neapolitan
cytheflyguy: VT
projectmatt: ???
Egg: ???
zakk: ???
Nahdia: ???

i want a claim from projectmatt in particular.

@Mod I cannot play this game anymore, I am actually surprised I wasn't replaced sooner.

=_=

In post 3908, Nahdia wrote:ok still tho point remains why kill rolestopper over neapolitan. that's bad. that's real bad.

I was blocked night 1.

In post 3905, Nahdia wrote:ok so working under the assumption it's 5-3 here:

i'm town, zakk is town, egg is town. i think.

one of liger/MoI is town. probably not both?

projectmatt, titus, cythefly remain. 2/3 scum in there.

5-3 means we gamesolve but only lynch if we feel the game is solved.

I do feel that one of Liger or MoI is town, at least.
I am town.
Cy is conftown.

Two of Egg/Nahdia/PM/Zakk are town.

I think a review is in order, of everything.

I have a cold, so give me time.

Murdering me also conftowns Cy.

I do hink massclaim issss in order. If we hit the scum roleblocker, that forces scum to murder me and conftown Cy.

ugh titus i want you to be town so bad but like : \

I came into today wanting to lynch nobody but Titus. Claim seemed fake and I suspected shotty slot too, and I thought they had awkwardly coordinated uncommon claims for the "too elaborate to be scum" angle

But with the flip of untrod/shotty, her claim's legitimacy skyrockets and basically we can safely believe the result on cy too. So that's 3 out of 8 including each of ourselves

After a skim of some pertinent parts, remaining scum is most likely within Nahdia projectmatt and Liger. Liger probably tried to out the neighborhood for town cred, but why didn't he talk in the thread, and why hasn't he died yet, and why is he replacing out now? Maybe there are other circumstances for that but the other two points stand easily on their own

And then projectmatt has li nd of been acting like scum entire game, staying just on the periphery and only really pushing one case of consequence, Nosferatu.

I don't trust Titus' reads like at ALL but the claim of odd night neo matches very well with even night role-stopper because she clears a townoe and the roles topper targets them the next night to guarantee at least one night of conftown not dying and there's always the possibility the role stopper targets Titus instead of Titus target so WIFOM for scum too

Everything is making more sense now

Nahdia throwing shade on Titus today is super weak, I'm thinking anen was a bus specifically of how it went down on anen's end, though Nahdia sold it very well if it WAS a bus

I feel safest lynching projectmatt or liger first. Leaning liger because projectmatt at least HAS pushed a case. And also the people that are alive right now are the people I would expect him not to be killing. I would never expect him to kill Magna EVER, mostly because of the whole one-scum-in-the-neighborhood theory that everybody tossed around pretty liberally on D2.

I think we should be holding off on votes for now

More later, phone post in the bathroom at work LOL

I am actually agreeing with Zakk here....

I need to look at the votes again...

actually

In post 3906, Nahdia wrote:i hipster townread cy early on but eh. pjm and titus could totally be scum together so i mighta been right on that.

attempt at poking sardonic fun at one's own meta with language like "hipster townread". check.

attempt at making wishy washy statements like "but eh" and "could totally be" and "mighta been right" seem like legitimate stream of consciousness posting. check

bonus attempt at linking 2 people together, i see this in endgame mostly done by scum with 1 probtown and 1 probscum, and in this case it seems clear titus would be the town and pmatt would be the scum.

but that's all just my experience talking and none of it is concrete, it's just gut.

however!

main problem with this post lies within nahdia not treating titus claim legitimacy and titus results claim legitimacy with similar levels of "eh", e.g. if nahdia really thought titus was scum she should be throwing shade at cy too, but is not. she's buddying up to cy being town.

thats a completely inconsistent train of thought for town

In post 3908, Nahdia wrote:ok still tho point remains why kill rolestopper over neapolitan. that's bad. that's real bad.

"omg why would scum do this, that makes no sense!"

distancing from the choice i bet she made

In post 3912, Nahdia wrote:lemme know if i missed anything

Liger_Zero: Neighbor
MagnaOfIllusion: Neighbor
Titus: Neapolitan
cytheflyguy: VT
projectmatt: ???
Egg: ???
zakk: ???
Nahdia: ???

i want a claim from projectmatt in particular.

this is zakk confbias talking now:

1. rolefishing for more people to block (titus was blocked N1, but probably not N3 because they probably blocked Lowell or someone else they thought was SK since 1 cleared townie isn't worth 1 dead scum)

2. trying to make it look pro-town a la "hay guys im just collecting information, look at me being so town wheeee"

3. also calls out ostensible scumbuddy to put pressure on them and distance

In post 3913, Liger_Zero wrote:@Mod I cannot play this game anymore, I am actually surprised I wasn't replaced sooner.

In post 3914, Nahdia wrote:=_=

if liger is town: no scum wants a fresh set of eyes at this point
if liger is scum: no scum wants a buddy replacing out right now, or at least doesn't want to be seen wanting that

i believe nahdia is scum very strongly now

In post 3919, Nahdia wrote:ugh titus i want you to be town so bad but like : \

and this is the icing on the cake.


ready to vote nahdia. very, very ready.

me >>> cy > titus > magna = egg >> liger > projectmatt >> nahdia atm




and its funny because i bet nahdia thought that string of posts made her look super town.

no not really.