Why does that make me scum? If I realize there was an error in communication between us then why wouldn’t I back off there?
'Cause I felt you overreacted in the first place and then called it a misunderstanding to make it look like both were in the wrong, therefore making my case on you wrong. It's like a subconscious thing to do.
In post 3969, Pink Ball wrote:I haven't called it a solid case, I've been calling it a theory since the begining. Very different, if you ask me. I don't have a solid case on anyone, but I have a nice theory that I want to check. Makes sense?
You can call it what you want but it’s what you’re pushing so I’m gonna call it like I see it.
Sure, you do you. But it's not a solid case and I'm not trying to depict it like it is.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:25 am
by Cafe Stile
when people say "your case isn't good" instead of "your case is wrong" or "you're wrong"
it's typically scum
js
- Hideri
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:25 am
by Alchemist21
In post 3971, Pink Ball wrote:I know what you're doing, by the way. You're proving that my "case" is not good enough so people won't follow me. I would do the same, 'cause you're right.
I’m proving it’s not good enough because I know it’s wrong. Do you think scum me defends against this while Town me just concedes?
God i was thinking that too & was about to say i feel like scum hasn’t even been here. & could be within
-the mason pair.
-the duck
-FL although. I think (rn he’s not scum but still got my eyes on him)
I’m sure there is at least on active scum rn too
Which could be
-FL (still not there yet for me tho)
Anyone else I’m unsure of for scum.
From the top of my head town is
-Cheeky
-tet
-Furret
Based off the clear & claim.
I also had good feeling about tet for most of the game, until fl came in. So this makes him iffy in my book still.
He might be misguided.
I can only think of a couple TL
-X
-alch
Alch cos I don’t see krillin as a scum role. But. That could be a mistake on my part. & if i need to ISO him later i will.
I was really relying on being able to bouncing off of Titus. I felt it in my jelly’s she was town.
In post 3971, Pink Ball wrote:I know what you're doing, by the way. You're proving that my "case" is not good enough so people won't follow me. I would do the same, 'cause you're right.
I’m proving it’s not good enough because I know it’s wrong. Do you think scum me defends against this while Town me just concedes?
I think town!you works with me with the other parts of my theory instead of focusing on yourself.
Why does that make me scum? If I realize there was an error in communication between us then why wouldn’t I back off there?
'Cause I felt you overreacted in the first place and then called it a misunderstanding to make it look like both were in the wrong, therefore making my case on you wrong. It's like a subconscious thing to do.
If we’re both Town then yeah we were both in the wrong, and by this point I am sure you’re Town.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:28 am
by Pink Ball
Like "you're wrong about me but could be right about being the designated nightkill. If you were right, I think jjh could be a better suspect 'cause you were calling him obvtown and that would give him an alibi", or something like that.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:28 am
by Alchemist21
In post 3977, Cafe Stile wrote:when people say "your case isn't good" instead of "your case is wrong" or "you're wrong"
it's typically scum
js
- Hideri
I’m saying both. Where does that put me?
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:30 am
by Alchemist21
In post 3982, Pink Ball wrote:Like "you're wrong about me but could be right about being the designated nightkill. If you were right, I think jjh could be a better suspect 'cause you were calling him obvtown and that would give him an alibi", or something like that.
Except I’m not going to deflect and push someone based on the lack of a Nightkill.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:31 am
by Cafe Stile
You said "you're wrong" right after I posted that
idrk, move on.
In post 3971, Pink Ball wrote:I know what you're doing, by the way. You're proving that my "case" is not good enough so people won't follow me. I would do the same, 'cause you're right.
I’m proving it’s not good enough because I know it’s wrong. Do you think scum me defends against this while Town me just concedes?
I think town!you works with me with the other parts of my theory instead of focusing on yourself.
I’m not going to focus on the lack of a NK because there’s too much WIFOM there.
God i was thinking that too & was about to say i feel like scum hasn’t even been here. & could be within
-the mason pair.
-the duck
-FL although. I think (rn he’s not scum but still got my eyes on him)
I’m sure there is at least on active scum rn too
Which could be
-FL (still not there yet for me tho)
Anyone else I’m unsure of for scum.
From the top of my head town is
-Cheeky
-tet
-Furret
Based off the clear & claim.
I also had good feeling about tet for most of the game, until fl came in. So this makes him iffy in my book still.
He might be misguided.
I can only think of a couple TL
-X
-alch
Alch cos I don’t see krillin as a scum role. But. That could be a mistake on my part. & if i need to ISO him later i will.
I was really relying on being able to bouncing off of Titus. I felt it in my jelly’s she was town.
Why can't what Alch claimed be a scum role?
I just don’t like the idea of
Krillin
being evil.
1.krillin is
green
2.krillin is just
red
. (Which I don’t like. Cos i mean. Krillin, But I think I could be being bias.)
3.alch is another
evil
DBZ character with sensu beans.
But idk what character that could be if 3 is the case.
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:37 am
by Cafe Stile
Aren't we playing a Upick? Like...flavour doesn't suggest alignment or whatever
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:38 am
by Krazy
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:39 am
by Emperor flippyNips
Yeah. So I’m being bias I guess. I could vote alch
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:40 am
by Emperor flippyNips
Aww Krazy stole pg. top from me
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:40 am
by Emperor flippyNips
Oh i was wrong
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:40 am
by Emperor flippyNips
The way it was when i tried to post made it seem like it was the next page
I think Chaos Wind's role being the only thing that can drop a player's power level to below its original value that we know of so far, it's reasonable to think what Alchemist claimed could be a scum role to counter act Chaos Wind's.
I'm actually not leaning either way regarding Alchemist's role but
idk how serious you are with Krillin being evil yada yada but if you are I think that looks like TMI on Alchemist's alignment
- Hideri
Posted: Mon Jun 17, 2019 10:44 am
by Alchemist21
In post 3988, Cafe Stile wrote:Aren't we playing a Upick? Like...flavour doesn't suggest alignment or whatever
This is true, flavor doesn’t affect Alignment. It just affects abilities.