Ok hopefully this game has calmed down enough that I can actually play. I have a while, I'm gunna do some iso reading after catching up. If anyone has requests let me know, I probably won't give comments while catching up.
I didn't find Arte's fakeclaim as bad as other people did, though I did just look at the message they were trying to communicate rather than the specifics of how it would work out mechanically.
In post 3715, Dunnstral wrote:Or if it's not a counterclaim, somebody help me understand how it isn't, because I see two people claiming opposite things happened
It initially looked like whemestar was claiming a solid amount of information.
But then when Morph stepped forward saying a part of it didn't happen, Wheme stepped back saying he didn't say that. By extension, Wheme can do this for any part of the information.
So to me, it looks like a fakeclaim designed to look informative while also not being cc'able.
Would be intrigued to hear another result though.
In post 3934, Farkran wrote:
2) the STD kill probably comes from town? If scum have access to just 1 factional kill it must be toog
3) following up from point 2, it could point to NDMath scum rather than flea or sigmund.
This is pretty much where i am at with my current reasoning, everyone else is just a gutping or faded memory.
What is the connection between points 2 and 3?
I am finally now seeing Bell as town. Bit late I know.
Also am having the weirdest 'paranoia' that whitefire has the same role as me but probably shouldn't discuss that further.
This is a really good post, I want to keep it in my iso
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:20 pm
by MURDERCAT
Wow really no one warned me I was about to read 20 pages of nonsense?
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:22 pm
by notscience
Hey murder you’re about to read 20 pages of nonsense
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:24 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 3979, MURDERCAT wrote:Wow really no one warned me I was about to read 20 pages of nonsense?
You read 140 pages of nonsense, I don't know why this surprises you
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:26 pm
by MURDERCAT
fair
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:27 pm
by Ircher
In post 1010, Titus wrote:4. White Fire (Shiro/Firebringer) - Null town, only reserve is buddying.
5. Lady Lambdadelta - Weak town (solely bc past baggage, anyone else solid town)
These read as reads that you want to pivot away from later. Basically, you state that they are town for now, but when it becomes convenient, you will be able to change them due to your "reservations" now.
A real weak excuse
You can still read tone, but sure
Easy to fan flames
No. People just ignore your posts and give you a free pass because "post restriction means town". Granted, you did drop it; I'll give you that. Point still stands though that this "post restriction" of yours actively made it much harder to read you. Also, tone is irrelevant. People can fake whatever tone they like; it's one of the easiest things to fake. Want to fake confidence? Easy, just say things directly and with force. Want to appear uninterested? That's easy too; just complain a lot about being bored and lurk. Want to fake frustration? Just make your words forceful and if you are so inclined, throw in a few curses. Add in a "I'm leaving before I get extra angry," for added effect. With the post restriction, it becomes even easier to just have an abject absence of a tone.
In post 1044, WhemeStar wrote:I think I can read ircher pretty well unless he has changed up his meta. Haven’t played with him in a while. I’ll see when he starts making posts
I am curious if you still think that at this point in the game.
In post 1082, morph the cat wrote:It's the trend of large themes over the past few years to have scumteams that don't actually post that much
Is it that they end up lurking... or that they get drowned out? Another popular trend (and it didn't start in 2020) is for large themes to move at a ridiculously fast pace. Regardless, I don't put much stock in this kind of thing.
she's not pushing me for a single good reason her push on bingles failed bc it was on confirmed town and now she's trying again on me
but look at her posts asking for people to vote me they're all filled with "anya good vote, anya scum, please. vote anya." she's so desperate she must have good reasons right? nope not even a single one
In post 3114, Guillotina wrote:Sigmund turning out to be town leaves Flea exposed with my TMI suspicion. It is obvious we are gonna lose the Doctor tonight otherwise the wolves would be playing against their wincon, but if we can bag mafia today, the loss won't feel as huge.
This is such a hilariously bad post. Are you scum, Guillo? I think you are, just from the phrasing of this one post.
We'll get to that tomorrow.
VOTE: Anya
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:48 pm
by MURDERCAT
I have a sense that a decent number of the people shading me are scum
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:48 pm
by notscience
In post 3983, Ircher wrote:With the post restriction, it becomes even easier to just have an abject absence of a tone.
Tones my tell, you can ask the multiple people with games of experience reading me
And imo it’s pretty prevalent even with the post restriction sooooo
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:48 pm
by notscience
Hey azelf why are you so chatty this game I’ve never seen you post this much
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:54 pm
by notscience
In post 3988, MURDERCAT wrote:I have a sense that a decent number of the people shading me are scum
Please name names
I love tea.
Also I was going to reread tonight but I realized I don’t have my tablet charger
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 3:55 pm
by MURDERCAT
Spoiler: LLD and Anya
In post 2097, Anya wrote:how are 8 words like that ever gonna be out of someone's range anyone can say that
a toddler can say they float like a butterfly and sting like a bee doesn't make them Muhammad Ali
In post 2238, Anya wrote:starting to think guillo might be playing up the confidence act not sure how he can really believe the tabloid articles he's writing
In post 2245, Anya wrote:depends on the ticket prices and what regulations they have
In post 2709, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:Like I took a few days to reset my reads after another was pulled from under me and I think I want Anya dead.
I know they're weird and stuff by nature but it just feels... so...
is that bc most people are city dwellers and you lurk down in the sewers
In post 2739, Anya wrote:the confirmed bingles gave the badge of approval for ircher votes ages ago and still is yet collecting them is harder than finding diamonds in a coal mine
In post 2742, Bingle wrote:It's kind of weird that people are willing to sheep my weak case on Ircher based on it being where I was voting now that I've moved on to pushing Sigmund who has more votes, tbh.
sigmund's a lot more active and looks like he's being shoved for his account gimmick more than anything else though your reason makes more sense
I'm working on it, will probably save the actual analysis of votes on me for later though.
I do want to see how votes shifted from me to Titus
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 4:03 pm
by Guillotina
@Ircher are you still catching up or are you commenting on old posts on purpose?
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2021 4:09 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 3990, notscience wrote:Hey azelf why are you so chatty this game I’ve never seen you post this much
I had this conversation with Sigmund already.
Tl;dr, my activity varies pretty widely depending on my engagement in the game and my RL availability (and I have literally nothing going on at the moment).
There isn't really an I am sick as fuck option. I'm doing the best I can right now. I strongly feel Anya and G are teamed. I can't prove it but G's reaction is OMGUS for omgus sake. I could buy a certain amount of bias after our last game, but this just feels like they're hiding instead. There's no hunting, just whining.
When I asked G to give a read on Anya (who I had gut pings on at the time), they tried to pass the buck.
Look at their iso to this point. This post particularly pinged but there's no solving. Some fluff is ok but we're past fluff.
In post 1010, Titus wrote:1. Morph the Cat (fferyllt/Cabd) - Town
2. Dunnstral - Null town
3. Save the Dragons - I want to say town but I may be attributing some posts of them in my mind to Morph. Gmth town
4. White Fire (Shiro/Firebringer) - Null town, only reserve is buddying.
5. Lady Lambdadelta - Weak town (solely bc past baggage, anyone else solid town)
6. jjh927 Ircher - Null
7. Artemiana - Null scum
8. Sigmund - Null, gtmh town
9. Titus - Moonwalker
10. Bell - Townish
12. NDMath - lean scum
13. WhemeStar - Null, would compromise
14. notscience - Moderate town, hard with the PR
15. Anya - lean scum
16. Guillotina - Null, high priority to sort
17. Toogeloo - Weak town
18. Flea the Magician - Null (I need to sort them)
19. Chara - Weak town
20. Thestatusquo - I want to say town but keeps defending scum
21. MURDERCAT - Town
22. Farkran - Town
23. Bingle - Town
24. Something_Smart - Weak town
In post 475, Bell wrote:I have dug through 4 pages and I can't find his post and for some reason reason to just iso him.
Anya seems kind of free flow in that townie way but then she left and that killed my vibe.
In post 519, Bell wrote:Anya seems vaguely townie.
White fire seems postury, but in a good way.
Chara seems bored.
You seem fine so far.
Unsure why Jjh repped.
I feel that shea is vaguely scummy from an impressin that they didn't seem to be thinking about hunting, but more interested with giving opinions.
NS: I dunno I can't read poetry and haiku posers. Some times they're scum, sometimes they're town and I can't tell the difference.
I don't know what to think about LLD. I'll just let it lie.
I liked Dunn's angle shot. Though he is being proactive early which is opposite the trend I've seen.
I've mentioned Murdercat.
Titus is being her unreadable self. In that, I don't get why she chooses her reads or positions or the timing. She's walkin' out of tune from everybody else.
In post 1224, Bell wrote:I pretty strongly disagree with an Anya vote. I don’t know who A is and I don’t feel like guillotina is scum this game.