Memento Mafia - Over

[AurorusVox]

Also open to a GhostWriter lynch tbh.
Where has his townie goodness been all game?

[Amrun]

Why would you be conf town because Fate got killed, Katsuki? That doesn't make sense.

That post was explaining why my suspicions of you are diminishing, but reading is tech.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Oh hey I'm alive.

I'll be reading up but have an issue I've sent to AGM in PM.

For the moment just let me say I'll be ignoring Katsuki unless I'm voting for him. Don't expect any direct interactions from me to him since it would be a waste of my time and result in ranting and whining on his part.

My gut says that Grey is likely a very good vote now that LLD has flipped scum. Especially in light of his attempt to push "The scum in the 'dead' must be either MoI or ICB" when LLD flipped as such.

More later.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Ok ... on the more later thing ...

AGM is replacing me because I'm going to be V/LA with zero expected access to the internet for a week. Sigh. Why did you spammers have to burn through three game days in one RL week?

[gandalf5166]

VOTE: GI

[GreyICE]

... shit.

My read on the situation was obviously bollocks, and I can't blame you if I get lynched here.

I will say I'm normally a decent scumhunter, and I did have edmund pinned down. I hate playing games with Fate, because this shit ALWAYS HAPPENS. I can point to more games with him where I got mislynched because of his actions (funny fact - he hasn't had a town read on me since Hito's game, and I haven't been scum against him since Brotherhood, excepting one large where the other scum team killed him off after a day (he had a town read there, obv). Which is a straight emotional appeal, I know, but I'm tired of it. It's not fun for the rest of the thread, and it's not particularly fun for me anymore.

So, I'll throw straight meta defense. This is what happened in cupcake mafia. This is what happened in IPod Mafia. This is what happened in Llamafluff's game.

So I'd prefer if you guys let me live for a few more days, because we WILL catch scum.

At least let me read the fucking thread before you quicklynch me. Because this one is fucking derptastic. We DID get edmund, and his reaction to me was a large part of that. You think my scumbuddy cocked up reacting to his partner that badly?

[gandalf5166]

Unvote

I'll give you some time to put together a list of reads(a couple of days at most), but you're dying.

[Katsuki]

That post was explaining why my suspicions of you are diminishing, but reading is tech.

Ok. Your post was confusing, that's why I asked.

Still sheeping AV today.

[AurorusVox]

Grey why were you defending LLD if you haven't read the thread?
Game. Set. And match?

@MoI :'( sorry we kicked scum ass so hard

I'll re-read Grey x edmund, but someone who's name begins with G is getting noosed today.

[gandalf5166]

I'll re-read Grey x edmund, but someone who's name begins with G is getting noosed today.

[Amrun]

There is part of me that says grey wouldn't do that as scum, and being lld's boyfriend explains his actions...

Occam's razor demands blood, though.

[GhostWriter]

I actually did contribute yesterday. Granted, at the time, I thought we were in twilight with an LLD lynch having already happened, and then the mod showed up and posted a non-end-of-day votecount and it turned out we weren't. And the claims of me being cautious scum are kind of funny. In a "Fate is fighting my scumbuddy" situation, anyone who has played him knows the safest place to be is either sheeping him with reasons outside of any he may have said, or directly opposing the lynch in a way that seems protown enough. Sitting on the sidelines is probably the easiest way of catching his rage later down the line.

Anyway, I posted a list of reads at the "end" of yesterday, and I do believe most of it still stands, I just need to go back and double iso (I love this feature) a few people with both LLD and Edmund. Something I'm not liking right now, though, is the suspicion of GI. His actions from since Fate got into the game make sense for him as a player, and only add up to null for this game. And he's been fairly, I believe, pro-town. I've had him as town for a while now. With my belief that we have at least two more scum in the game, I like Gandalf and Amrun's responses to his most recent post, since they are two of my scumreads. Gandalf isn't showing confidence in his scumread, which I see as a towntell, and Amrun seems to be setting herself up for an "I should have listened to my gut" post after a GI-townflip.

[GhostWriter]

Nevermind, Amrun is town. She's just overthinking things.

[GhostWriter]

Amrun is town, Elli is town, GI is town. AV is town. That leaves Gandalf, Kat, and MoI. I doubt MoI is mafia. I am getting more of a town read on Gandalf now. Which leaves Kat. Which means that OMGUS suspicion he threw on me after I called him possible scum the first time, despite him never have directly mentioned me previously, was scumKatsuki flailing for no real reason other than because he's scum. Sadly, that doesn't leave me with a second read, so I'll have to go over the rest again and sift through some of my towntells that I feel each has made and look for angles.

[Katsuki]

I was flailing... at a time when I had no votes and no one was calling me scum?

LOL

Well this game is pretty much wrapped up anyways after GI and GW eat rope.

[GhostWriter]

Say what you want, there's no way you're town.

[Katsuki]

Ok.

[Amrun]

Say what you want, there's no way you're town.

Yeah this is never a good argument.

[Ellibereth]

Weekend V/LA sig etc.

[GreyICE]

Okay, so far AurousVox and GhostWriter are definitely town, Amrun is fairly solid, and Ellibereth isn't coming out too good. The hammer feels a bit forced after no comment on the wagon. Ellibereth's major talent as scum is doing nothing while looking townie for unidentifiable reasons, and if that doesn't describe his posts stick me in a dress and call me Shirley. Nothing summarizes everything he's done in thread.

Gandalf is a mess as well, although I admit that that's fairly alignment neutral for him. However he's mostly just been declaring whoever he likes scum and voting for them, except LLD. Which, well, I don't have much of a leg to stand on there, but better point after I flip I suppose.

So far, I'd put money on Gandalf or Ellibereth after this fiasco. AV is def town, and I feel good about Ghostwriter and Amrun

[Amrun]

you don't think gandalf's interaction with edmund makes him town?

[AurorusVox]

Grey, explain your GW townread please.

[AlmasterGM]

Day 4, Vote Count 1

I know what that's going to sound like when I knock on it. I know that's what going to feel like when I pick it up. See? Certainties. It's the kind of memory that you take for granted.

Amrun

(0)

AurorusVox

(0)

Ellibereth

(0)

gandalf5166

(0)

GhostWriter

(0)

GreyICE

(2) - Amrun, AurorusVox

Katsuki

(0)

MagnaofIllusion

(1) - Katsuki

Not voting

(5) - GhostWriter, GreyICE, gandalf5166, Ellibereth, gandalf5166

The deadline is Sunday, September 25th at 12pm EST.
Prods will be issued when the weekend is over if needed.
Searching for a replacement for MagnaofIllusion.

[Katsuki]

unvote, vote: GI

[AlmasterGM]

Meransiel replaces MagnaofIllusion.

gandalf5166, GhostWriter, and Ellibereth have been prodded.