Mafiascum.net

EBWOP: Xegarus early on didn't like BaldEagle prior to his soft-claim reveleation: His reaction was - Looks to me like he's just trying to force some reactions.
And its making him look like anti town pushing for a lynch.

I said Baldeagle is very chatty as town and is easy mislynch bait.

Ok, so...

GiF feels pretty strongly that this is scum-NS. Not sure NS and SD make sense as scum together.

Consolidated reads:


Eagle
Mac


Nati - GiF says null and can see a scum team with both NS and Nati, ffery says leaning town
Cait Sith
TiP
Cephrir
Trolling Fairy - GiF says null, ffery sasy leaning slightly town because Cabd posts are pure null but Nacho's substantive posts look town even though she disagrees with some of his reads


BRO
Sax


SD
Shodan
NS - GiF says scum, and ffery finds his argument that NS is forcing his town meta convincing

Oh, and my comments since the start are that I Don't like notscience, Xeg never commented on ns though.

I don't like salmonella or cephrir from what I remember. Need to re-skim this morning and make my reads more concrete/solid gut ones



Trying too hard to look town and the asking why people aren't townreading him looks really fake. Doesn't feel natural, any of his posts this game. Trying to duplicate his town game as much as possible, but it comes across not genuine.

Bert, you are scumreading Nati for his reads list. Mine is very close to his, and you didn't mention me in your reads. Why is that?

Agreed on at least all the scumreads SoS, though NS is the weakest one for me.

@Sho: The last sentence of my 54 makes a lot more sense when you know that I am very frequently lynched. I appreciate you bringing in a couple novel reads (CS and myself), but I could wish they were any good. Why didn't you comment on my 54 when I originally made it?

P-edit: Well that was a bit of a jump. Not sure how those posts don't end in a vote for me.

We didn't know what to think of you two

Plus can't tell who is posting. Also, we discussed this yesterday before your reads list was presented.

He informed me he had to quit last night.

Your last post is not taken into account.

P-edit: I didn't comment because I was having trouble getting into this game and staying interested

Thankfully Nacho is in this game so I should be able to submerge myself eventually

Been lrocrastinating on catching up with posts here every day

Notscience is much easier to read, Cephrir, and I don't know you

More confident in notscience scum

In post 404, Cephrir wrote:Agreed on at least all the scumreads SoS, though NS is the weakest one for me.

@Sho: The last sentence of my 54 makes a lot more sense when you know that I am very frequently lynched. I appreciate you bringing in a couple novel reads (CS and myself), but I could wish they were any good. Why didn't you comment on my 54 when I originally made it?

P-edit: Well that was a bit of a jump. Not sure how those posts don't end in a vote for me.

On my own, he'd be a weak scum read at worst. GiF's read plays pretty heavily into where he's placed. I trust him to read NS better than I can.

In post 405, Shodan wrote:We didn't know what to think of you two

Plus can't tell who is posting. Also, we discussed this yesterday before your reads list was presented.

He informed me he had to quit last night.

Your last post is not taken into account.

P-edit: I didn't comment because I was having trouble getting into this game and staying interested

Thankfully Nacho is in this game so I should be able to submerge myself eventually

Been lrocrastinating on catching up with posts here every day

Gif has made about three posts so far. He'll be posting more during the weekdays after this, I think. I spam pretty much whenever.

That was a pretty short gap in time between Nati's reads post and mine. :/

In post 408, Sound of Silence wrote:That was a pretty short gap in time between Nati's reads post and mine. :/

bad timing. we got done with discussions before 11:37 PM CST (your reads list timestamp), which is past normal computer access time for me - it's getting ready for beddie-bye time at that point

EBWOP: Still have had a gut scumread on notscience since the start of the game, so sticking with that as my most confident scumread

Also, I don't have to worry about dissonance now so I can be forthright in my reads and votes and such

In post 375, Sound of Silence wrote:I'm not sure he's even null, given what he's capable of as town.

>:C Stop setting unreasonable expectations for me.

Catching up now. Been absent from this game the past few days >.>

My expectations are quite reasonable.

Hydra dissonance of DP re: NS is annoying. Both people chainsawing are un-cc'd PRs. That looks bad for DP. His argument is blegh.

In post 324, Cephrir wrote:I want to see a lot more from TF and SoS today. We're not lynching anyone yet.

Why these two specifically?

In post 326, Cephrir wrote:I may need to look at Xenoblade or whatever it is.

You mean that game where ffery was scum and spammed up the thread to the point that her hydra had the most posts until day 7 or 8 despite having been lynched day 1?

She had a lot to say.

The CS/VS interaction goes entirely over my head.

In post 334, Cait Sith wrote:Mac shouldn't release reads. Make it easier to scum to counter what he's thinking and makes him more killable. x.x

This. Like, Mac shouldn't post reads and nobody should try to direct him so that scum are in as bad a position as possible for catching him out.

In post 343, Trolling Fairy wrote:i'm seriously loving this avatar but syr and cabd didn't like it that much, which makes me seriously seriously sad.

The avatar is great, you should keep it.

In post 345, Trolling Fairy wrote:BRO's open is pretty solid. I like his stance on TiP's claim in particular.

Why did you like it, given the context of you, ffery, mala, and mara all being in this game when noobtown-me got baited by it?

In post 376, notscience wrote:Good read on me Nati

10/10

welcome to the scumreads with Mac as well

>:C

Can you try acting like town if you're town and scumhunt? Be useful? Anything?

In post 385, notscience wrote:I make people defy their preconceptions about town

What, that town play in such a way that they demonstrate a town interest?

In post 387, notscience wrote:When I'm scum I play more protown

Not even joking

In post 399, Shodan wrote:Nat's last reads list is very scummy, which negates our initial townread, we agreed on this.

What about his reads list is scummy?

In post 401, Sound of Silence wrote:Not sure NS and SD make sense as scum together.

I don't think they do.

In post 412, Sound of Silence wrote:My expectations are quite reasonable.

I don't like this pressure

Also I would be voting NS right now except I don't know what he's at in terms of votes and don't want to accidentally hammer like a derp.

He's done literally nothing but spam up the thread, and I trust Mac and GiF here (former is conf-town, latter is a strong townread)

BRO wrote:

In post 324, Cephrir wrote:I want to see a lot more from TF and SoS today. We're not lynching anyone yet.

Why these two specifically?

Because I've played with them several times and am used to them being more proactive.

BRO wrote:

In post 326, Cephrir wrote:I may need to look at Xenoblade or whatever it is.

You mean that game where ffery was scum and spammed up the thread to the point that her hydra had the most posts until day 7 or 8 despite having been lynched day 1?

She had a lot to say.

I actually didn't know a thing about it other than ffery was scum in it.

I think Ceph is Town

Tammy and I talked a bit last night, but I want to talk to her more before I put out solid reads.

@bert:

Mind if you try and figure what's pinging your gut about us?

In post 414, BROseidon wrote:Also I would be voting NS right now except I don't know what he's at in terms of votes and don't want to accidentally hammer like a derp.

He's done literally nothing but spam up the thread, and I trust Mac and GiF here (former is conf-town, latter is a strong townread)

This is not really a scum or a town tell for him. I gathered some meta analysis a while ago on him. He's not really following either meta on what I have on him.

._.

Upon further reflection Ns is town.

In post 419, Cait Sith wrote:This is not really a scum or a town tell for him. I gathered some meta analysis a while ago on him. He's not really following either meta on what I have on him.

I'm not townreading NS, so I'm willing to defer to other townreads on sorting him.

Care to make a case on why he's town so I don't put him at L-1?

In post 416, Cephrir wrote:Because I've played with them several times and am used to them being more proactive.

Are you referring specifically to the Nacho/ffery heads of these hydras, or are you including Cabd/GiF in this?

In post 415, Syryana wrote:

Mod Announcement: Xegarus (and thus the Shodan hydra) has withdrawn from the game. Bert will remain playing alone. VC and OP have been updated to reflect this and the Shodan slot may now post only on Bert.

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Bert is RIDING SOLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

TROLL TIME

<3333333333333333333333333333333333333333

hahahahahaha

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

In post 422, BROseidon wrote:

In post 416, Cephrir wrote:Because I've played with them several times and am used to them being more proactive.

Are you referring specifically to the Nacho/ffery heads of these hydras, or are you including Cabd/GiF in this?

Largely, and Cabd to a lesser extent. I feel like AMOL gave me some decent insight on his thought process, though I don't know if I'll be able to make anything useful of it.