In post 399, Xayzeck wrote:Because some of these reads, like Aronis and Hiraki, are made with consideration to what happened AFTER you went for your trip, 316 .
Reads on Shinobi and I are vague as fuck, you didn't give me an alignment. You promised a full readlist, not shitreads.
Did you magically see into the future?
Did you really spend the day before the trip working on this "full readlist"? Because it's pretty empty.
I had a general real list of who was scum but I did some isos and reads while at the trip. It might be empty but that is all what I have to say
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2014 7:37 pm
by pieguyn
quit stealing my pagetops ;w;
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2014 7:42 pm
by Xayzeck
That's not a full readlist? Let me quote you on this matter:
In post 316, ZZZX wrote:I know I promised full reads today but I am posting from my 3g as my familly decided today is a good day for a field trip.
a few hours... hopefully... I promise for real! I got a full readlist nearly ready in my pc I have been working on since yesterday.
Nearly ready eh? Yeah I could do with that.
So Shinobi and my reads probably weren't done yet? Yeah I could do with that.
(Realised Aronis wasn't made with consideration after 316, but this is still an incredibly bad read)
Hiraki though? Reads made with consideration after 316. Probably did this after you came back?
So nearly half was undone, don't go promising full readlists. Why'd you need to lie about it?
Also for a full readlist I was expecting detailed explanations, linking to posts on what you observed and what you made out of it. 5 out of your 7 reads were just generalisation of play, only Hiraki and Rubicon came close to talking about what they did, SPECIFICALLY, that gave you a read on them.
I had to go ISO Rubicon to find out what you referring to, and I haven't found it yet. I'm still searching though don't worry, you don't have to come in do it for me, because you know, it's not like it's your readlist or anything like that.
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2014 7:59 pm
by ZZZX
In post 402, Xayzeck wrote:That's not a full readlist? Let me quote you on this matter:
In post 316, ZZZX wrote:I know I promised full reads today but I am posting from my 3g as my familly decided today is a good day for a field trip.
a few hours... hopefully... I promise for real! I got a full readlist nearly ready in my pc I have been working on since yesterday.
Nearly ready eh? Yeah I could do with that.
So Shinobi and my reads probably weren't done yet? Yeah I could do with that.
(Realised Aronis wasn't made with consideration after 316, but this is still an incredibly bad read)
Hiraki though? Reads made with consideration after 316. Probably did this after you came back?
So nearly half was undone, don't go promising full readlists. Why'd you need to lie about it?
Also for a full readlist I was expecting detailed explanations, linking to posts on what you observed and what you made out of it. 5 out of your 7 reads were just generalisation of play, only Hiraki and Rubicon came close to talking about what they did, SPECIFICALLY, that gave you a read on them.
I had to go ISO Rubicon to find out what you referring to, and I haven't found it yet. I'm still searching though don't worry, you don't have to come in do it for me, because you know, it's not like it's your readlist or anything like that.
readlist = who I think is scummy/not scummy with general reasoning.
PbPA = I explain someone's allignment with a wall of doom text
or at least thats how I consider them.
Posted: Thu Jun 26, 2014 2:17 am
by Hiraki
In post 391, ZZZX wrote:You basically said even if someone is scum you are not interested in lynching him? I don't want to be lynched but I see you refuse to scum hunt and focus only on hunting jester which is a jester tell
Are you actually reading this game? Serious question. If not, replace out please.
In post 391, ZZZX wrote:You basically said even if someone is scum you are not interested in lynching him? I don't want to be lynched but I see you refuse to scum hunt and focus only on hunting jester which is a jester tell
Are you actually reading this game? Serious question. If not, replace out please.
I quoted the part where you said that so yea I did.
Posted: Thu Jun 26, 2014 9:09 pm
by pieguyn
Shinobi has been prodded.
Posted: Thu Jun 26, 2014 11:44 pm
by ZZZX
Actually I just cant find the list in my pc. damn it. >.<
In post 391, ZZZX wrote:You basically said even if someone is scum you are not interested in lynching him? I don't want to be lynched but I see you refuse to scum hunt and focus only on hunting jester which is a jester tell
Are you actually reading this game? Serious question. If not, replace out please.
I quoted the part where you said that so yea I did.
No, you completely misrepresented my point of view, actually.
In post 391, ZZZX wrote:You basically said even if someone is scum you are not interested in lynching him? I don't want to be lynched but I see you refuse to scum hunt and focus only on hunting jester which is a jester tell
Are you actually reading this game? Serious question. If not, replace out please.
I quoted the part where you said that so yea I did.
No, you completely misrepresented my point of view, actually.
Then WHAT was your point of view?
Posted: Fri Jun 27, 2014 1:43 am
by Hiraki
If you actually took the time to read my post:
Hiraki wrote:If ZZZX is scum, I'm willing to ignore it for the time being because there is no reason to lynch him. Eventually that slot will replace out or the pressure exerted onto him will produce results.
The point wasn't that you would be confirmed scum to everyone, as your opinion states. The point was that if you were scum, and no one knew, I'd be willing to ignore you because there's no reason to lynch you.
Posted: Fri Jun 27, 2014 5:59 am
by ZZZX
In post 412, Hiraki wrote:If you actually took the time to read my post:
Hiraki wrote:If ZZZX is scum, I'm willing to ignore it for the time being because there is no reason to lynch him. Eventually that slot will replace out or the pressure exerted onto him will produce results.
The point wasn't that you would be confirmed scum to everyone, as your opinion states. The point was that if you were scum, and no one knew, I'd be willing to ignore you because there's no reason to lynch you.