Mafiascum.net

In post 395, MURDERCAT wrote:And then to go to immediately town reading from a wall that honestly was not that AI makes it seem like podo is not really forming his own reads.

How was townreading Maru when literally nobody else was not forming my own reads?

Both of you feel like Smith is a scummy candidate, yet you're focused on each other.

In fact, I fos Smith as well. His actions look kinda dumb this game.

Why don't the three of us, just hold hands, sing Kumbayah, and rope this guy?

VOTE: Smith

Both of you right now are reading town to me it just looks like the points you make which both look legitimate, contradict each either.

In post 401, Transcend wrote:Both of you feel like Smith is a scummy candidate, yet you're focused on each other.

In fact, I fos Smith as well. His actions look kinda dumb this game.

Why don't the three of us, just hold hands, sing Kumbayah, and rope this guy?

VOTE: Smith

I have stated before that I'd happily lynch Smith. I'd like to remind you of this, though:

In post 330, MURDERCAT wrote:I feel better about podoboq because both podoboq and smith are scummy to me, but podoboq is on smith.

In post 341, MURDERCAT wrote:I want to see who jumps on again and who doesn't and why. And yeah of course podo could be town thinking smith is scum, I still don't love voting with scum reads though.

In post 358, Transcend wrote:

In post 306, drmyshottyizsik wrote:anem is sucm. That reaction test was just a lie. And wen called on it after saying it was 2 tier btw, you just say oh nah it was nothing.

VOTE: anen

uhhh this is the most recent vote shotty has made, not sure why the log says he has a vote on me

(4): Aneninen, PenguinPower, MURDERCAT, Ranger
(3): DixC, karnos, podoboq
(2): Smithereens, drmyshottyizsik
(2): SirCakez, Transcend
(1): Chip Butty
(1): Maruchan

(0):

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

: (expired on 2016-07-02 13:04:34)

Smith case.

In post 62, Smithereens wrote:Imo Maruchan did well to get this game rolling. You could at the very least be a tad grateful. I dislike Sircakez calling it a big ball of fluff when literally it's one of the only posts made thus far that has attempted to progress the game. Why is Maruchan a big ball of fluff but nobody else is?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: SirCakez

Bad defense on Maruchan, relatively bad vote on Cakez.

In post 75, Smithereens wrote:Why don't you vote SirCakez Chip? Your vote is still RVS and you've brought up some relatively good reasons to be voting elsewhere..

In post 87, Smithereens wrote:

In post 84, SirCakez wrote:

In post 62, Smithereens wrote:Imo Maruchan did well to get this game rolling. You could at the very least be a tad grateful. I dislike Sircakez calling it a big ball of fluff when literally it's one of the only posts made thus far that has attempted to progress the game. Why is Maruchan a big ball of fluff but nobody else is?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: SirCakez

It was fluffy because it was all a big fencesit. It didn't really progress the game at all and I'm not sure why you think it did.
DixC's vote on Shotty for the dog story was really terrible as well.

Look closely, it generated a lot of material, asked questions to multiple players and contained a sufficient amount of things you could have taken issue with. Instead you chose to take issue with the fact that his post on the whole didn't condemn any one player...

It's a bit tall of an order for RVS in a game as slow as this don't you think?

Again extreme defense on Maruchan which doesn't sit well. Maruchan did help get the game rolling, but it didn't warrant all the defense on him that he got when he received at most 2 or 3 votes.

In post 128, Smithereens wrote:UNVOTE:
VOTE: podoboq

Votes podoboq for a dumb reason. Don't worry guys this won't last very long!

In post 141, Smithereens wrote:UNVOTE:
VOTE: drmyshottyizsik

well I'm happy with this.

13 posts later, evades his naked vote on podo to vote shotty when he got into that debacle with karnos (which feels TVT to me)

In post 165, Smithereens wrote:Trans is town ^_^

Don't think I deserved a townread alongside Maruchan. I looked at my ISO and I don't really think I towntold that hard. Feels more like Smith knowing I'm town, than him actually townreading me.

In post 187, Smithereens wrote:

In post 185, podoboq wrote:

In post 179, Transcend wrote:how come you jabbed at smith for his defense on maru but you somewhat low-key defend maru as well?

Smithereen defended Maru, but then voted me, when the only logic to vote me is that I townread Maru. It's inconsistent. Also, I did not "somewhat low-key defend maru." I thought I was pretty overt.

There was no defense for Maru intended just btw, it was supposed to be an attack on SirCakez for something I found really inconsistent myself about his attack on Maru. I think you should go back and read my post vs SirCakez because it raises a valid point which you missed.

I think you defended Maruchan more than you attacked SirCakez. In fact you pursued a lot of other shitty lynches instead of building your case on Cakez.

In post 249, Smithereens wrote:@Trans, If you think I'm a scum read I'd recommend this informative book to you by Dr Seuss and it's called Learn To Read.

Still unsure about Karnos though. Might be misguided townie who thinks he's onto something or generic scum.

What a towny way to respond to someone who foses you!!!!!

In post 287, Smithereens wrote:I didn't think you buy his reaction test so easily Trans...

I looked at this post and it honestly feels more like Smith manipulating me.

In post 315, Smithereens wrote:Scum team imo Ananenin + Shotty + Mudercat atm.

Don't like this team read. Shotty? Seriously? He evades his scumread on SirCakez??? Where did that go????

In post 336, Smithereens wrote:Anenenin/murdercat are two good wagons if you're still asking. Podoboq is almost certainly going to become a counter wagon because the scum can't choose between either of the first two.

Yuck.

For what it's worth:
VOTE: Smithereens

All I ask is that we get some votes Smith's way.

I dumped a lot of information that suggests Smith!Scum.

Also a lot of other people besides myself have had this guy as scum or scummy but have evaded his vote to pursue other lynches.

Now that the day is finalizing I think we need to settle on a lynch we all agree with, and this is the ideal candidate IMO.

PEDIT: Podo, what do you think of my case on him?

Ok, transcend I can do smith.

VOTE: smith

You are obv town now by the way, but I agree with your point about not looking super towny earlier. I'll default to your judgement about podo as I am still not liking how fast that wagon grew.

I mean I don't have both of you marked as solid town and you shouldn't base my reads off of mine, because I'm not extremely good at this game. I just think we should use this lynch on someone we can all agree is scum and figure out the rest from there. You and podo have both made good points to suggest each other as scum to the point of me thinking you might both be misguided town.

I think you might be right.

Every once in a while the random number generator works in my favor

In post 408, Transcend wrote:PEDIT: Podo, what do you think of my case on him?

I don't really agree with your thoughts on his interactions between Maru and Cakez. I think he did it to discredit Cakez, because he still voted me for townreading Maru. Well, he didn't actually explain his reasons, but that was the only real logic that was floating in the air when he naked voted me.

I think you excluded his scummiest post:

In post 138, Smithereens wrote:My vote looks sketchy~~

I had an irresistible urge to just lynch a fucker, I'm not gonna lie to you :3 I'm awful.

There's still time to unvote him and lynch someone else though...

For the most part, I think your case is pretty OK. Most of his posts are empty, and those which aren't are inconsistent among eachother.

Yeah that post is pretty bad upon a second glance. Now hopefully we can get some other players to vote this slot.

Anyways thoughts from the peanut gallery about this lynch would be appreciated. Because I don't think there's been much resistance on this guy AKA not anyone's die-hard TR.

Catch up here later

this isn't opportunistic, I've been saying for days smith is in my lynchpool.

VOTE: smithereens

PS: I've skimmed / mostly followed everything going on since my last post, my life is just been a little hectic. I got drunk for the first time in my life (after spending 8 months attempting to get drunk at every port visit I could to no avail), I'm currently massively hard-pushing on a "certification" of sorts at work that is majorly eating into all my free time/internet time/sleep time. And my watch schedule has shifted to one that encourages me to go to sleep before I get internet access unlocked.

All in all, I've here, and i'm still tracking, and my current thoughts are the same (vote within shotty smith and ranger, maybe with a murdercat vote being a willling alternative if the other option is a no lynch due to clock ticking). I still will continue with my walls again starting on thursday/friday when I get a little less hectic. Tomorrow is my final oral exam for my certification I'm being pressured to get so It's my priority right this second.

all in all, lovin this game, sorry about my activity, etc.

lynch smith

In post 218, Aneninen wrote:F-cking town: Murdercat, ChipButty, Karnos
Townish: SirCakez, Smithereens, Ranger
No idea yet: Transcend, DixC
Ghhhhhhh: Maruchan, Shotty
Scummy and needs to meet pigeons: Penguin, Podoboq

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Podoboq

I'm rating Anen nullTown for now. I don't know if this is just me, but I am struggling a bit in this game. By this stage I usually have a few players I have strong reads on - either Town or scum - but so far I haven't been able to really get a handle on what is going on here. Even Shotty is only a moderate scumread for me atm. Part of that is because I haven't put enough time in, so hopefully get it together here fairly soon.

I don't agree with all of Anen's reads here but I don't think any of them are awful. He's pushing podo fairly consistently, and I think it goes beyond possible distancing, so I don't think they will be scum together. Of the players on the scummy end of his list, I agree Shotty, and can understand the others. Maruchan is Townish for me, but I can understand the opposite view.

On the top end, I don't think I would have anyone in top tier yet - or, to put it another way, my top tier would just be moderate nullTown. I think Anen has Smithereens too high, still need to look more at the others.

In post 338, Ranger wrote:

SirCakez wrote:Why aren't you happy with the Smithereens wagon?

Because it has people I'm suspicious of on it, while being on a player I do not find suspicious.

Maruchan wrote:If lynch within smithereens ranger and shotty at this point

...Find a townflip guaranteed, we will!
{karnos, Aneninen}
{SirCakez, Smithereens}
{shotty, Chip Butty, Murdercat}
{DixC}
{Maruchan, Transcend}
{podoboq, PenguinPower}

In post 218, Aneninen wrote:F-cking town: Murdercat, ChipButty, Karnos
Townish: SirCakez, Smithereens, Ranger
No idea yet: Transcend, DixC
Ghhhhhhh: Maruchan, Shotty
Scummy and needs to meet pigeons: Penguin, Podoboq

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Podoboq

On the basis of Ranger's readlist, which bears some similarity to Anen's, I'm nullTown reading her also. She hasn't posted enough for this to be a strong read, but I have found that in games where we are both Town, her rankings look quite similar to mine. I haven't completed doing my reads yet, but I would say of both Anen's and Ranger's lists that they look "the right side up".

Both Anen and Ranger are Townish on Cakes and karnos, so I'll look at them next. Will revisit Ranger when I've done those and Transcend, MC etc.

Cakes has been V/LA for a while, which explains why he hasn't posted much. I don't see anything awful in his ISO. Will revisit when he has posted more. Not a priority for today.

In post 345, karnos wrote: My vote on smithereens is feeling stale, time for a change.

WTH is this?

I finally unvote him, and then everyone else decides to hop on the wagon?

Need to re-read and review.

In post 421, karnos wrote:

In post 345, karnos wrote: My vote on smithereens is feeling stale, time for a change.

WTH is this?

I finally unvote him, and then everyone else decides to hop on the wagon?

Need to re-read and review.

It has to be said that you gave a kind of nothing reason for moving on...

LOL I just bumped the thread but I have no idea how I did it...

Karnos come back! This lynch welcomes you with open arms!