Page 17 of 53
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 12:44 pm
by bji
In post 378, Sashaddin wrote:I'm happy this game is picking up pace again!
What I'm thinking about right now:
1. We haven't heard of the TexdoesHalo slot for the entire game
2. I like jumping on wagons but I have to have a reason to do it.
3. I don't find Creature that scummy (nor that towny either) to wagon him.
4. If Creature is town, I think he will be a great asset to town. If he's scum, we'll just get him later,
So... for those four points, I think I'm going to stick with Tex for now. I could give Creature a vote if someone can convince me so.
*Poke TexdoesHalo* bc we don't want a modkill.
Do you actually want to lynch Tex? Because it doesn't sound like you do. If you wanted to lynch him, a modkill should be just as good from your perspective; maybe even better. Because:
a. If Tex is modkilled and flips scum then this is just a good result. We want to lynch scum!
b. If Tex is modkilled and flips town, then:
- We still have more time in Day 1 to discuss and select another Day 1 lynch
- We will at least have one fewer town to mislynch, making the odds of hitting scum that much better on Day 1
I just can't see how, if you really do want to lynch Tex, you'd be so worried about mod kill.
And if you actually want Tex lynched, then it is I think a net positive from your position because you get what is tantamount to
two
lynches before the scum get a night kill. Unless you think that a NK is more valuable to town for info than another lynch; but even if you do think that, you can just vote for no lynch after the modkill and the effect is the same as if Tex had been lynched. instead of modkilled.
Did you not realize this?
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 12:45 pm
by Lady Angel
Votecount 1.9:
Bji: 1 (Garmr)
Texdoeshalo: 2 (Sashaddin, ReaperOfSouls)
ReaperOfSouls: 2 (Irrelephant11, Skitter30)
Creature: 2 (bji, Clemency)
If this is incorrect please notify me as to what needs to be changed. I write these by hand and thus mistakes are inevitable.
Not voting: TexdoesHalo, Creature
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
Day 1 will end on December 1st, 2018 at 3:30 PM PST or 10 days, 23 hours, and 46 minutes from this post.
The following players have not posted since the last votecount and will be prodded if they have not posted before the next one, unless they are V/LA: ReaperOfSouls (V/LA, will be prodded if he does not post before the next votecount)
Texdoeshalo has been prodded. He will be forcibly replaced out if he does not post within 24 hours or gets prodded again.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 1:46 pm
by ReaperOfSouls
In post 401, Lady Angel wrote:Votecount 1.9:
Bji: 1 (Garmr)
Texdoeshalo: 2 (Sashaddin, ReaperOfSouls)
ReaperOfSouls: 2 (Irrelephant11, Skitter30)
Creature: 2 (bji, Clemency)
If this is incorrect please notify me as to what needs to be changed. I write these by hand and thus mistakes are inevitable.
Not voting: TexdoesHalo, Creature
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
Day 1 will end on December 1st, 2018 at 3:30 PM PST or 10 days, 23 hours, and 46 minutes from this post.
The following players have not posted since the last votecount and will be prodded if they have not posted before the next one, unless they are V/LA: ReaperOfSouls (V/LA, will be prodded if he does not post before the next votecount)
Texdoeshalo has been prodded. He will be forcibly replaced out if he does not post within 24 hours or gets prodded again.
Then replace me. I thought thats what the v/la was for. Been at hospital for 3 days. Family>mafia any day. And the elephants scum game isnt very good.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 2:30 pm
by bji
In post 402, ReaperOfSouls wrote: In post 401, Lady Angel wrote:Votecount 1.9:
Bji: 1 (Garmr)
Texdoeshalo: 2 (Sashaddin, ReaperOfSouls)
ReaperOfSouls: 2 (Irrelephant11, Skitter30)
Creature: 2 (bji, Clemency)
If this is incorrect please notify me as to what needs to be changed. I write these by hand and thus mistakes are inevitable.
Not voting: TexdoesHalo, Creature
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
Day 1 will end on December 1st, 2018 at 3:30 PM PST or 10 days, 23 hours, and 46 minutes from this post.
The following players have not posted since the last votecount and will be prodded if they have not posted before the next one, unless they are V/LA: ReaperOfSouls (V/LA, will be prodded if he does not post before the next votecount)
Texdoeshalo has been prodded. He will be forcibly replaced out if he does not post within 24 hours or gets prodded again.
Then replace me. I thought thats what the v/la was for. Been at hospital for 3 days. Family>mafia any day. And the elephants scum game isnt very good.
Are you playing against your win condition or are you just calling Irrelephant scum?
Also, sorry that you have to be at the hospital, but no need to be an ass about it.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 2:32 pm
by bji
In post 403, bji wrote: In post 402, ReaperOfSouls wrote: In post 401, Lady Angel wrote:Votecount 1.9:
Bji: 1 (Garmr)
Texdoeshalo: 2 (Sashaddin, ReaperOfSouls)
ReaperOfSouls: 2 (Irrelephant11, Skitter30)
Creature: 2 (bji, Clemency)
If this is incorrect please notify me as to what needs to be changed. I write these by hand and thus mistakes are inevitable.
Not voting: TexdoesHalo, Creature
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
Day 1 will end on December 1st, 2018 at 3:30 PM PST or 10 days, 23 hours, and 46 minutes from this post.
The following players have not posted since the last votecount and will be prodded if they have not posted before the next one, unless they are V/LA: ReaperOfSouls (V/LA, will be prodded if he does not post before the next votecount)
Texdoeshalo has been prodded. He will be forcibly replaced out if he does not post within 24 hours or gets prodded again.
Then replace me. I thought thats what the v/la was for. Been at hospital for 3 days. Family>mafia any day. And the elephants scum game isnt very good.
Are you playing against your win condition or are you just calling Irrelephant scum?
Also, sorry that you have to be at the hospital, but no need to be an ass about it.
By which I meant, acting like the mod is being so unreasonable, which is how your post came off. Because the mod hasn't said you'll be replaced, just prodded.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 3:01 pm
by ReaperOfSouls
I don't know what alignment irrell is. All I know as soon as I put the v/la status up he/she has been hell bent on getting votes on me. I informed the mod the reason for my being away. I have no problem with her. But if I'm going to be a distraction then I'll replace out. I don't have time to worry about taking time to check this thread because someone uses a known absence to try and wagon.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 3:29 pm
by ReaperOfSouls
In post 404, bji wrote: In post 403, bji wrote: In post 402, ReaperOfSouls wrote: In post 401, Lady Angel wrote:Votecount 1.9:
Bji: 1 (Garmr)
Texdoeshalo: 2 (Sashaddin, ReaperOfSouls)
ReaperOfSouls: 2 (Irrelephant11, Skitter30)
Creature: 2 (bji, Clemency)
If this is incorrect please notify me as to what needs to be changed. I write these by hand and thus mistakes are inevitable.
Not voting: TexdoesHalo, Creature
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
Day 1 will end on December 1st, 2018 at 3:30 PM PST or 10 days, 23 hours, and 46 minutes from this post.
The following players have not posted since the last votecount and will be prodded if they have not posted before the next one, unless they are V/LA: ReaperOfSouls (V/LA, will be prodded if he does not post before the next votecount)
Texdoeshalo has been prodded. He will be forcibly replaced out if he does not post within 24 hours or gets prodded again.
Then replace me. I thought thats what the v/la was for. Been at hospital for 3 days. Family>mafia any day. And the elephants scum game isnt very good.
Are you playing against your win condition or are you just calling Irrelephant scum?
Also, sorry that you have to be at the hospital, but no need to be an ass about it.
By which I meant, acting like the mod is being so unreasonable, which is how your post came off. Because the mod hasn't said you'll be replaced, just prodded.
My win condition is the same as 6 other players.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 4:00 pm
by bji
OK, thanks, I really did not understand your initial post -- I actually thought you might be throwing the game out of frustration with the mod.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 4:14 pm
by ReaperOfSouls
In post 407, bji wrote:OK, thanks, I really did not understand your initial post -- I actually thought you might be throwing the game out of frustration with the mod.
No. And I know no one knows me on this site. But that is one of my biggest peeves. I honestly just needed a few days to take care of the things that I needed to do in real life without having to worry about possibly fighting off a wagon. I don't want to be a distraction for anyone let alone the players with my alignment. I havent had an issue except in this game. And it really seems like from one player. Just seems like to push when someone is known to be gone isn't very townish. Now I have to get some sleep. There are things I need to do in the am in preparation of the most beautiful girl in the world coming home for the first time.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 4:34 pm
by bji
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 4:36 pm
by ReaperOfSouls
Thank you. My first grand child. I have had Grand Dog duty as well. So back and forth to hospital and everything. She's absolutely perfect.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 4:55 pm
by Sashaddin
In post 400, bji wrote:Do you actually want to lynch Tex? Because it doesn't sound like you do. If you wanted to lynch him, a modkill should be just as good from your perspective; maybe even better. Because:
a. If Tex is modkilled and flips scum then this is just a good result. We want to lynch scum!
b. If Tex is modkilled and flips town, then:
- We still have more time in Day 1 to discuss and select another Day 1 lynch
- We will at least have one fewer town to mislynch, making the odds of hitting scum that much better on Day 1
I just can't see how, if you really do want to lynch Tex, you'd be so worried about mod kill.
And if you actually want Tex lynched, then it is I think a net positive from your position because you get what is tantamount to two lynches before the scum get a night kill. Unless you think that a NK is more valuable to town for info than another lynch; but even if you do think that, you can just vote for no lynch after the modkill and the effect is the same as if Tex had been lynched. instead of modkilled.
Did you not realize this?
I am the guy that needs info and to me a wagon is more informative than a nightkill, because you get to see who got on the wagon, in what order, how soon etc. You don't get any of this with the modkill. Plus it's still a kill, so that's 3 players gone on the first day. So if Tex and the lynched guy flip green, that's 3 townies less for Day 2 and one less lynch available. I think you prefer having a good (scum/town) ratio, but I prefer having an extra lynch. I posted in
228 exactly why. So to answer your question: yes, but I'd prefer not to do it.
I don't want to expressly lynch Tex, I'm just frustrated at his slot for being dormant. But that new wagon didn't seem better to me so I lazily stayed with Tex.
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 4:57 pm
by Sashaddin
Gratz!
Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2018 9:22 pm
by Garmr
Congrats reaper.
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 3:46 am
by Irrelephant11
congratulations reaper!
the AtE is working, I'll VOTE: creature and see how that goes
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 4:02 am
by ReaperOfSouls
Thanks everyone. Mom and baby are doing great. Here for 5 minutes before I head to the hospital. I honestly don't have a read on creature. No time to study the ISO. But if you all want to I will lead my vote to the wagon in order for those that are here to apply the pressure needed. Just know I am doing it to further this direction along. I just won't be here. Let me know quick. Taking dog out for a bathroom break.
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 4:07 am
by Irrelephant11
You can if you want. Your vote would be L-1
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 4:09 am
by ReaperOfSouls
That's why I asked. Pressure is good. But I didn't want it set up for someone to quick hammer them. Sorry I don't remember off hand the term that is used on this site.
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 4:14 am
by ReaperOfSouls
In post 417, ReaperOfSouls wrote:
That's why I asked. Pressure is good. But I didn't want it set up for someone to quick hammer them. Sorry I don't remember off hand the term that is used on this site.
VOTE: Creature
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 4:21 am
by Garmr
I don't mind hammering creature slot because I had a slight scum read on it from raya earlier on, but I am in no rush and want to hear more on reapers thoughts first.
You had the options to vote elsewhere or not at all and just make a case. What made you pick option 3 and put creature at l-1?
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 5:13 am
by Creature
lol wtf we're not hammering anyone now
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 5:14 am
by Creature
In post 415, ReaperOfSouls wrote:Thanks everyone. Mom and baby are doing great. Here for 5 minutes before I head to the hospital. I honestly don't have a read on creature. No time to study the ISO. But if you all want to I will lead my vote to the wagon in order for those that are here to apply the pressure needed. Just know I am doing it to further this direction along. I just won't be here. Let me know quick. Taking dog out for a bathroom break.
Is this basically a "Can I vote Creature?" "Yes, sure"?
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 5:15 am
by Creature
What are you expecting to happen? For the mod to confirm my alignment out of nowhere?
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 5:16 am
by Creature
Ok let me see
bji and Clem have no idea what they're doing
nor Irre nor Reaper
Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2018 5:16 am
by Creature
Then there's this crappy shade