In post 340, profii wrote:Interestingly you call it scum team 1 and scum team 2 when someone else just openly said the obvious 2nd choice of werewolf...
Considering your word choice is probably more scummy than the dude who didnt
Why is werewolf the "obvious 2nd choice"? Why does Kirari's choice of nomenclature carry so much weight with u?
I mean, why in the world is it "scummy" that I didn't call the 2nd scum team wolves?
i feel like you were more conscious of your word choice, whereas the other post just said werewolves without worrying... I feel like scum would concern themselves with details like that more than town.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:23 am
by gobbledygook
Hello. I am town. I will be posting maybe once a day.
This is my one post for today.
Goodbye!
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:26 am
by Yiley
I'll need to go see if hectic plays every d1 like this but for someone who claims to be lurking/observing he is posting a lot of nothing
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:27 am
by Nero Cain
calling the scum teams 1 and 2 is me being conscious? This seems very stretchy and reminds me of your scum game.
In post 340, profii wrote:Interestingly you call it scum team 1 and scum team 2 when someone else just openly said the obvious 2nd choice of werewolf...
Considering your word choice is probably more scummy than the dude who didnt
Why is werewolf the "obvious 2nd choice"? Why does Kirari's choice of nomenclature carry so much weight with u?
I mean, why in the world is it "scummy" that I didn't call the 2nd scum team wolves?
i feel like you were more conscious of your word choice, whereas the other post just said werewolves without worrying... I feel like scum would concern themselves with details like that more than town.
This really seems like a nothing point. This seems more like a matter of personal nomenclature than something one really worries about the wording on. Maybe there's something here but I'm not buying it yet.
In post 340, profii wrote:Interestingly you call it scum team 1 and scum team 2 when someone else just openly said the obvious 2nd choice of werewolf...
Considering your word choice is probably more scummy than the dude who didnt
Why is werewolf the "obvious 2nd choice"? Why does Kirari's choice of nomenclature carry so much weight with u?
I mean, why in the world is it "scummy" that I didn't call the 2nd scum team wolves?
i feel like you were more conscious of your word choice, whereas the other post just said werewolves without worrying... I feel like scum would concern themselves with details like that more than town.
This really seems like a nothing point. This seems more like a matter of personal nomenclature than something one really worries about the wording on. Maybe there's something here but I'm not buying it yet.
It's one of many "I don't think it's a thing, but can see why someone who is genuinely scumhunting could think of was" in the game.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:34 am
by kagesong
Okay, officially catching up.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:37 am
by profii
In post 403, Nero Cain wrote:calling the scum teams 1 and 2 is me being conscious? This seems very stretchy and reminds me of your scum game.
I'm trying to cast my mind back to when we've been scum together but it's been too long
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:39 am
by Nero Cain
What would u have called the 2 scum teams?
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:41 am
by Cat Scratch Fever
In post 393, AaronFrost wrote:bob I've already answered why I think TSE is likely town. It's not a read I'm willing to die on, but it's one of the only reads I have right now.
If you want me to comment on his actual play, there's nothing AI. The scum motivated wagon on him is what points to him being town. I'm not gonna keep repeating myself.
Do you think what TSE described in 364 is truthful? Namely that he didn't realize there were votes on him before he claimed?
: Uncrowned, UltimatePlank, kagesong, Hectic, Pine, pisskop, Jamelia, davesaz, Not Known 15, Rhinox, QuantumQuasar, Eeveelution Army, dsjstr, Non Imh, eth0s, Amrun, Golden Robster, NotAJumbleOfNumbers, Something_Smart, hersho, ar98mubarik, clidd, gobbledygook, VaultDweller
50 alive, 26 to lynch
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:41 am
by kagesong
In post 41, Something_Smart wrote:I didn't suggest info lynching? I suggested just playing the game normally, which is probably going to result in a scramble to find a wagon amenable to 26 people and the result is probably going to be a pretty bad lynch... but the events that led to it will still be more useful than a policy lynch.
As of this post, I agree with this position. I'm clearly behind. Taking notes, etc.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:43 am
by NotAJumbleOfNumbers
In post 41, Something_Smart wrote:I didn't suggest info lynching? I suggested just playing the game normally, which is probably going to result in a scramble to find a wagon amenable to 26 people and the result is probably going to be a pretty bad lynch... but the events that led to it will still be more useful than a policy lynch.
In post 340, profii wrote:Interestingly you call it scum team 1 and scum team 2 when someone else just openly said the obvious 2nd choice of werewolf...
Considering your word choice is probably more scummy than the dude who didnt
Why is werewolf the "obvious 2nd choice"? Why does Kirari's choice of nomenclature carry so much weight with u?
I mean, why in the world is it "scummy" that I didn't call the 2nd scum team wolves?
i feel like you were more conscious of your word choice, whereas the other post just said werewolves without worrying... I feel like scum would concern themselves with details like that more than town.
Maybe I missed it but do you have a reason why you think scum team 1 and 2 is more scummy than someone saying wolves? I havent played mafia here in a long time, are wolves more common in games with 2 scum teams?
I respect that. Do you also hate Day 1? If you're okay with it, would you like to conglomerate into a hydra for this game?
My role is: Town Mason. What about yours?
In post 340, profii wrote:Interestingly you call it scum team 1 and scum team 2 when someone else just openly said the obvious 2nd choice of werewolf...
Considering your word choice is probably more scummy than the dude who didnt
Why is werewolf the "obvious 2nd choice"? Why does Kirari's choice of nomenclature carry so much weight with u?
I mean, why in the world is it "scummy" that I didn't call the 2nd scum team wolves?
i feel like you were more conscious of your word choice, whereas the other post just said werewolves without worrying... I feel like scum would concern themselves with details like that more than town.
Maybe I missed it but do you have a reason why you think scum team 1 and 2 is more scummy than someone saying wolves? I havent played mafia here in a long time, are wolves more common in games with 2 scum teams?
nah just my instinct would be to call the 2 scum teams different things... it's based on absolutely no previous games on this site to be fair.
if anything it's less likely that I'd mix them up than if i said red scum blue scum
if that's what you'd call them y did you prod kirari about calling a 2nd team wolves?
In post 303, profii wrote:how do you know the other scum faction are werewolves ?
and then use kirari to chide me over using scum team 1 and 2.
Also
strongly disagree
with Fonz that you are doing scum hunting. Light pushing me over using not wolves and throwing out a pressure point but meaningless q @ kirari seems very surface lvl @ best.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:56 am
by Elsa Jay
TSE replacing out instead of just actually playing the game? Sigh.
I hate tactical replace outs very much.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:57 am
by Wake1
I see the auto-votecounter is not working?
I could have sworn it automatically collects votes and posts then automatically, or do I post them? (It's been a long while.)
After work sometime tomorrow morning I'll try to figure out why it's not auto-posting the VCs.
Posted: Sun Mar 08, 2020 11:59 am
by Nero Cain
someone said it collects the vote but you have to do something to tell it to post a vc
if anything it's less likely that I'd mix them up than if i said red scum blue scum
if that's what you'd call them y did you prod kirari about calling a 2nd team wolves?
In post 303, profii wrote:how do you know the other scum faction are werewolves ?
and then use kirari to chide me over using scum team 1 and 2.
Also
strongly disagree
with Fonz that you are doing scum hunting. Light pushing me over using not wolves and throwing out a pressure point but meaningless q @ kirari seems very surface lvl @ best.
first bit - because i figured if i probe this sort of thing someone might react in a slippy kind of 'oops that's what my PM said kind of way'
2nd bit - i dont know what chide means but kirari didnt really react (though there is every chance i missed it if they did) and my gut is just more bothered by scum 1/2 than werewolves.
