Mafiascum.net

Alright, just testing.

I also don't townread SS, btw

- Dumber

In post 401, Dumb and Dumber wrote:I also don't townread SS, btw

- Dumber

Null read? Or scum read?

I like them so I'm curious as to your reasoning

Hey, I'm back from vacation last week and job interviews yesterday, and I've been spending most of today reading and making reads. I'll admit that I froze up a couple times when thinking about coming back and doing this, and I'm really sorry for not posting since the beginning. I'll be posting more soon, but first I'm gonna

VOTE: NorwegianboyEE

and joey, like, I'm ok with you calling me alligator but please use my listed pronouns

The plot thickens

That is a post

Is it tho?

Technically, yeah

In post 403, Jackel98 wrote:Hey, I'm back from vacation last week and job interviews yesterday, and I've been spending most of today reading and making reads. I'll admit that I froze up a couple times when thinking about coming back and doing this, and I'm really sorry for not posting since the beginning. I'll be posting more soon, but first I'm gonna

VOTE: NorwegianboyEE

and joey, like, I'm ok with you calling me alligator but please use my listed pronouns

My bad, in my head an alligator was ''a he'' by default

In post 358, BananaCucho wrote: 2nd part: I appreciate your answer to this question. I also found Bee to be townie, but now they appear to be somewhat... apathetic? Towards the game. Would you agree with that, and would the apathy drive them more into the town column or the scum column for you?

I don't think they're being apathetic, or at least not anymore than they were at the start of the game if you ignore the post restriction stuff. Haven't seen scum!bee so I'd have to glance through a scum game or two of his to answer that.

In post 374, Dumb and Dumber wrote:

In post 346, NDMath wrote:I agree with the third section and at the time I scumread norwee and redtea.

Who do you currently scumread then?

- Dumber

redtea. Probably Jackel but would like more from her before I'm sure. Sorta S_S but I trust others reads of him much more than my own.

I'm getting to this I swear to god

In post 393, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 390, Starbuck wrote:I think their lack of participation sucks, too, but when you bring an outside the game element into it, that's where I have a problem.

They haven't posted anywhere on site since Friday. That's a fact. I would, instead, call on the mod to prod or replace because it seems Jackal might not have the time.

If not Jackel then who? Has your read on redtea changed at all from their latest posts? I don't see them as a better lynch alternative at this time

@Starbuck, hoping you answer this

In post 410, Porkens wrote:I'm getting to this I swear to god

Is there a reason why you've yet to place a vote on anyone?

Yeah - I don't have a clue. I'll put something together tomorrow

In post 413, Porkens wrote:Yeah - I don't have a clue. I'll put something together tomorrow

As in don't have a clue who to vote?

As in I don't have any reads because I haven't even skimmed everything yet.

Ah. lol okay.

Are you a serial killer?

I wish lol

I actually have historically done very poorly as neutral/neutral evil roles tbh. As mafia I'll usually bus my partners for that sweet sweet town cred

It's still fun to stab tho lol. Here I am tho, no knives and no votes... for now at least heheh

In fact the first time I rolled neutral evil I rolled witch in a 25 person event on my home site and I was lynched first

That shit was humbling

In post 403, Jackel98 wrote:I'll be posting more soon, but first I'm gonna

VOTE: NorwegianboyEE

That’s it? Give me yo reasonings behind the vote.

Ok, so my reads, scores from -3 (Scum) to +3 (Townie):

I hate that I think Joey_ is my strongest townread. The way he thinks, the way he writes, it all really annoys me, but it's coming from a place that I think is townie, and he seems to be putting a lot of effort into that. He believes his reads, however wrong I think they are. +3

My strongest scumread is definitely NEE. On the one hand, I recognize that this could be seen as OMGUS, but it really strikes me as odd how, despite being the first one to vote for me in 219 and repeatedly putting me as his strongest scumread, he waits until 288 to give a reason beyond not having a townread, and even there he only echoes Banana. In 312, he finally posts original reasons, although I disagree with the reasons. The rest of his reasoning is agreeing with Joey, eliminate lurkers, and the potential of more info. This, his other scumreads being mostly based on inactivity, what looked to maybe be a failed attempt at a wagon on catboi (this is mostly gut tbh), and that weird trying to get Starbuck with a gotcha in 394 just makes me really read this slot as scum. Idk, the rest of his interactions, especially with Banana and Joey, feel like attempts to buddy or just be jocular or whatever. -3

After NEE is D&D, but they're a significantly weaker scumread. I don't understand their reads, and that's mostly what they talk about. This read/lean is really just mostly feelings. -1½

Mechanically, Banana is probably town. I'm ambivalent about their posting. They are active, but their posts aren't really AI, and their switching between being open and reticent about their role annoys me, but that is probably just paranoia about the possibility of a mafia corruption redirector or whatever posing as a stump, which is really unlikely considering their lack of a vote. -½

S_S hasn't interacted with many people, despite being relatively active post-wise. He's kept the same vote since post 62. -½
Is your vote still where you want it? What are your current reads and opinions?

[Doing more explained reads isn't possible if I want to finish tonight, considering I did fall asleep in the middle already so here goes]

Catboi: +1½
androgybee: +¾
redtea: +1

the rest: 0

Joey_ wrote: My bad, in my head an alligator was ''a he'' by default

No problem, just figured I'd say something now, while it's still relatively early.

In post 411, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 393, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 390, Starbuck wrote:I think their lack of participation sucks, too, but when you bring an outside the game element into it, that's where I have a problem.

They haven't posted anywhere on site since Friday. That's a fact. I would, instead, call on the mod to prod or replace because it seems Jackal might not have the time.

If not Jackel then who? Has your read on redtea changed at all from their latest posts? I don't see them as a better lynch alternative at this time

@Starbuck, hoping you answer this

Oh, apologies. I missed it.

In regards to Jackal, I'm concerned about the lack of patience for a returning player because I just recently returned myself and faced something similar in my first game back. So I find the push there to be a bit opportunistic and taking advantage of a situation where there is someone who is clearly rusty and might need some time to settle in.

My redtea read hasn't changed. I do see them as a good alternative. NEE is creeping that direction for me, as well, given the above in regards to Jackal.

Ahhh, and that post above is exactly why I think Jackal needed some breathing room.