Mafiascum.net

In post 398, innocentvillager wrote:Were u scum in a previous pyp and u chose a low number while ur teammates chose high?

Nah I've only drafted as town

In post 396, catboi wrote:

In post 395, innocentvillager wrote:

In post 383, skitter30 wrote:

In post 378, catboi wrote:1000000

O.o fair enuf
Ok i no longer find that suspicious, but i do find your posting somewhat off still

can someone link the catboi game I can’t parse the skitter/catboi interaction

NO!!!!!

ok I’m still confused I guess then

whatever I should really take a break from this game idk why I’m still here guess I’m just that bored

In post 402, innocentvillager wrote:ok I’m still confused I guess then

Well of course, I am here

In post 393, catboi wrote:

In post 383, skitter30 wrote:

In post 378, catboi wrote:1000000

O.o fair enuf
Ok i no longer find that suspicious, but i do find your posting somewhat off still

Okay how

I dont know exactly
- sleepless vote felt like weird timing (even tho you made a fair point), like its weird to vote someone based on p2 while you're still catching up on several more pages
- midway tr also feels off (and tbh if anything that feels tmi to me)
- not sure i like the flow trap vote. Like i get why you think they might be just spamming but i'm not sure i get that vibe
- i dont like your take on my dats read but i will admit i might just be annoyed by this one

None of these things are inherently bad or damning but the cumulative picture just feels kinda off

In post 398, innocentvillager wrote:Were u scum in a previous pyp and u chose a low number while ur teammates chose high?

No he was town and did indeed choose an absurdly high number, so my feelings of being suspicious of him for doing that here is kinda baseless

In post 404, skitter30 wrote:

In post 393, catboi wrote:

In post 383, skitter30 wrote:

In post 378, catboi wrote:1000000

O.o fair enuf
Ok i no longer find that suspicious, but i do find your posting somewhat off still

Okay how

I dont know exactly
- sleepless vote felt like weird timing (even tho you made a fair point), like its weird to vote someone based on p2 while you're still catching up on several more pages
- midway tr also feels off (and tbh if anything that feels tmi to me)
- not sure i like the flow trap vote. Like i get why you think they might be just spamming but i'm not sure i get that vibe
- i dont like your take on my dats read but i will admit i might just be annoyed by this one

None of these things are inherently bad or damning but the cumulative picture just feels kinda off

Shrug, I read linearly and reacted to stuff as I was catching up. That's...basically normal as far as I know? Why would you actually have a problem with that? I find mwb fairly readable and in fact think he's probably one of the more towny people in the game. I find like basically nothing flow trap has posted to be town indicative and the signal to nose ratio there is incredibly low. My reaction to that Datisi read was only, like, half-serious, I'm not pushing you over it

For the first point - well, you obviously didnt know what happened between p2 and whatever page we were on at the time when you voted, and i feel like most people finish reading and then choose to vote?

Like i'm not objecting to the notion of reading lineraly obviously, i'm objecting ti the timing of the vote given the context of everything else that was happening

And for the rest - meh. Idk the strength of the midway read seems a little too strong given what they've posted thus far

~
But maybe i should outsource this read on u to faker

In post 405, skitter30 wrote:

In post 398, innocentvillager wrote:Were u scum in a previous pyp and u chose a low number while ur teammates chose high?

No he was town and did indeed choose an absurdly high number, so my feelings of being suspicious of him for doing that here is kinda baseless

oh right lmao that was the other possibility

In post 362, Andante wrote:

In post 360, catboi wrote:

In post 330, Datisi wrote:

In post 303, Andante wrote:

In post 295, innocentvillager wrote:well ok the benefits of a massclaim are to lock scum into a claim and I think their picks say a lot about their priorities and stuff

We have draft info too

We can read into this kind of stuff and share what we all put in for the draft etc and unravel the whole auction

It’s not completely dumb

See, here's what I don't like, your 27th post in this game was "how bad is a massclaim" after about 20 posts of "let me defend why I picked the number I picked" like, something feels VERY off here, and I think the simple answer is just, you're not town. Like, you asked about massclaim, jumped straight into making "reads". Something feels very off.

oh yeah it was this post

this seemed a bit too effort-y for scum who's faking reads early

That is reasonable, probably more nuance than she has in her scum game

ok, you already have me as a sr? you don't have to tr me, but like, a sr??

I was not implying I scumread you

My computer broke so all my activity will have to be on mobile:<

Noticing while ISOing Andante that I missed 322 from flow trap (because I don't click spoilers) which would at least count as something in the way of "signal", but I still don't really like it as it looks more like someone going back and pulling up posts and trying to manufacture reasons for them being town - none of that stuff strikes me as particularly towny? It's just iv joking around.

My actual thoughts on Andante which was the reason I was doing this: Had almost wanted to declare her town for being thoughtless about her number choice, which felt real, but the second thought I had was that not every configuration of players is going to produce a tryhard scumteam that plans for the draft (see last PYP), so not particularly a towntell, most of her posts are null, does feel like the way she's harping on the iv scum read feels kind of real though I don't agree with the reasoning at all, I like the comment about revisiting her read in 359, fine enough for now

In post 407, skitter30 wrote:For the first point - well, you obviously didnt know what happened between p2 and whatever page we were on at the time when you voted, and i feel like most people finish reading and then choose to vote?

Like i'm not objecting to the notion of reading lineraly obviously, i'm objecting ti the timing of the vote given the context of everything else that was happening

And for the rest - meh. Idk the strength of the midway read seems a little too strong given what they've posted thus far

~
But maybe i should outsource this read on u to faker

Why would you outsource the read to the person who literally always reads me wrong and failed to catch me the one time I was scum against her

(internal monologue: surely skitter does not crash her ship into the rock of "you feel off this game" twice in a row, right...?)

I thought she knew how to read you >.>
But if not then i wont outsource it

Pedit no, i abso-freaking-lutely would not, and i actually hadnt thought abt that at all today, but take that as you will

I’m not impressed with mwb yet although I wouldn’t call it a scumread exactly

i think he can be totally obvtown as town and I think they are very capable of posting fake analysis as scum for a bit like in the early posts that get a couple townleans from people

this catboi skitter tiff is very hawt and I can't wait to see them meta-dive each other for the next 20 pages

In post 68, skitter30 wrote:

In post 65, Datisi wrote:

In post 62, innocentvillager wrote:Is it to deter other people from picking them?

but there’s no pregame communication

how would you expect people to know that you just hope enough people do?

oh wow nice dumbslip iv i guess you're confirmed town now hehe

>.>

what’s with this rxn?

IV you scumfuck how are you still alive

Yeah there's no way I can read all this any time soon.

rofl dude walked in and straight up nope'd out of the thread

In post 418, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:IV you scumfuck how are you still alive

lol pooks I’m always town u town?

In post 417, innocentvillager wrote:

In post 68, skitter30 wrote:

In post 65, Datisi wrote:

In post 62, innocentvillager wrote:Is it to deter other people from picking them?

but there’s no pregame communication

how would you expect people to know that you just hope enough people do?

oh wow nice dumbslip iv i guess you're confirmed town now hehe

>.>

what’s with this rxn?

Uh the micro we played like ten days ago?

i can't really blame him lol

pedit: @420

In post 191, midwaybear wrote:

In post 175, Andante wrote:You think only scum picked 1?

I think if scum were to double up, it would be on a low number (like 1). Also doubling up hurts your chance at getting a good role, but also makes people think you aren’t wolves together. If Datisi and Pooky are wolf, I think they might give that a shot. I don’t think the other pairings do that. I don’t scumread either of them though. It’s more of an observation. But also scum chose multitasking which seems better when scum actually have roles to work with, so…

I just wanted to say

if Datisi and I were scum together

We would definitely have a 20 page argument in the scum PT about who gets to be #1

and then both pick it.

It's kind of a shame this didn't happen this game tho.