Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Gamma Emerald]

im starting to think one of the more reliable scumtells in this game is seeing who attacked gamma for a prolonged period time LOL. not even joking both varsoon/dunk did it and i bet another or 2 or 3 did too

I think you should be trying to find red scum with this because I had 2 of them pegged d1, meaning they'd probably want my head

[Joey_]

lol 1 was random as shit, d2 wasnt fite me pinnochio

[Joey_]

mfw wrong thread

[Shaziro]

Sorry I've been AWOL, reading and catching up but it kinda feels like folks have been locked into their reads and unwilling to listen to changing information unless it can be used to reaffirm their thoughts. Gamma is town, this seems very clear to me, but marshy only recently opened his mind to changing that. The progression on that mind-opening feels weird to me, but that is what it is. Also, Caesar is at L-1, please don't throw another vote that way until we get a claim from the slot.

[pidgey]

I didnt discuss because i want mt olympics yall!

Youll see when the post happens

[Chara]

i'm excited!

sorry for low energy. marshy's readslist is nearly exactly mine, don't know if that's a good or bad thing but in the interest of being optimistic i want to say that's good.

[Titus]

Sure let's lynch Klazam...another outspoken town. Yeah he SRs me but that's not changing the fact he's another deadline lynch lead by those who save Gamma. Another active town voice gone.

I'll just wait over here.

[Titus]

i'm excited!

sorry for low energy. marshy's readslist is nearly exactly mine, don't know if that's a good or bad thing but in the interest of being optimistic i want to say that's good.

Yeah circlejerks without reason. Totally good.

[Jodaxq]

does town have NO investigative roles? or does the red scum team have no investigative scum? id like to kno what joey thinks of this.

I thought about that a lot actually! Varsoon's flipping role cop is probably most-if-not all orange investigative role while no red flipped investigative! I also think that in some ways, the absurd amount of protectives could be the offset for the lack of investigative ? Like obviously town gets a lot of advantage if they can keep passing resolutions on town and protected players, maybe the resolutions themselves grants investigative abilities ? idk man, theres still like 3 unclaimed slot

I dont understand that part : "if someone could please link me/explain WHY jodax claim thatd b greatly appreciated and ill answer any question they hav for me in return", do you want to know why joda claimed at all or why would she as scum?

i want to see the post/reasoning behind her claim and then try to weigh if the way she did so tells us anything about her alignment

im gonna b here in a bit and am gonna try to figure some stuff out. gimme like an hr and a half and whatever i dont finish im gonna ask you guys about and then i can get back at you tomorrow cuz im off

I tracked Gamma N1 because I didn't like how he interacted with the Creature wagon. I learned that he visited brassherald. Because Brass was peacekept, I couldn't think of any great reason for him to be targeted, and I straight up asked people if a visit to brass was anti-town. I was then told it would be best to ask the person directly assuming it was an active person who knew Brass was peacekept. I did so. Afterwards, people were talking about trying to coordinate the claims we had on the table, so I full claimed because my ability each night is random and I didn't want to have someone try to leash a track to someone.
2175 is the beginning of my claim.

[Jodaxq]

Sorry I've been AWOL, reading and catching up but it kinda feels like folks have been locked into their reads and unwilling to listen to changing information unless it can be used to reaffirm their thoughts. Gamma is town, this seems very clear to me, but marshy only recently opened his mind to changing that. The progression on that mind-opening feels weird to me, but that is what it is. Also, Caesar is at L-1, please don't throw another vote that way until we get a claim from the slot.

I know you aren't talking to me in specific, but what changing information has there been for Caesar scum?

[Jodaxq]

im starting to think one of the more reliable scumtells in this game is seeing who attacked gamma for a prolonged period time LOL. not even joking both varsoon/dunk did it and i bet another or 2 or 3 did too

I think this is pretty accurate.

[Jodaxq]

I'm not convinced that the red team has to have an investigative role. The orange team would have to have something else as well and we've had no real indication of another roleblocker or scum protective (I feel like Dunker and Varsoon would have received protection from their respective scum teams).

[Jodaxq]

Hi. I have obtained some metagame evidence that points towards Gamma being town here.

VOTE: Klazam

I would appreciate if you expanded upon this for us.

[brassherald]

Orange makes sense to have an invest, and Red having more offensive sorts of roles. Roleblocker fits more into the domination field. Science might have more investigative roles and no roles that actually affect other people's actions. Maybe a scum doctor.

[Almost50]

a50 i hav a question for you. if town lynches me are you down with getting shot on my flip?

No. If you get lynched and flip town I'd say we lynch you again to make sure you're not messing the game any further.

[Joey_]

pidgey can you be more transparent

[Gamma Emerald]

Sure let's lynch Klazam...another outspoken town. Yeah he SRs me but that's not changing the fact he's another deadline lynch lead by those who save Gamma. Another active town voice gone.

I'll just wait over here.

looool nice little whiteknight ya got there
it's Ceasar's head we're after but thanks for sticking your neck out as well

[Pine]

Requested to replace myself. I can't seem to get it up as Caesar.

[Venmar]

Votecount 3.4

[0] Kiana Kaslana:

[0] brassherald:

[0] Bujaber:

[0] Chara:

[1]

Gamma Emerald:

Titus

[3]

Klazam:

Kiana Kaslana, Marshy, Chara

[2]

Titus:

Gamma Emerald, Almost50

[0] Shaziro:

[0] Joey_:

[0] pidgey:

[0] jodaxq:

[0] Almost50:

[0] marshy:

[6]

Pine:

Jodaxq, Shaziro, Brassherald, Klazam, Joey_, BuJaber

Not Voting

• pidgey, Pine

Deadline

• In (expired on 2018-04-10 09:00:00)
  
• Tuesday, April 10th @9:00am PST

Mod Notes:

• With 14 alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch.

[Venmar]

Pine replaces Caesar Wills It (himself)

Kiana Kaslana and BuJaber have both been prodded.

Currently sorting out the replacement status of the Titus slot. A replacement should be found soon if Titus does indeed still want to replace out.

[Shaziro]

Sorry I've been AWOL, reading and catching up but it kinda feels like folks have been locked into their reads and unwilling to listen to changing information unless it can be used to reaffirm their thoughts. Gamma is town, this seems very clear to me, but marshy only recently opened his mind to changing that. The progression on that mind-opening feels weird to me, but that is what it is. Also, Caesar is at L-1, please don't throw another vote that way until we get a claim from the slot.

I know you aren't talking to me in specific, but what changing information has there been for Caesar scum?

I was referring to reads on Gamma, largely, and Marshy's more specifically.


Titus, are you replacing out or not? If you are, it's kinda uncool to sit and keep ostensibly playing the game.

[Klazam]

ok Titus confuses me.

Says im town, then says people who defend gamma are scum.

I'm defending gamma. so uhm

Also if titus isnt replacing out, im all for a lynch there.

[Joey_]

replacing one-self is one of the nerdiest thing i have ever seen

[Pine]

Well, frankly, I can't manage as Caesar. I signed up when I figured I'd do one game and half-ass it, but now I'm in a bunch and have a lot on my plate. I can't manage a separate-account-with-gimmick.

[Gamma Emerald]

well that's all well and good but do you ahve anything more to contribute