Mafiascum.net

this might be very slow and ill miss the response but 6 third parties that align with town lmao

In post 4019, superbowl9 wrote:Why these 5 titus? Just vca or reads too?

VCA plus reads.

Town or Town Aligned	Titus Plusjoyed Diamond Sentinel Nero Cain Morning Mage shellyc (if April scum) A50 Ban Hydras superbowl9 mastina Menalque NorweiganboyEE
Above Null	The Golden Paradox Bell Something_Smart Mathblade
Null	DrDolittle jjh927 shellyc (if April town)
Lean Scum	Tayl0rSwift
Scum	Pickaxe Pete Chemist April Ludgate

For the record, I haven't updated my VCA. This is my old VCA plus reads. I also expect one of my bottom four to be wrong and someone in my "Above Null" and lower to be scum.

what is the BTS army?

In post 4028, Tayl0r Swift wrote:what is the BTS army?

What are you talking about? Where did you see that?

Also, can you talk to me about my reads Tayl0rSwift?

i independently scum read Pickaxe Pete Chemist April Ludgate so I guess its maps to what I'm feeling?

In post 4032, DrDolittle wrote:i independently scum read Pickaxe Pete Chemist April Ludgate so I guess its maps to what I'm feeling?

Why do you SR them?

I think Chemist's vote on April was very noncomittal in 3956 after he pulls out 3 quotes.
pickaxe pete is doing about the same as i am, but he's not really addressing the game as far as i can tell
mastina called FL guiltied scum

keep in mind this is based on the 20-30% of posts that i read

i dont like that you left the dead people as townreads. i get that its just a stylistic choice, but eh.
i generally have very little faith in your VCA, but i have somewhat more faith in your reads in general. i dont see why DS and MM are so high in your readlist. i saw what you said about DS, but again, i dont like VCA particularly. im unconvinced in its efficacy. i would guess theres at least one, probably two scum in your "above null" group. particularly SS and TGP, although bell has been a bit lurky this game i think. i dont think math is scum aorn, but could be wrong. ddl just scumclaimed, and it seemed like genuine surrender. if we think there isnt a serial killer then jjh is probably town. shelly im not sure about but i dont understand the contingency on april's flip. i havent really sorted shelly yet, ill need more content there. the claim stuff was interesting, but its only mildly town-indicative, and only if plus is confirmed. i could buy pickaxe as scum for sure, because although most posts seem pretty townie, a few have pinged me. i dont think chemist is scum, but i need to see more content. i dont know how to read april. but my vote is there because apparently shes confirmed scum mechanically per mastina.

overall i think the "above null" category in your readlist is the scummiest people to me. i do really appreciate still being in my own category though <3

oof thats a long block of words. sorry!

In post 4027, Titus wrote:

Town or Town Aligned	Titus Plusjoyed Diamond Sentinel Nero Cain Morning Mage shellyc (if April scum) A50 Ban Hydras superbowl9 mastina Menalque NorweiganboyEE
Above Null	The Golden Paradox Bell Something_Smart Mathblade
Null	DrDolittle jjh927 shellyc (if April town)
Lean Scum	Tayl0rSwift
Scum	Pickaxe Pete Chemist April Ludgate

For the record, I haven't updated my VCA. This is my old VCA plus reads. I also expect one of my bottom four to be wrong and someone in my "Above Null" and lower to be scum.

you've realised i'm town now? dang, what a U-turn

In post 3542, Something_Smart wrote:Presumably you're asking "what percentage of alleged scumslips are real scumslips", which I would estimate at around 4%.

I'd say 4.16375% is more like it.

In post 4039, Almost50 wrote:

In post 3542, Something_Smart wrote:Presumably you're asking "what percentage of alleged scumslips are real scumslips", which I would estimate at around 4%.

I'd say 4.16375% is more like it.

i mean youre rounding, but close enough.

In post 4036, Tayl0r Swift wrote:ddl just scumclaimed, and it seemed like genuine surrender

no

In post 4041, DrDolittle wrote:

In post 4036, Tayl0r Swift wrote:ddl just scumclaimed, and it seemed like genuine surrender

no

ok i didnt realize that kpop was a thing

I also thought for a couple seconds they were claiming member of the scum army tbh.

@Taylor,

I am open to someone in my nulls/above nulls being scum. I'm presuming by you not including Math that you townread them? I have Math as above null because his play reminds me of Steven Universe. There he was outside the main townblock and he threw a similar fit, demanding to know everything we knew. We wound up lynching him for it, in an otherwise flawless victory. There's always the chance Math is scum panicking or whiteknighting April, but I doubt both of these possibilities. The first I doubt because of Math actually voting April. If Math were scum panicking throwing out anything that sticks, he doesn't vote a partner here. He definitely doesn't vote a partner whose only contributions have been pushing on the 3ps. April flipping scum would hinder his progress immensely. Thus, I highly doubt scum!Math votes scum!April here. That leaves Math whiteknighting April. This possibility I can't rule out, and its the one that scares me the most. In the uber rare event that April flips town, Math will become insufferable for the rest of the game. That's regardless of their alignment. It will also be nigh on impossible to tell Scum!Math from Town!Math, as both would spam the thread. I don't like the whiteknight angle because Math can naturally be scumread for voting their townread much more so than mastina can for having a wrong opinion. In short, I think it's probable this is angry Town!Math from Steven's Universe.

As for Bell, I struggle with him. Bell lead a wagon on SS after I complained about him not being visible on any wagons. Most of what he's posted today has been good. I'm just missing the Wow! factor from Bell that I usually get when he's town. Of course maybe that Wow factor is because I was scum in the last game we played together.

SS gets to stay above null for his posting today. It's been logically sound and accurate, but it prevents us from confirming town. It would have been better if SS highlighted this flaw earlier or just merely claimed he'd play outside of the results.

TGP stays there due to the lack of scumpings in his play. I don't get much in the way of town pings either, but he has a presence and it doesn't seem demotivated. So tonally, he's town. That's weak so above null.

@Morning Mage, I slept on it and discussed it with the hoods and realized you were likely town. The reason might offend you but here goes.
As town, you tend to tunnel hard on townies frequently, especially ones who have a zone of influence equal or stronger than your own. You had no influence alone day 1. So you saw two people linked at the hip and naturally scumread them. So basically, you were playing the role of misguided town.

In post 4043, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I also thought for a couple seconds they were claiming member of the scum army tbh.

Hey EE, care to talk reads with me?

In post 3639, PlusJOYED wrote:this makes a lot of sense with the "town but not town" mason. I wish they would have revealed this day 1 but whatevs.

I'm pretty sure I did, and so did sb.

i said this about math: " i dont think math is scum aorn, but could be wrong."

the play feels town from math. im fairly confident. but you obviously know math a lot better than i do.

In post 4046, Almost50 wrote:

In post 3639, PlusJOYED wrote:this makes a lot of sense with the "town but not town" mason. I wish they would have revealed this day 1 but whatevs.

I'm pretty sure I did, and so did sb.

wait youre not town A50?

In post 4045, Titus wrote:

In post 4043, NorwegianboyEE wrote:I also thought for a couple seconds they were claiming member of the scum army tbh.

Hey EE, care to talk reads with me?

Anyone specific?