In post 2755, Roden wrote:Sorry, was dealing with wedding stuff yesterday, I just finished catching up on the game.
Ircher is caught scum for multiple reasons, I don't believe he's FN and I'm pretty sure he wasn't RB'd. Somebody mentioned earlier that Ircher's reads list looked townie, but also noted that he essentially had written it ahead of time, which leads me to believe it was just fabricated as a last ditch effort to save himself. He also
still
isn't scum hunting, unless you count this:
In post 2587, Ircher wrote:I think Bell scum claimed in the last few pages.
In post 2449, TheWayItEnds wrote:if your action was roleblocked can you use it tonight? for non consec? im assuming not but worth a check
Nope.
This also feels off. The confident conclusiveness of this answer doesn't add up if the claim is real. The reply is instant, and the only way he could know for sure is if he asked the mod ahead of time, but he doesn't mention that. Very much just feels like a "just trust me bro" response.
Also Val needs to die tonight or tomorrow. He tried to instigate an argument but never responded when I brought the receipts. And then today he's like "oh no where's Roden" as if there isn't an unfinished case against him that he's been ignoring.
Consider my vote spiritually on Ircher, I don't want to put him at E-1 in case he hammers himself to cut off discussion and info exchange. I'm fine to do it when we're ready though.
In post 2758, Ircher wrote:In other news, Roden just dropped several percentage points with how he's spinning things here.
Except he’s referring to me who said it first and you didn’t bat an eye
That's not true. I just didn't comment; not everything is worth it at the time. Also, the specifics matter here. You called me out for my initial reaction. Roden is calling me out for providing the standard answer to a question that has a standard answer on this site. That's very different; the former is a good faith engagement even if I disagree. The latter is just incredibly bad faith. You both agree the claim is fake; that's fine, sure; however, the way you reach that conclusion matters, and the way Roden is reaching that conclusion is really iffy compared to yours.
In post 2758, Ircher wrote:In other news, Roden just dropped several percentage points with how he's spinning things here.
Except he’s referring to me who said it first and you didn’t bat an eye
I was hoping someone would notice this first. Ircher has been ignoring most people who try to case him, only ever replying to people he thinks are easy to out-argue.
In post 2821, Roden wrote:Anyway the real reason Ircher is scum here is because there is a 100% chance we have a Voyeur and/or a Watcher and there's no way they don't sit on Ircher N1 to catch a Roleblocker. But no one's stepping forward to vouch for Ircher besides I guess Andante, who just claimed VT.
Hot take:
let's actually kill scum today. The CORRECT play today is to KILL roden.
Here's why:
Here's roden's first "scum" ircher when there was multiple people already looking that way, but no case, no reasons why.
Then there's the naked vote. That naked vote is placed in spot 6/11. There's no "real" reason, just a naked vote.
Now Roden switches to Val.
1560 again naked jumps onto the wagon for no real reason for E-3
No where around for the last minute switcharoooo.
Now open up to D2:
All of a sudden is convinced that Ircher is lying. Full on bussing. knowing the partner is going down. The other part of the line "someone mentioned that the posts looked fabricated".
The last two posts are distancing between ircer & roden.
Up until the naked vote there was BARELY any mention re:ircher until the naked 6/11 vote & the E-3 vote then the start of D2.
So please for the sake of catching an actual scum. please vote roden
thank you kindly
for my sanity
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 6:41 pm
by Save The Dragons
VOTE: roden
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 6:41 pm
by Malakittens
sorry it took long.
i'm at work. between here and this thread being a fucking dumpster fire.
I just want to purge everyone, but like my friends/family/coworkers
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 6:47 pm
by The Three Bears
man i didnt know the way to get people to flash wagon was to disappear from the thread and rush in while other wagons were building for maximum confusion and opportunity. i need to start taking notes what the heck!!!! i just need to dip off the surface of the earth and rush in halfway through the day with a full game solve and some really big text.
I think mold was an attempt to janitor The Bears, but the kill was protected by LLD. The kill was stopped, but the mold was a clue that they were being targeted. I think mastina is using the mold as an attempt to get town cred.
We have Ircher's flip, it doesn't say anything about mold, and the flavor doesn't match
this is the ultimate shitpost. fuckin. commendations u win the shitpost meta.
HEY uh mala so like u got less than 100 posts in 4 gamedays. im tr u here n ull see me vote w u in jus a sec here but 4 the ppl still tryin 2 figure out whats goin on why shoud we trust u
VOTE: roden
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 6:54 pm
by Malakittens
In post 4078, The Three Bears wrote:man i didnt know the way to get people to flash wagon was to disappear from the thread and rush in while other wagons were building for maximum confusion and opportunity. i need to start taking notes what the heck!!!! i just need to dip off the surface of the earth and rush in halfway through the day with a full game solve and some really big text.
I remember not liking them early, and then mostly forgetting about what they've done later.
what alignment am i?
-noraa
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 6:56 pm
by Malakittens
Mush
I'm a low poster in general. I'm rather busy. I have one full time job, I work PT as a paramedic & I still volunteer. It also didn't help that I got covid right in the middle of D1 which made it harder for me to post anything.
I have played with many people in this player list. Don't discredit me for the "number" of posts. I am a rather transparent player. so look at my content when I'm actually active; go from there and you'll be able to read me
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:00 pm
by MUSHSHAGANA
UHHHHH im not discreditin u LOL wtf, im givin u a reason 2 explain why other ppl should fuckin trust u cuz like ????
shit i already tr u n think u got scum here like i am 99% theres an anti roden post p recent in my iso like what a weird dam slot
but like i can see arguments against ur slot n like i dont agree w them but i dont got arguments 2 shut them down what do u want me 2 do here LOL
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:01 pm
by The Three Bears
dunn i have 3 questions for you.
1) why have you not replied to my posts accusing you of being scum?
2) what do you think my alignment is? you seem very waffley on it
3) what is your strongest read right now? you seem to only be sheeping people this game
mhm. then what do you think about me? what's my alignment?
-noraa
I've been waffling, despite what Mushshanga would have you believe I'm not locked into the idea that Tet checked you.
I don't agree that Andante is town. They seem transparently scum to me. To that extent I guess Roden isn't my preferred wagon today, but I'm not going to fight against it.
It is amusing to me that after ~15 pages of nonsense between you and Cephrir, they revealed that the big thing they saw was what I was already talking about ~18 pages ago anyway, down to the letter.
I didn't find what Titus was doing with vca and me/toog to be towny. Especially because the vca shows your slot and Tet on the wagon that you say will be good for information.
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:04 pm
by Dunnstral
I've responded to you plenty. I don't have the energy to compete with three different people name dropping me over 150 times.
You bring up an argument, and then while that is being argued against as nonsense, you've already started to bring up a different argument, and then you're working on another one. All nonsense, but you flood the thread and make it impossible to engage. So like, you do you, I think that's a slimy tactic, I'm not going to let you act like I'm not responding to you
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:08 pm
by Malakittens
In post 4090, MUSHSHAGANA wrote:UHHHHH im not discreditin u LOL wtf, im givin u a reason 2 explain why other ppl should fuckin trust u cuz like ????
shit i already tr u n think u got scum here like i am 99% theres an anti roden post p recent in my iso like what a weird dam slot
but like i can see arguments against ur slot n like i dont agree w them but i dont got arguments 2 shut them down what do u want me 2 do here LOL
sorry I misunderstood the post then. I just got confused because i thought you were townreading me and I saw the anti roden post as well
I know there's been other players using the same reason to discredit me aka andante.
yea its nbd im jus wasnt expectin that reaction 2 like "let me help u out here" is all
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:12 pm
by Malakittens
its just its the first time i played with you, but i have played with others before such as {titus, std, dunn, bell} i believe i played with cephrir before, but we have definetly have done rl mafia together so
then add the dead ppl {lld}
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:16 pm
by Dunnstral
I am of the opinion that Andante's stance on Malakittens was scummy. And also that their weird sort of mafia claim yesterday was never really explained, just followed up with AtE/Widom
Posted: Thu Jan 27, 2022 7:16 pm
by Cephrir
In post 4097, Malakittens wrote:its just its the first time i played with you, but i have played with others before such as {titus, std, dunn, bell} i believe i played with cephrir before, but we have definetly have done rl mafia together so
then add the dead ppl {lld}
You were my partner in the wedding game!
I think we've played other times but that is the most salient to me