Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:04 am
but if he doesnt poison who we say hes scumclaiming
The dif is we pick who said kill is because whoever we're picking we assume we'd have lynched at one point so it saves us a lynch and gives mafia less choices of night kill and poe.In post 4099, Sakura Hana wrote:Remember the argument i made when i thought you were the scum poisoner.In post 4097, MariaR wrote:Idk guys I feel like having leashed killing power is pretty good to me I like having more than 1 lynch where if math is scum has to poison someone of our choosing but sure go nuts
It's literally just letting a scum slot live so they can do a 2x kill again.
True, but, if he poisons who we say he's playing against win con anyway or just flat out helping town in any case, He might just poison someone else and for the same result of getting lynched anyway so.. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯In post 4100, Wisdom wrote:but if he doesnt poison who we say hes scumclaiming
Yeah, I think Math claimed as a scum gambit. He could well be telling the truth about beingIn post 4085, Sakura Hana wrote:yeah the MCs have been nerfed i dont think the town:scum MC ratio was changed tho. since MCs are STILL the strongest PRs.In post 4083, MariaR wrote:yes exactly and you don't think fakegod went "hey hang on that was a bit op" let's nerf that a little!
Especially when he wants Muffin and I killed for no good reason.MariaR wrote:You know this game is scary when you're agreeing with wisdom most of all.
I'm not convinced personally, even if it would benefit me to do so (MathBlade as scum MC poisoner makes me conftown). I have a hard time understanding how MathBlade's play thus far comes from scum!MB.Sakura Hana wrote:True, but, if he poisons who we say he's playing against win con anyway or just flat out helping town in any case, He might just poison someone else and for the same result of getting lynched anyway so.. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯In post 4100, Wisdom wrote:but if he doesnt poison who we say hes scumclaiming
Besides as I said im fairly sure that there has to be a scum MC for balance.
Do the rules explicitly state that as the case (that is, that MCs are necessarily stronger than any other non-MC PR)? I feel like Brian's weak MC role makes room for these exceptions in MathBlade as town poisoner and 2 scum non-MC PRs.Sakura Hana wrote:Ok so here's another thing:
If scum has a poisoner along Math, then WTF is Math's role for an MC, scum's wouldnt be an MC coz there's 3 MCs, so scum cannot have something as strong as math's role or stronger, which then leaves Math as the only poisoner.
Math, I don’t see why you’re so sure Sakura is scum. Her theory on the mains is solid. Muffin was the one who thought your character was defacto scum. He just thought it was Maria and not you.In post 4087, Sakura Hana wrote:Again, i have no gun, so if im scum im the poisoner, you can have literally all 5 gunsmiths check me the same night if you dont believe me.In post 4086, MathBlade wrote:lynch Sakura tomorrow then a ton of innocent town that have no guns.
OR
Im just town.
Then I rest my case.In post 4111, MariaR wrote:No it's just assumed because most of the times MC's have been op compared to other roles
they werent MC.In post 4108, MariaR wrote:scum had a vig
town had a vig
what's to say poisoner can't be the same thing if we're assuming scum in gunsmiths
In post 1347, FakeGod wrote:
Perhaps scum have a x-shot poisoner? That'd make senseIn post 4114, Sakura Hana wrote:they werent MC.In post 4108, MariaR wrote:scum had a vig
town had a vig
what's to say poisoner can't be the same thing if we're assuming scum in gunsmiths
If you agree that Poisoner is something MC level (which should be if you believe Math), then there's no way there's another poisoner, which means pmatt poisoned Katsuki.
In post 4105, Sakura Hana wrote:Ok so here's another thing:
If scum has a poisoner along Math, then WTF is Math's role for an MC, scum's wouldnt be an MC coz there's 3 MCs, so scum cannot have something as strong as math's role or stronger, which then leaves Math as the only poisoner.
But Purr, 3 town mains would screw up the balance, because the mains have the most power. What I don’t understand is my role PM doesn’t specify that I’m a minor character, so I’m assuming that only mains do? I wish I had asked Ank that before she replaced out.In post 4107, Purrcocet wrote:math is town
if you guys want to lynch a townie then go with mariaR lol but apparently we got past that
im pretty fine with that flip cause it would have cleared up a lot of dumb shit in this game
Because she's been pushing an improper theory, not pushing any reads for any content based reasons, not trying to argue meta or try to figure out why I'm doing what I'm doing.In post 4110, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:Math, I don’t see why you’re so sure Sakura is scum. Her theory on the mains is solid. Muffin was the one who thought your character was defacto scum. He just thought it was Maria and not you.In post 4087, Sakura Hana wrote:Again, i have no gun, so if im scum im the poisoner, you can have literally all 5 gunsmiths check me the same night if you dont believe me.In post 4086, MathBlade wrote:lynch Sakura tomorrow then a ton of innocent town that have no guns.
OR
Im just town.
We really don’t have a great reason to lynch Maria though. Muffin was convinced she had Math’s flavour.In post 4107, Purrcocet wrote:math is town
if you guys want to lynch a townie then go with mariaR lol but apparently we got past that
im pretty fine with that flip cause it would have cleared up a lot of dumb shit in this game
There are sample role PMs for both Nancy.In post 4117, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:In post 4105, Sakura Hana wrote:Ok so here's another thing:
If scum has a poisoner along Math, then WTF is Math's role for an MC, scum's wouldnt be an MC coz there's 3 MCs, so scum cannot have something as strong as math's role or stronger, which then leaves Math as the only poisoner.But Purr, 3 town mains would screw up the balance, because the mains have the most power. What I don’t understand is my role PM doesn’t specify that I’m a minor character, so I’m assuming that only mains do? I wish I had asked Ank that before she replaced out.In post 4107, Purrcocet wrote:math is town
if you guys want to lynch a townie then go with mariaR lol but apparently we got past that
im pretty fine with that flip cause it would have cleared up a lot of dumb shit in this game
muffin and profIn post 4112, Purrcocet wrote:wisdom, sakura slash prof friday? what do u think
Nancy Drew 39 wrote:
But Purr, 3 town mains would screw up the balance, because the mains have the most power. What I don’t understand is my role PM doesn’t specify that I’m a minor character, so I’m assuming that only mains do? I wish I had asked Ank that before she replaced out.
I think there could be another poisoner - who isn’t a main - and that Math didn’t necessarily poison Katsuki. I don’t think that clears him, however.In post 4114, Sakura Hana wrote:they werent MC.In post 4108, MariaR wrote:scum had a vig
town had a vig
what's to say poisoner can't be the same thing if we're assuming scum in gunsmiths
If you agree that Poisoner is something MC level (which should be if you believe Math), then there's no way there's another poisoner, which means pmatt poisoned Katsuki.