Menalque has fallen off the melancholy melon queue!
He was a...
Spoiler:
Vanilla Townie
!
It is now Night Four. Please PM me your actions, or post them in an appropriate private topic. This phase will end in (expired on 2020-11-28 13:00:00).
Posted: Fri Nov 27, 2020 3:36 pm
by the worst
petapan has been killed. They were a...
Spoiler:
Vanilla Townie
.
It is now Day Five. This phase will end in (expired on 2020-12-05 13:15:00).
Posted: Fri Nov 27, 2020 3:40 pm
by the worst
Posted: Fri Nov 27, 2020 5:29 pm
by Infinity 324
Oops, all town
Posted: Fri Nov 27, 2020 7:53 pm
by Smoke and Mirrors
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 6:52 am
by Something_Smart
So uh I have a few things to say
First, I'm quite annoyed by Menalque's play yesterday. I very clearly telegraphed my confusion and uncertainty before deciding at the eleventh hour that Menalque was the best compromise (and it was based on me having a strong townread on peta, which was RIGHT) only to have him rip into me because how could I possibly be so confident that he's scum, when I obviously WASN'T confident. It will be interesting to look at the wagons knowing all of peta/me/Menalque are town-- intuitively I would guess that at least one scum jumped on me because they wanted to save the Menalque/peta fight for lylo.
Second, I'm actually really glad peta was killed, because I think I was leaning him over Infinity, because I wanted to trust in Menalque and skitter's townreads of Infinity and peta's vote switching was kinda awful. I don't know why peta was killed; maybe it was just to give Infinity an excuse to drop his townread of me.
Third, when the day opened I asked myself if there was any reason not to vote Infinity immediately, and it turns out there is. It requires very specifically S&M/N_M/BB or S&M/N_M/Hoopla where N_M claimed neighborizer to cover for his real neighborizer partner and he's actually redirector. This is a pretty remote possibility, but there is no harm in taking things a little slower.
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 6:53 am
by Something_Smart
Oh yeah, and also the PR's should claim their actions asap.
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 12:28 pm
by davesaz
That would have been epic if true, too bad.
I guessed wrong on who the kill would be.
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 4:37 pm
by Infinity 324
Who did you target?
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 5:55 pm
by Hoopla
wow, what the hell was that yesterday? and what the hell is that NK?
i have some theories. but yah, lets hear the night actions first.
First, I'm quite annoyed by Menalque's play yesterday. I very clearly telegraphed my confusion and uncertainty before deciding at the eleventh hour that Menalque was the best compromise (and it was based on me having a strong townread on peta, which was RIGHT) only to have him rip into me because how could I possibly be so confident that he's scum, when I obviously WASN'T confident. It will be interesting to look at the wagons knowing all of peta/me/Menalque are town-- intuitively I would guess that at least one scum jumped on me because they wanted to save the Menalque/peta fight for lylo.
Second, I'm actually really glad peta was killed, because I think I was leaning him over Infinity, because I wanted to trust in Menalque and skitter's townreads of Infinity and peta's vote switching was kinda awful. I don't know why peta was killed; maybe it was just to give Infinity an excuse to drop his townread of me.
Third, when the day opened I asked myself if there was any reason not to vote Infinity immediately, and it turns out there is. It requires very specifically S&M/N_M/BB or S&M/N_M/Hoopla where N_M claimed neighborizer to cover for his real neighborizer partner and he's actually redirector. This is a pretty remote possibility, but there is no harm in taking things a little slower.
I don’t understand this @SS, why are we even in your PoE? As for NM, couldn’t this be verified based on who he claimed to neighbourize and the neighbourizing target confirm it? And of course, we should take this slower because we obviously lose if we misexecute another townie.
Posted: Sun Nov 29, 2020 5:32 am
by Smoke and Mirrors
In post 4133, davesaz wrote:That would have been epic if true, too bad.
I guessed wrong on who the kill would be.
Yeah, we did too, unfortunately. I thought it would be Infinty which is why we jk’d them.
If you're referring to my third point, that was just an explanation of why mechanically Infinity is not quite confscum from my POV (though he almost certainly is scum). I don't think you being scum is all that likely, though a gambit is in theory possible.
Posted: Sun Nov 29, 2020 9:45 am
by Something_Smart
Dave, claim your action now.
Posted: Sun Nov 29, 2020 11:00 am
by davesaz
I tend to think that 1-shots should not reveal whether the shot is used or not.
Posted: Sun Nov 29, 2020 12:03 pm
by Smoke and Mirrors
Where is everyone? I would request prods but it’s still the holidays in the States rn. right?
In post 4142, davesaz wrote:I tend to think that 1-shots should not reveal whether the shot is used or not.
you should claim it. we're in a 7p ELo and need every townie to vote correctly for the next three days to win. i want to solve the game today, so we need all the information on the table, even if that information is a no-result.
Posted: Sun Nov 29, 2020 4:12 pm
by davesaz
Should scum shoot me, or keep me alive as a miselim? I don't want to make that question any easier for them to answer.
