Mafiascum.net

BOON HELP ME LEASH NERO TO A BETTER TARGET

NO POINT IN LETTING NERO LIVE IF HE ISN'T LEASHED

In post 4172, OkaPoka wrote:i am not comfortable with nero dictating the target

I’m perfectly fine with Auro as a target, tbh.

Scum aren’t going to want to kill him, he’s a VT claim, and I generally think he’s town, but I have hard paranoia, and this is actually really solid for me.

I’m okay with Auro.

given that presumably tomorrow we could have a guilty on auro and given that i assume most would agree that i can't be partners with auro, doesn't that point towards lynching me today being a bad idea?

In post 4164, northsidegal wrote:nero, it seems confusing to me for you to vote with your primary scumread as opposed to voting the player he's hard defending. could you explain?

Are you willing to ever vote boon?

And you are in the sea og vt claims that has 2 scum in it.

Also, Nero’s lone wolf attitude is kinda townie for me right now.

NSG is L-2.

@Luna - Can you join this wagon with me? I don’t plan to lead you astray. If I do, I’m sorry, but can we trust in our town block again? I’m not gonna pull a fast one on you.

In post 4178, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 4164, northsidegal wrote:nero, it seems confusing to me for you to vote with your primary scumread as opposed to voting the player he's hard defending. could you explain?

Are you willing to ever vote boon?

And you are in the sea og vt claims that has 2 scum in it.

comical is the centerpoint of many possible scumteam solves for me. it would never be today, but i could see myself voting him tomorrow, depending on what we learn.

and the wheels on the bus go round and round

In post 4177, northsidegal wrote:given that presumably tomorrow we could have a guilty on auro and given that i assume most would agree that i can't be partners with auro, doesn't that point towards lynching me today being a bad idea?

Why can’t you be partners with Auro?

In post 4178, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 4164, northsidegal wrote:nero, it seems confusing to me for you to vote with your primary scumread as opposed to voting the player he's hard defending. could you explain?

Are you willing to ever vote boon?

And you are in the sea og vt claims that has 2 scum in it.

In post 4180, northsidegal wrote:

In post 4178, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 4164, northsidegal wrote:nero, it seems confusing to me for you to vote with your primary scumread as opposed to voting the player he's hard defending. could you explain?

Are you willing to ever vote boon?

And you are in the sea og vt claims that has 2 scum in it.

comical is the centerpoint of many possible scumteam solves for me.

it would never be today, but i could see myself voting him tomorrow, depending on what we learn.

@Okapoka - vote this. This is not a town mindset in this gamestate.

NSG WHY IS COMICAL IN YOUR SOLVE

I mean this game should be easy, we got 2 players with supposedly easy to read meta (NC and NSG), and one player who already dropped his towntell (Boon), on top of Oka being town by the way he played around Eddie, and a player that's town if their role is confirmed (PP), and now i have a personal townread on Eddie.
Anything outside of those I can probably lynch no regrets.

Do you agree there are “many” solves where I could be scum? I can see a couple, not many

In post 4182, Comical wrote:

In post 4177, northsidegal wrote:given that presumably tomorrow we could have a guilty on auro and given that i assume most would agree that i can't be partners with auro, doesn't that point towards lynching me today being a bad idea?

Why can’t you be partners with Auro?

that's not what i'm saying, although i do think it's true (from an observer's point of view, i mean—i know that i can't be partners with auro because i'm town)

what i'm assuming is that most people would already agree that i couldn't be partners with auro.

In post 4166, Comical wrote:but I honestly feel Penguin’s just scum now.

FTR, if Boon thinks PP is scum he saying that he thinks its a 4/6 town setup. Was it Boon or someone else that that ragged on me for thinking this was a 4/6 town setup?

Yet im being asked to vote literally there, except for NSG who wants me to vote idany.

In post 4185, Luna Fox wrote:I mean this game should be easy, we got 2 players with supposedly easy to read meta (NC and NSG), and one player who already dropped his towntell (Boon), on top of Oka being town by the way he played around Eddie, and a player that's town if their role is confirmed (PP), and now i have a personal townread on Eddie.
Anything outside of those I can probably lynch no regrets.

i know you're probably tired of people appealing to you like this then, but if that's what you think – would you vote idany with us?

In post 4188, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 4166, Comical wrote:but I honestly feel Penguin’s just scum now.

FTR, if Boon thinks PP is scum he

IS

saying that he thinks its a 4/6 town setup. Was it Boon or someone else that that ragged on me for thinking this was a 4/6 town setup?

Eh, I think there’s another town PR out there, but I’ll talk about this later.

so, nice weather we've been having, isn't it?

yes

In post 4192, Comical wrote:Eh, I think there’s another town PR out there, but I’ll talk about this later.

In post 4191, northsidegal wrote:

In post 4185, Luna Fox wrote:I mean this game should be easy, we got 2 players with supposedly easy to read meta (NC and NSG), and one player who already dropped his towntell (Boon), on top of Oka being town by the way he played around Eddie, and a player that's town if their role is confirmed (PP), and now i have a personal townread on Eddie.
Anything outside of those I can probably lynch no regrets.

i know you're probably tired of people appealing to you like this then, but if that's what you think – would you vote idany with us?

I mean, i said i could lynch anyone outside of that without regrets, I can still lynch inside if being persuaded by a reasonable enough reason.
"NSG magically became a good scum player" isnt a reasonable enough reason.
"NSG would've been lynched already if she was town" is reasonably better, but that depends on knowing what the heck scum is doing right now, without flips that's hard to determine.
I'm currently trying to figure out what makes the most sense as a course of action which gives us the biggest chance of lynching scum.
To answer your question is "yes, if none of the above happens"

In post 4187, northsidegal wrote:

In post 4182, Comical wrote:

In post 4177, northsidegal wrote:given that presumably tomorrow we could have a guilty on auro and given that i assume most would agree that i can't be partners with auro, doesn't that point towards lynching me today being a bad idea?

Why can’t you be partners with Auro?

that's not what i'm saying, although i do think it's true (from an observer's point of view, i mean—i know that i can't be partners with auro because i'm town)

what i'm assuming is that most people would already agree that i couldn't be partners with auro.

In post 4188, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 4166, Comical wrote:but I honestly feel Penguin’s just scum now.

FTR, if Boon thinks PP is scum he

IS

saying that he thinks its a 4/6 town setup. Was it Boon or someone else that that ragged on me for thinking this was a 4/6 town setup?

Also, i don’t think that was me. I don’t really rag on setup in that way as do’s or don’t s.

We have no clue what scum have, so

We were told no cop, so i can believe double gunsmith.

Luna is confirmed Voyeur.

Oka is confirmed JK.


1 and a half Gunsmith
Voyeur
Jailkeeper
Unclaimed role
5 VT

Complex FV
Doctor
Goon

that’s balanced based on what I believe of the unclaimed role.

Penguin was also trying to soft like he had a gun and not be clear on his FV, so that could have been his way of avoiding.

Yeah, solid game.

If Nero is scum, Penguin is town probably.

In post 4196, Luna Fox wrote:

In post 4191, northsidegal wrote:

In post 4185, Luna Fox wrote:I mean this game should be easy, we got 2 players with supposedly easy to read meta (NC and NSG), and one player who already dropped his towntell (Boon), on top of Oka being town by the way he played around Eddie, and a player that's town if their role is confirmed (PP), and now i have a personal townread on Eddie.
Anything outside of those I can probably lynch no regrets.

i know you're probably tired of people appealing to you like this then, but if that's what you think – would you vote idany with us?

I mean, i said i could lynch anyone outside of that without regrets, I can still lynch inside if being persuaded by a reasonable enough reason.
"NSG magically became a good scum player" isnt a reasonable enough reason.
"NSG would've been lynched already if she was town" is reasonably better, but that depends on knowing what the heck scum is doing right now, without flips that's hard to determine.
I'm currently trying to figure out what makes the most sense as a course of action which gives us the biggest chance of lynching scum.
To answer your question is "yes, if none of the above happens"

Let me say this.

You think NSG would go down as scum early, yes?

It’s happening again in that case, so what’s so “magically become good” about it?

In post 4198, Comical wrote:

In post 4196, Luna Fox wrote:

In post 4191, northsidegal wrote:

In post 4185, Luna Fox wrote:I mean this game should be easy, we got 2 players with supposedly easy to read meta (NC and NSG), and one player who already dropped his towntell (Boon), on top of Oka being town by the way he played around Eddie, and a player that's town if their role is confirmed (PP), and now i have a personal townread on Eddie.
Anything outside of those I can probably lynch no regrets.

i know you're probably tired of people appealing to you like this then, but if that's what you think – would you vote idany with us?

I mean, i said i could lynch anyone outside of that without regrets, I can still lynch inside if being persuaded by a reasonable enough reason.
"NSG magically became a good scum player" isnt a reasonable enough reason.
"NSG would've been lynched already if she was town" is reasonably better, but that depends on knowing what the heck scum is doing right now, without flips that's hard to determine.
I'm currently trying to figure out what makes the most sense as a course of action which gives us the biggest chance of lynching scum.
To answer your question is "yes, if none of the above happens"

Let me say this.

You think NSG would go down as scum early, yes?

It’s happening again in that case, so what’s so “magically become good” about it?

Well she certainly isnt lurking that's for sure.