Mafiascum.net

i don't know what's happening either shelly

my mind is an enigma
and it will be proven soon i think

ok i took a minute to calm down
disregard my earlier panicking

ok then tell me
1) read on bob
2) read on ydrasse

with explanations attached

shelly is scum?

incorrect

In post 3964, PlusJOYED wrote:also i've softed long enough, not 100% sure if admitting my role is good here but
i am vengeful townie

In an ideal world we save this for Even # of players or F3.

In post 4004, Andresvmb wrote:I have to be honest, the odds that we have a Vengeful Townie this game are like 1%. It doesn’t fit with an Informed Loyal Cop, a Scum Rolestopper, an Ascetic, and a Miller Town Checker. I think it’s way overpowered (since it’s essentially a Day Vig that negates the Scum Rolestopper, which would be insane in a game with a Cop).

Hot Take: the mafia rolestopper is disloyal.
There has to be a bit more town power, could fit with that.

In post 4040, bob3141 wrote:Any game some makes a claim thats clearly not true, you can expect me to scum read them. If he had never made the claim informed townie full stop I doubt i would have ever tunneled him.

And if I was scum you can well bet your arse i would have kept my interactions to him to min. If i spot a town power role i near always town read them as scum and bumb them off in the night.

I feel you should be able to reason that the informed claim was a partial claim and not a full claim, considering you did during your nk spec.


VOTE: osuka

In post 4181, NDMath wrote:

In post 3964, PlusJOYED wrote:also i've softed long enough, not 100% sure if admitting my role is good here but
i am vengeful townie

In an ideal world we save this for Even # of players or F3.

In post 4004, Andresvmb wrote:I have to be honest, the odds that we have a Vengeful Townie this game are like 1%. It doesn’t fit with an Informed Loyal Cop, a Scum Rolestopper, an Ascetic, and a Miller Town Checker. I think it’s way overpowered (since it’s essentially a Day Vig that negates the Scum Rolestopper, which would be insane in a game with a Cop).

Hot Take: the mafia rolestopper is disloyal.
There has to be a bit more town power, could fit with that.

In post 4040, bob3141 wrote:Any game some makes a claim thats clearly not true, you can expect me to scum read them. If he had never made the claim informed townie full stop I doubt i would have ever tunneled him.

And if I was scum you can well bet your arse i would have kept my interactions to him to min. If i spot a town power role i near always town read them as scum and bumb them off in the night.

I feel you should be able to reason that the informed claim was a partial claim and not a full claim, considering you did during your nk spec.


VOTE: osuka

i dont see how the vote follows

In post 4182, Tayl0r Swift wrote:i dont see how the vote follows

this is exactly what i was going to say

In post 4181, NDMath wrote:Hot Take: the mafia rolestopper is disloyal.
There has to be a bit more town power, could fit with that.

also: what the fuck is the point of a disloyal mafia rolestopper? that's got to be the stupidest role+modifier combination ive ever heard of

a disloyal rolestopper in general just sounds moronic

execution

osuka [3]:

shellyc, bob3141, NDMath

PlusJOYED [3]:

osuka, Menalque, Ydrasse

bob3141 [3]:

Tayl0r Swift, Andresvmb, PlusJOYED

Not Voting [0]:

mod notes

~ a thunderstorm woke me up, so you lovelies get a VC

flavour

In post 4154, Ydrasse wrote:i have suddenly changed my mind on who i want plus to shoot ...

i would also like an actual ~case~ on me or w/e.

secretly ydrasse loves the daddy jokes she just doesn't want to admit it

oh wait I already responded to that lmao

In post 4168, shellyc wrote:

In post 4165, PlusJOYED wrote:yeah i don't think this level of acting is in ydrasse scumrange

I have a Fun Fact

Ydrasse's scumrange isn't as weak as you think
I wasted my life reading Newbie 2012 yesterday

I don't disagree that ydrasse is p capable as scum (hence why all the super early TRs were bad takes) but for her to be scum /this game/ she still has to have made, at a fairly key point, a choice that goes directly against her wincon and what she would have been trying to achieve for the rest of that day, /purely/ for the sake of WIFOM which in any case clearly hasn't worked as there's now significantly more suspicion on her now than there was before

like even if you think ydrasse is an amazing scumplayer this is just dumb for scum!her to do and again I'm p sure it literally only makes sense if she's paired with plus which... seems unlikely given their interactions today?

okay I still want to flip plus but I'm now actually wondering if we haven't been overlooking math by a significant margin just because he hasn't been here

In post 4178, shellyc wrote:ok then tell me
1) read on bob
2) read on ydrasse

with explanations attached

bob is probably scum, he's been playing kind of weird this game and I now realize that it makes the most sense for scum!bob to pocket me here so he doesn't die

ydrasse was really sus earlier and today I think has been sus. I'm pretty much null on ydrasse, leaning sort of scum

i've come around to a town!osuka possibility

math have you got any completed scumgames?

honestly besides mena and andres I could see the scum being any of the 2 of you

plus what was your take on math again/

In post 4195, Menalque wrote:plus what was your take on math again/

i can see scum math

JOYED DIDNT YOU TR YDRASSE

like all these thought gaps and non logical trajectories, look super duper bad.

joyed instead of seeing scum!anybody can you give me a lynch order so we have have some Fun Discussion and I can release my theory on the alignments of plus and ydrasse

here's mine: (least to most)
Shelly
Andres
Menalque
Ydrasse
Math
Bob
Joyed
Osuka

In post 4197, shellyc wrote:JOYED DIDNT YOU TR YDRASSE

like all these thought gaps and non logical trajectories, look super duper bad.

i did before now im unsure, my solve shit has been messed up since all my reads have been wrong (iv, teacher, kerset, even suade a lil)
while I have no scumgames here shelly, i think you underestimate my scumgame and don't realize how fucking awful i am as town