malthusis wrote:@ToD: What you said at least clears up what happened to the mafia kills. I'm starting to think that veerus is probably last scum.
If on Day 3, there really were 4 scum out (which by all means there practically was) that means that only 1 person out of the group of 5 wasn't scum.
The group of 5 was: (for reference)
Panzer (scum)
Budja (scum)
Percy (scum)
Me
Veerus
Obviously I don't think I'm scum, and I'm starting to have a hunch veerus is the last scum after all. Therefore I will
Vote: Veerus
I did miss this at first.
Your theory has one, rather large, hole. TOD was also a non-dead player at the time meaning there were 6 players on that list with 2 not scum. You're a good enough player, I think, not to miss this which makes me think you're omitting this fact on purpose to convince the town to mislynch me for the lose.
Since the phase counter was placed on you and TOD, the lack of kills could be attributed to either one of you. Tar implied that I wouldn't get a message if my counter had no effect as you implied by your untargetable claim.
There's only one thing that doesn't make sense to me. If I countered Panzer, he should not have been able to jail TOD... I'm not sure what to think of it except to assume that TOD or Panzer started with a phase counter (2nd counter removes all counters) or I was blocked. Let's think on this:
1) I was blocked - this seems unlikely to me as Tar seems to have placed an emphasis on abilities affecting other active players and not being blocked.
2) Panzer started with a counter (or acquired one prior to the action in question) - this also seems unlikely as the lack of kill on day 4 seems to imply that he were unable to make the kills because he was the only one with a counter at the time (plus malt after D4).
3) TOD started with a counter (or acquired one prior to the action in question) - this seems the most plausible explanation. Which means my counter placed a 2nd counter on TOD thus removing all counters.
Assuming this line of thinking is plausible, malt is the only living player with a counter on him. Lack of a kill since D4 seems to support this theory especially when you consider that TOD wasn't around during twilight of Day 4.
I would like to see what DGB/Seraphim think as the confirmed townspeople. But I'll
unvote
for now.
On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops to zero.
-Fight Club