@KMD
1. I read some of Vi's other games so I see why you don't want to outguess the mod. Plus Cobalt's flip means he gave town fake claiming powers, something that I only exclusively saw for 3rd parties and scum.
2. I expected Town Sniper (Townie/PR because Shinon is an archer. He's not some civilian in the game.
3. Yes. You reevulated your town reads and caught scum that way. Aka they were townie in your books. The scum players were townie. There fore your town reads were too townie and are actually scum. Unless I'm reading that argument wrongly it appears that way to me.
@LL
1. I still don't get the point. If scum fake claims, you are supposed to catch them on this. You are supposed to verify their roles/flavours. Before or after the fact, it doesn't matter. In fact if your role mechanics are correct scum cannot fake claim at all if you investigate them (same conclusion as you).
In hypo if you claimed your investigation early and scum knew the format. Then they fake claimed their role (ie instead of Mafia XXX say they are Town YYY) you investigate if the person was YYY. You should get XXX as a result. Why are you so worried about fake claims here? From my understanding your role counters all fake claims created.
Therefore it shouldn't matter if scum fake claims because you would catch him
2. Yes the point was: if you already caught scum then reveal it. I don't see the point of MCing if your result could lead towards a scum lynch. In fact if you revealed a guilty pre-MC and caught scum, we wouldn't be in potential lylo right now and we would have kept 2 PR claims underwrapped. You also full ability claimed before the MC so town-you was already be out and about.
So your question on why you shouldn't have claimed a guilty result pre-mass claim is obvious: why bother with a MC if you caught scum. We could lynch the person.
3. What was your N1 result and and why didn't you say it in the full claim?
@VP
1. Flavourwise I don't know what COAT stands for. LL's background story fits but a name would help me piece it together. I played Radiant Dawn and unless it didn't show up there, I can't help. :< (aka I didn't play the first one)
2. Uh unless Cobalt is an anti-miller then I don't see why he would lie about his blockage. We also know that Fuzzy's claim is ability verified too. KMD's claim gives me the heebies and I'm waiting for an LL analysis before I make my decision.