Mafiascum.net

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Straw man argument anyone?

Straw man? What?

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:So your role is that you're a bodyguard that has 1 shot BP not a BP that has a 1 shot bodyguard?

That is correct, because a bulletproof 1-shot bodyguard isn't a thing.

Yeah but he's arguing that I don't want the cop protected, which is an untenable argument that I never posited.

Goddamnit. I thought I had this.

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Yeah but he's arguing that I don't want the cop protected, which is an untenable argument that I never posited.

It was an implication of the argument you presented, i.e. that lynching me was fine because I'm not a PR at this point (which is horrible anyway, because VTs are still valuable).

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Goddamnit. I thought I had this.

VOTE: Anatole?

↑ Prof Fridays wrote:

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Yeah but he's arguing that I don't want the cop protected, which is an untenable argument that I never posited.

It was an implication of the argument you presented, i.e. that lynching me was fine because I'm not a PR at this point (which is horrible anyway, because VTs are still valuable).

Again, not what I posited, if you're town don't twist my words.

I said since I found it likely you were lying, lynching what would effectively be VT would be easier to stomach than losing a PR. I was also bloodthirsty at the time because for some reason the two scum had a hard on for you.

That can't be a scum claim lol.

Can we not do this whole thing again?

Derivan/Phok, Fridays, Anatole and probably BJC are town. We have a good enough base to work with from there.

Clusk, SKOT, Havingfitz are on the chopping block

↑ bjc wrote:That can't be a scum claim lol.

I meant I thought I had the game figured out, since Fridays was a shoe-in for the last mafia. I continue by shit streak this game.

Anatole Kuragin wrote:

↑ Prof Fridays wrote:

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Yeah but he's arguing that I don't want the cop protected, which is an untenable argument that I never posited.

It was an implication of the argument you presented, i.e. that lynching me was fine because I'm not a PR at this point (which is horrible anyway, because VTs are still valuable).

Again, not what I posited, if you're town don't twist my words.

I said since I found it likely you were lying, lynching what would effectively be VT would be easier to stomach than losing a PR. I was also bloodthirsty at the time because for some reason the two scum had a hard on for you.

*shrugs* I mean, scum will naturally have strong town reads that are actually town so they can be like, "Look, yeah, we're totally town because we read him right!"

UNVOTE:

↑ Prof Fridays wrote:

Anatole Kuragin wrote:

↑ Prof Fridays wrote:

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Yeah but he's arguing that I don't want the cop protected, which is an untenable argument that I never posited.

It was an implication of the argument you presented, i.e. that lynching me was fine because I'm not a PR at this point (which is horrible anyway, because VTs are still valuable).

Again, not what I posited, if you're town don't twist my words.

I said since I found it likely you were lying, lynching what would effectively be VT would be easier to stomach than losing a PR. I was also bloodthirsty at the time because for some reason the two scum had a hard on for you.

*shrugs* I mean, scum will naturally have strong town reads that are actually town so they can be like, "Look, yeah, we're totally town because we read him right!"

UNVOTE:

Yeah I know but both were fairly careless with their play.

Oh shit I forgot Marquis - who is now my #1

Assuming the cop isn't inactive with a town result on Fridays, it must be on one of the other players. Cop reveals 1 extra CI, Fridays protects him tonight, we get another result tomorrow, we win the game?

And if the cop dies we just lynch Fridays, who would have to be the last scum in this scenario.

That might not be bad.

VOTE: Marquis

(assuming it's an every night cop)

I brain farted on the BP aspect of DPs claim.

So are people basing belief of PF's claim on the possibility that Albert was jk'd N2?

And if PF thought he might have protected who we thought was a cop N2...why not protect him N3?

↑ havingfitz wrote:I brain farted on the BP aspect of DPs claim.

So are people basing belief of PF's claim on the possibility that Albert was jk'd N2?

...no. Not sure where you're getting that from.

↑ havingfitz wrote:And if PF thought he might have protected who we thought was a cop N2...why not protect him N3?

I thought surely the mafia wouldn't be so silly as to attempt to kill Albert again. But alas, I underestimated how desperate the last mafia member was.

Fortunately, it ends up being pretty revealing of what kind of mafia PR we're dealing with.

↑ Prof Fridays wrote:I thought surely the mafia wouldn't be so silly as to attempt to kill Albert again. But alas, I underestimated how desperate the last mafia member was.

This comes across as complete bollocks.

1. You thought Albert was a cop
2. You "protected" him N2.
3. There was no NK N2 but afayk you still have a 1shot BP
4. You assume Albert was targeted N2
5. Yet you decide scum will give up and decide to protect someone who in no way warranted protection over a perceived cop.
6. A.k.a. Bullshit

What do you mean you WIFOM'd last night and decided to protect bjc?

I've already made my case well enough. Night 2 no-death proves my claim by Occam's Razor. You have to make a much more roundabout argument to say I'm scum from these events, than to admit I'm town. I protected bjc on the grounds that I assumed the mafia would not continue to pursue a kill on Albert and bjc seemed the next-least scummy, and I justified it by the fact that we have room to wiggle.

VOTE: havingfitz

This seems in line with the desperate move of the Night 3 Albert kill.

Wiggle room: if albert lives we basically have the game locked up, if he dies our chances drop considerably

The way I see it, Anatole's right. We've got this game all sealed up. You have to convince the rest of the town to lynch me to stand a chance of killing that Cop in order to even think about the winning.

that was with the assumption he was a doctor