Page 18 of 170
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 5:41 pm
by Land of Xanth
Oh. Makes sense.
Wowie Kyouko, you're so helpful!
But Wowie Kyouko, that's a pretty random vote you got there. You wanna explain why you did that?
-Ali
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 5:53 pm
by D3f3nd3r
TTTT replaces Gamma Emerald.
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 5:57 pm
by Lil Uzi Vert
In post 424, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:
That's just a response to vifam voting narna in RVS. Skelda doesn't seem worth voting right now so I'll come back to that.
VOTE: PeregrineV
How did you come to that conclusion? Seems like a reach.
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:15 pm
by Land of Xanth
Yep, it's totally a reach when Vifam's RVS post was the 2nd post of the game.
Adapt Uzi. You're better then this.
-Ali
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:16 pm
by Land of Xanth
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:20 pm
by ssbm_Kyouko
Narna hasn't read the game yet, it's just reacting to what they've seen so far. And peregrine is my second choice but and Skelda I don't think is going to react to pressure
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:21 pm
by Land of Xanth
I ask for a reason on PV. I don't get it.
Nice!
-Ali
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:23 pm
by ssbm_Kyouko
In post 357, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:
Don't like the way Peregrine criticizes both Comm and James here:
In post 257, PeregrineV wrote:
So, given the disadvantage of claiming cop right away, and the fact you could be fakeclaiming as scum, you understand if we ignore the bit of self-meta that you always claim day1, and any reasons you gave for it. Right?
In post 258, PeregrineV wrote: In post 169, CommKnight wrote: In post 167, Land of Xanth wrote: In post 165, James3 wrote:Okay, so Comm is confirmed scum.
UNVOTE: Xanth
VOTE: Comm
If he really were cop he would've immediately CCed.
Do you seriously think for half a second that there isn't a second investigative role if you're a 1-shot cop?
This shit is redonkulous. No investigative claims are getting lynched on day fucking one.
-G
You know, I actually really want to check the hyrdra's role. Just because of how defensive they've been of a 1-shot cop. I've already claimed the pointlessness of a 1-shot and now I've even CC'd.
Now, I can believe there's other investigatives out there, but a cop? Maybe, maybe not. A 1-shot cop at that? Hell no. I'm sticking to my guns with this one. I can believe a Tracker, a Watcher or some other claim. But 1-shot. Nope, he receives the bullet train to the noose today.
You are claiming a role that is much more beneficial for scum to have than town, so I don't buy any arguments that your role and a cop role (even X-shot), can't exist at the same time.
I feel like he should be leaning towards believing at least one of them since scum aren't likely to be CCing each other, but it looks more like he's sat in the middle.
In post 261, PeregrineV wrote:@Tywin
- Except that your vote and rationale boils down to a OMGUS vote. Would rather see attempted discussion by you of either Xanth or SlySly early reads list.
This is a simplification and discredit of Tywin's vote and I think Tywin's town. He's also trying to direct Tywin to talk about what he wants Tywin to talk about, rather than talking about the reads lists himself. If PerV is scum I could see myself being wrong on SlySly.
Going to get back to rereading
Peregrine suspicions^
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:24 pm
by ssbm_Kyouko
It was already posted like 3 pages ago
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 6:25 pm
by Land of Xanth
Thx!
-Ali
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 7:12 pm
by Tywin Lannister
Just caught up. Went to doctor today and found out I have bronchitis. It sucks, and my ass hurts from getting a shot there. Not been a fun day.
Anyway, VOTE: peregrinV. I agree with Kyouko's reasoning, since I've already said the same things myself, and I still haven't gotten a response to my questions. Also, Sly is probably scum, but maybe he is just another VI. I can't really tell at this point, so I'll leave it alone for now. At least he didn't ignore me when I asked him questions like peregrinV has.
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 7:16 pm
by Land of Xanth
Tywin thoughts on Pep?
Also that fucking sucks.
-Ali
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 11:50 pm
by Narna
I think both of the mind-bendingly stupid cop claims are town.
I'm surprised this doesn't have more votes.
VOTE: Lil Uzi
Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 11:56 pm
by Narna
{Comm, James, Kyouko
Skelda, Xanth, Vifam}
{Twin, Pep, Fuzzy, Harp, TTTT, Zekromaster}
{Slysly, Ramcius,
PV, Lil Uzi}
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 12:14 am
by Ramcius
In post 437, Narna wrote:I think both of the mind-bendingly stupid cop claims are town.
I'm surprised this doesn't have more votes.
VOTE: Lil Uzi
why he?
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 12:21 am
by Narna
His
#427 is a joke among various gut pingings.
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 12:33 am
by TTTT
Started reading this when I requested to replace in
I'm about halfway current.
Was hoping for a dayvig role pm so I could shut up Navy SEAL James.
hi ssbm and LUV
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 1:00 am
by Lil Uzi Vert
In post 428, Land of Xanth wrote:Yep, it's totally a reach when Vifam's RVS post was the 2nd post of the game.
Adapt Uzi. You're better then this.
-Ali
In post 430, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:Narna hasn't read the game yet, it's just reacting to what they've seen so far. And peregrine is my second choice but and Skelda I don't think is going to react to pressure
Didn't read that way to me. Read like while he was catching up he saw something that pinged him about Vifam.
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 1:12 am
by Lil Uzi Vert
In post 432, ssbm_Kyouko wrote: In post 357, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:
Don't like the way Peregrine criticizes both Comm and James here:
In post 257, PeregrineV wrote:
So, given the disadvantage of claiming cop right away, and the fact you could be fakeclaiming as scum, you understand if we ignore the bit of self-meta that you always claim day1, and any reasons you gave for it. Right?
In post 258, PeregrineV wrote: In post 169, CommKnight wrote: In post 167, Land of Xanth wrote: In post 165, James3 wrote:Okay, so Comm is confirmed scum.
UNVOTE: Xanth
VOTE: Comm
If he really were cop he would've immediately CCed.
Do you seriously think for half a second that there isn't a second investigative role if you're a 1-shot cop?
This shit is redonkulous. No investigative claims are getting lynched on day fucking one.
-G
You know, I actually really want to check the hyrdra's role. Just because of how defensive they've been of a 1-shot cop. I've already claimed the pointlessness of a 1-shot and now I've even CC'd.
Now, I can believe there's other investigatives out there, but a cop? Maybe, maybe not. A 1-shot cop at that? Hell no. I'm sticking to my guns with this one. I can believe a Tracker, a Watcher or some other claim. But 1-shot. Nope, he receives the bullet train to the noose today.
You are claiming a role that is much more beneficial for scum to have than town, so I don't buy any arguments that your role and a cop role (even X-shot), can't exist at the same time.
I feel like he should be leaning towards believing at least one of them since scum aren't likely to be CCing each other, but it looks more like he's sat in the middle.
In post 261, PeregrineV wrote:@Tywin
- Except that your vote and rationale boils down to a OMGUS vote. Would rather see attempted discussion by you of either Xanth or SlySly early reads list.
This is a simplification and discredit of Tywin's vote and I think Tywin's town. He's also trying to direct Tywin to talk about what he wants Tywin to talk about, rather than talking about the reads lists himself. If PerV is scum I could see myself being wrong on SlySly.
Going to get back to rereading
Peregrine suspicions^
I don't think he's scum here just because he's doubtful of the claims. Seems reasonable if he's thinking about the utility of each role and how helpful it would be each alignment. Your last point is valid but I don't think scum would suggest things he would like to see after the discredit. His suggestions reads like things he felt would've actually moved the game forward at the time as well.
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 5:06 am
by TTTT
plz share other "gut pingings"
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 7:12 am
by CommKnight
Yes, let's hear some more from everyone. I still want to lynch James, but that isn't happening today and Ramcius is just either bad town or scum. It's not even funny but with everyone looking elsewhere I'm giving up my crusades until they either get over themselves and their TvT fighting or I get some conf scum with my role.
I'm comfortable with my reads so far.
Ramcius and James in the scum pile with Tywin being my only hard town read. The rest are neutral or near neutral with their posts or lack thereof.
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 7:19 am
by Vifam
He could be scum but I haven't really noticed him
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 7:26 am
by Tywin Lannister
@Uzi: so discussing the reads list of Sly/LoX would've moved the game along, but me discussing Sly's other posts were not? How does that make any sense? Also, I ignored his request, because I was going to do a read list myself until I saw that almost everyone was lurking/inactive/0-2 posts total (all with no real content) for me to say anything more than 'these couple of players are obv town, these 1-2 players look scummy, the other 12-15 players are completely null.' It was pointless and I stopped. Narna hadn't posted yet. Gamma wasn't replaced. Hark didn't post yet. Most players had maybe 1 RVS post at best. So how would his request for me to discuss a useless endeavor have progressed the game more than my genuine SR on Sly? It looked like chainsawing to me, since the goal seemed to be take heat off of Sly there. Otherwise, it could be scum trying to gain TCred by defending what he saw as lynchbait. I don't see why town would defend another player from simple questions, especially when Sly seemed capable of answering them himself. He wasn't wilting under pressure like a new player may (which then makes the defense more understandable), so I still can't see why he'd do it. His entire point about the OMGUS thing looks fabricated, and the term didn't even fit.
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 8:04 am
by CommKnight
Also to note: I'm still shaking off the rust from my long break of forum mafia in general. I use to keep a folder for each game I played with excel spreadsheets and word when I was hardcore in it doing 3-4 games at a time and could spend more than a few minutes here and there on. So if I bypass questions or forget why I think something one way or another, I just don't have it written down and saved somewhere like I use to do all the time.
Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 8:35 am
by TTTT
@ssbm
can you help a bro out
and give me the game-state from your pov?
