KradDrol, I'd find your position a lot less scummy if your reasons for a no-lynch were different. Relying on an investigator and not wanting to take a position on anyone is more than a little scummy.
Unvote:KradDrol
- Time for me to eat my hat.
However, I have been thinking about it a bit more and I'm actually going to reverse course right now.
Looking at the numbers again, a no-lynch might not be so bad for us.
There are two big assumptions at work here - we have three mafia and an SK. If we've actually got a vig instead - and Peers' role is some kind of cruel joke by Iammars - then this is not a good idea.
If we end up lynching the SK and the mafia kill a townie at night, we will end up tomorrow morning in a 3-3 tie. I'm not sure what Iammars' rules are about ties, but they often mean a scum win.
Mod - could you clarify whether the game is over when only three vanilla townies and three mafia are alive?
I'm specifically wording it this way so we can hopefully get an answer without the mod saying that it would give away whether some roles exist.
Given that, I only think we should lynch if we
know
that Liam still has use of his ability. At this stage of the game, an SK is one of our biggest allies, especially if Peers is telling the truth.
Interestingly, I'm now leaning toward a no-lynch and letting Liam's ability remain unknown. I'd rather let him decide if it's better to use it or to keep the possibility of cross-kills alive. Liam's ability is much more useful for us once the SK is dead or town.
Vote: No Lynch
I realise this may be a stretch for some of you, so feel free to ask me to clarify my thoughts before jumping on me.