Mini 555 --- LDF Mafia -- Game Over!
Forum rules
I won't deny that fish at D2 Sly, but I will say that it was said before I deduced a partial reveal type game.
What is being revealed, not full info. We get name and alliance. Sarcastro is not giving roles after death, that is what he is hiding. Andy's #3 is when fishing like that should have stopped, after the Pope explained the reveal system.
Also, are you reading the comic more Sly, or are you obtaining your knowledge some other way.
What is being revealed, not full info. We get name and alliance. Sarcastro is not giving roles after death, that is what he is hiding. Andy's #3 is when fishing like that should have stopped, after the Pope explained the reveal system.
Also, are you reading the comic more Sly, or are you obtaining your knowledge some other way.
- SlySly
- SlySly
-
SlySly
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 5851
- Joined: October 18, 2007
- Location: Unknown
Oh, I thought you meant that you thought Thanatos was only partially revealing something.eljcko wrote: What is being revealed, not full info. We get name and alliance. Sarcastro is not giving roles after death, that is what he is hiding.
Does this mean that your entire case against Thanatos is based on role fishing?
When this day started, I thought the same thing that Thanatos posted. I thought it was rather strange that no power roles had died yet until I read back through and reminded myself that this game was only partial reveal. I don't see his post as a scum tell as I thought the exact same thing the first time I saw the post.
Hopefully we will get a replacement for Thanatos soon.
I have read up and gained much knowledge about the characters of LDF.eljcko wrote: Also, are you reading the comic more Sly, or are you obtaining your knowledge some other way.
- SlySly
- SlySly
-
SlySly
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 5851
- Joined: October 18, 2007
- Location: Unknown
Assuming there have been no successful role blocks and will continue to be none, here are the possibilities that I see remaining...
1)
2 scum(1 team)
4 town
----------------------------------------------------------------
2)
3 scum(1 team of 2, 1 team of 1(hasdgfas' partner))
3 town
This scenario puts us at LYLO now. No room for error. Now.
----------------------------------------------------------------
It is my understanding that an SK has to kill every night where a vig can kill when they choose. If this is the case, the lack of 2 kills during N0, leans to there not being an SK and there not being a vig kill on the first night.
I am still fairly a newb, help me out here. Generally, in a multi-scum group game, is it possible for one scum group to unknowingly NK a member of another scum group?
Am I missing another possibility?
1)
2 scum(1 team)
4 town
----------------------------------------------------------------
2)
3 scum(1 team of 2, 1 team of 1(hasdgfas' partner))
3 town
This scenario puts us at LYLO now. No room for error. Now.
----------------------------------------------------------------
It is my understanding that an SK has to kill every night where a vig can kill when they choose. If this is the case, the lack of 2 kills during N0, leans to there not being an SK and there not being a vig kill on the first night.
I am still fairly a newb, help me out here. Generally, in a multi-scum group game, is it possible for one scum group to unknowingly NK a member of another scum group?
Am I missing another possibility?
- Alabaska J
- Alabaska J
-
Alabaska J
- Title Arbitrairy
- Title Arbitrairy
- Posts: 2568
- Joined: November 18, 2007
- Location: Texas (and I don't know anyone who owns a horse)
Hey! I'll post soon, hopefully.
Show
Concussed by a poorly constructed title - how ironic. - Erg0
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
- Alabaska J
- Alabaska J
-
Alabaska J
- Title Arbitrairy
- Title Arbitrairy
- Posts: 2568
- Joined: November 18, 2007
- Location: Texas (and I don't know anyone who owns a horse)
Wow the case against me is crap. Notice my predecessor also missed lovo18's claim. Him missing the structure of the reveals isn't that farfetched, IMO.
With four scum (two groups), it is 4/13 scum ratio with crosskill possibility. With one scumgroup, it would be 3/13, and I would have to say that we have an sk for balance reasons.
Also, I believe I'm at L-1. *checks* Yep I am. I am a little nervous, so claim time.
I am Naomi Hunter, the doctor of FOXHOUND. Now let's get to finding scum! Tomorrow I will hopefully be able to post some of my thoughts b/c my AP tests will all be complete.
With four scum (two groups), it is 4/13 scum ratio with crosskill possibility. With one scumgroup, it would be 3/13, and I would have to say that we have an sk for balance reasons.
Also, I believe I'm at L-1. *checks* Yep I am. I am a little nervous, so claim time.
I am Naomi Hunter, the doctor of FOXHOUND. Now let's get to finding scum! Tomorrow I will hopefully be able to post some of my thoughts b/c my AP tests will all be complete.
Show
Concussed by a poorly constructed title - how ironic. - Erg0
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
unvote: vote lloyd
albaska's claim should be the kick we need.
I chose to vote for lloyd over andy because I do not agree with the case on Andy right now.
I vote lloyd because he has barely posted at all in this game, and while I checked his posting records, he probably has a tendency to do this type of thing. But I figure a bit of pressure should get more talking out of him. Plus there is the decent possiblity that lloyd is lurking and trying to avoid the heat because he is scum/SK.
OK. Given your eagerness for Andy, I think you investigate him last night. No need to confirm / deny one way or another.SlySly wrote:No, I did not waste it again last night.Lloyd wrote:
SlySly, did you happen to waste it again last night?
Alabaska, I wish you hadn't claimed. I do believe your claim, and that's precisely why I wish you hadn't done it. If we are in LYLO (as Sly described in scenario 2), then a claim by a real doctor (assuming your claim is true) has essentially made the game sure-loss, unless we can your death from here on out.Alabaska J wrote:I am Naomi Hunter, the doctor of FOXHOUND.
eljcko, if you want me to post, you can also ask in bold letters without voting. Your vote for me seems opportunistic.eljcko wrote:I figure a bit of pressure should get more talking out of him.
I post when I have something valuable to contribute, and I still feel strongly about Andy being scum.
I'm in the heat already, since I was the first to point out suspicious points against Andy.
SlySly's posts in pushing for Andy's lynch seems slightly over-eager.
At first, I viewed it as suspicious-ness, then I thought it was possible new-ish-ness, but I now think it's most likely that SlySly investigated Andy last night.
eljcko, the fact that you don't seem convinced of the reasons against Andy, preferred Thanatos previously, and now me, makes me think it's more likely that you are teamed with Andy (as opposed to Jdodge, which I originally suspected).
With that said, I still think Andy is a better candidate to be lynched than you, or anyone else, at this point.
- Andycyca
- Andycyca
-
Andycyca
- Gets To Kill All Spammers
- Gets To Kill All Spammers
- Posts: 778
- Joined: July 31, 2007
- Location: The Tesseract
- Contact:
Do you know whether Alabaska's role is protective? After all, Naomi's helped building a cyborg, the "doctor" part of "Dr Naomi Hunter" doesn't mean she's a medical person, rather someone with a high degree of studies within a particular field of study.
FoS: Lloyd
Planning: Katamari Damacy Mafia - Less than 50% done!
BTRAF 6 coming to a Mafia Forum near you. Now with 50% less chlorine! Bring your tin foil hat
- JDodge
- JDodge
-
JDodge
- Accept it
- Accept it
- Posts: 5926
- Joined: May 6, 2005
- Location: Atop my cloud
- Contact:
Andy, does your role fit your rolename?Andycyca wrote:Do you know whether Alabaska's role is protective? After all, Naomi's helped building a cyborg, the "doctor" part of "Dr Naomi Hunter" doesn't mean she's a medical person, rather someone with a high degree of studies within a particular field of study.
FoS: Lloyd
- Alabaska J
- Alabaska J
-
Alabaska J
- Title Arbitrairy
- Title Arbitrairy
- Posts: 2568
- Joined: November 18, 2007
- Location: Texas (and I don't know anyone who owns a horse)
Well, I was at L-1 and it wasn't looking good. Lynching me if we are in LYLO is also a game sure-loss.Lloyd wrote:Alabaska, I wish you hadn't claimed. I do believe your claim, and that's precisely why I wish you hadn't done it. If we are in LYLO (as Sly described in scenario 2), then a claim by a real doctor (assuming your claim is true) has essentially made the game sure-loss, unless we can your death from here on out.
Show
Concussed by a poorly constructed title - how ironic. - Erg0
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
well, lloyd, I am sorry for not corresponding to your preferred call to post. It is not an opportunistic vote, it was the first of this kind and I had no real intentions of bandwagoning you. It means very little, and FOS's are stupid IMO and I rarely use them.
Stupid reasoning by Andy there, but JD covered that anyway.
Stupid reasoning by Andy there, but JD covered that anyway.
- SlySly
- SlySly
-
SlySly
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 5851
- Joined: October 18, 2007
- Location: Unknown
Naomi does genetics research for Foxhound R & D. Genetics are part of the medical field. IMO, fits the flavor of "doctor" for this game perfectly.Andycyca wrote: the "doctor" part of "Dr Naomi Hunter" doesn't mean she's a medical person, rather someone with a high degree of studies within a particular field of study.
- SlySly
- SlySly
-
SlySly
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 5851
- Joined: October 18, 2007
- Location: Unknown
Nice how this made you sweat so hard that you took some serious time to do reverse number calculations to discredit it and how quick it was to get you to jump on the ooba wagon, coincidentally, right after Andy boarded.eljcko wrote:That was very clever of you. So clever, in fact, that I was tempted to vote for myself. But that would be dumb. But is the inverse true? Let's see the truth value of this. A=26, Z=1.ooba wrote:Nobody asked me a reason for my random vote
Anywayz ...
SCUM = 19+3+21+13 = 56
ELJCKO = 5+12+10+3+11+15 = 56
Confirm Vote : Eljcko
Eljcko = 22+15+17+24+16+12= 106
Scum = 8+24+6+14= 52
Since the inverse is false, you cannot make this 100% true. Therefore this logic is not 100% reliable.
unvote, vote oobafor having unreliable math and not completely reliable logic. And you thought you could trick me. HAHA
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
eljcko wrote: It means very little, and FOS's are stupid IMO
Wishy, washy.eljcko, earlier in the game, wrote: I am a bit iffy on you voting on SGK, only because I saw an FOS more sutable.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note the FOS put on lovo.eljcko wrote: I really don't care for that type of voting like you could care less what happens,FOS: Lovo. I am also wathcing ooba and korts, since they are not clean either.
Funny how you cast suspicion on the exact same 3 now confirmed innocents Andy had cast suspicion on, which I pointed out in my #397(Copycat) post. It took Andy 2 posts and 2 summarization sentences, to do what you did in one sentence, you are quite the eager beaver!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FoS: eljcko
- Alabaska J
- Alabaska J
-
Alabaska J
- Title Arbitrairy
- Title Arbitrairy
- Posts: 2568
- Joined: November 18, 2007
- Location: Texas (and I don't know anyone who owns a horse)
Ocelot? Vanilla?
Show
Concussed by a poorly constructed title - how ironic. - Erg0
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
Town - 16-13
Mafia - 5-7
Third Party - 0-1
Games Called/Abandoned - 1 (town)
May I remind all that you Ocelot has Chronic Back-Stabbing Syndrome.
Ocelot being vanilla is not that surprising. lovo's character (campbell?) is allegedly vanilla.
Also, I am personally sick of JD taking this game in cruise control and thinking he doesn't have to explain a bit of what he does. Did you ever explain your ooba vote.
Sly:
-My first ooba vote with the math was just to have a little fun, unless thats on your list of 10,000 scumtells. We were studying inverses in my geometry class and it was still fairly random.
-As I am gaining my experience on this site, I have developed new opinions and tweaked how I play the game. I now see FOS's as silly things, I did not back then. Don't go and say, "if FOS's are silly why did you defend yourself." You made a case on me, I defend myself.
-That post was in light of the bandwagon-for-the-hell-of-it thing going on. ooba and korts were just bandwagoning carelessly, which is never a good thing for the town.
Ocelot being vanilla is not that surprising. lovo's character (campbell?) is allegedly vanilla.
Also, I am personally sick of JD taking this game in cruise control and thinking he doesn't have to explain a bit of what he does. Did you ever explain your ooba vote.
unvote
Sly:
-My first ooba vote with the math was just to have a little fun, unless thats on your list of 10,000 scumtells. We were studying inverses in my geometry class and it was still fairly random.
-As I am gaining my experience on this site, I have developed new opinions and tweaked how I play the game. I now see FOS's as silly things, I did not back then. Don't go and say, "if FOS's are silly why did you defend yourself." You made a case on me, I defend myself.
-That post was in light of the bandwagon-for-the-hell-of-it thing going on. ooba and korts were just bandwagoning carelessly, which is never a good thing for the town.