Alright, I'll concede that Nancy is fine, i don't agree with what she's saying but whatever, also have no clue what Brian's problem with me is, or why everyone wants to vote Kaede (she's towny to me)
VOTE: Katsuki
Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2018 6:08 pm
by FakeGod
Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2018 6:09 pm
by Nosferatu
{nancy, muffin, brian} <--- townreads so far
I'm gonna townhunt this game so I don't have to read as much (4 games and a piano concerto to write rn)
Yeah, I'm a bit suspicious. I think he's tyign to buddy me based off his posts to me and trying to push the Nancy post I said.
Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2018 6:15 pm
by Kokichi Oma
In post 415, Human Sequencer wrote:kochiki why
please explain your history and thought process here in your own words
Because in the Necro game which she stated before, when she became scumread she started obvious towning really hard. Even though I was scum, I could tell she was obvious town.
In post 425, Dunnstral wrote:Alright, I'll concede that Nancy is fine, i don't agree with what she's saying but whatever, also have no clue what Brian's problem with me is, or why everyone wants to vote Kaede (she's towny to me)
VOTE: Katsuki
What do you think of wisdom
Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2018 6:17 pm
by Human Sequencer
being a condescending ass isn't gonna make me townread u sry
In post 429, Kokichi Oma wrote:Because in the Necro game which she stated before, when she became scumread she started obvious towning really hard. Even though I was scum, I could tell she was obvious town.
i feel like this is more or less what happened, do you agree?
In post 429, Kokichi Oma wrote:Because in the Necro game which she stated before, when she became scumread she started obvious towning really hard. Even though I was scum, I could tell she was obvious town.
i feel like this is more or less what happened, do you agree?
Wasn't being condescending, sorry if it came out that way. And yes, which is why I stated what I did last page? Also, the reason why I stated I was suspect on the people just voting Eevee, especially the people who didn't have the meta. The reason I didn't say the reasoning for my soft scumread on her, was because I wanted to see who would just be sheeping if they weren't in that game or had previous experience with her.
Also, that was a weird wagon on Nancy and needs to be looked at later on in the game. As soon as I stated that if Nancy didn't obvtown, I was going to vote her a weird wagon of 6 or 7 formed. Her posts have been ok so far, so I don't see myself voting there right now. Nancy what is your Wisdom read?
Well, I can’t say you’re someone I can easily read but you don’t seem to have an agenda like you did in Necro with your Eevee push. I liked your quick defense on Kaede and the whole way you’ve interacted with me and your comments about people pushing me seem to come from a town perspective.
He doesn’t really seem all that different to me than he did in Necro. It seemed to me that his push on Kaede was based on history but it looks like he came around on that. Like I’d probably be far more likely to scumread Sugar in any future games I’d play with them.
This is probably not a good barometer but it reads well to me that no one in Necro suddenly jumped on my wagon. Dunnstral should also know my meta a bit and not have voted me but I liked his townreading Kaede. Meh.
I’m sorry if I’m not “obvtowning” yet. I don’t usually do that until I really get into the game, like I did on d2, when I figured Zito couldn’t possibly be scum due to his vote on you in Necro.
In post 402, Nancy Drew 39 wrote:I don’t see how Kaede would have ever unvoted me if she were scum. Why wouldn’t she want to mislynch the lhf?
Because it would make her look bad?
What evidence is there in her ISO that makes you think she even cares how she looks?
Okay, so like, this wasn't me saying Kaede was scum jumping off of you because she's scum trying to avoid your wagon. Possible, but not what I was saying.
It was me giving an example of why, if she were scum, and you were actually town here (which I don't know and isn't even my current stance on you, which should be evidenced by me still voting you), that scum Kaede
could
have unvoted there. If this is still unclear to you, then let me know, because there is a difference.
Secondly, why does it matter if there's evidence in Kaede's iso on how she cares she looks? Scum do care how they look, and many town also care about how they look, but who cares? Yes, scum do sometimes blatantly push bad wagons, but not always, and some are more strategic in how they do it.
The timing. It didn’t look bad for her to be on my wagon at the time she jumped off it, so the only logical explanation is the one I already stated, that she didn’t want to mislynch.
In post 308, Kokichi Oma wrote:Nancy if you dont obvious town this game I'm going to vote you
kochiki
why
please explain your history and thought process here in your own words
responding to
moment
on the topic of hebichan
In post 325, Moment wrote:I can understand you calling it "trash", then, but do you consider it scummy? That is, do you think that just because it offers wriggle room to a potential scum Hebichan, that it's more likely to come from a scum Hebichan? The way I've phrased it I feel like the instinctual answer is "of course", but it seems to me that just because there may potentially be scum utility in a certain method of posting, that doesn't necessarily imply that it comes from scum. Town is just as capable of phrasing things, explaining things or just making posts in general in such a method that would offer a lot of room as scum.
i mean yeah sure but this was like all we had from her at this point in the game
i can see a clear cut scum motivation behind what she said, making non-committal busywork. your read on nancy drew in the same post isn't much different.
reflecting on it some more i'm thinking the 'foolhardy town' archetype fits her better because of her tenuous grasp of what's actually happening in the game expressed more but i hadn't made that connection at the time
i dont think i could go for nancy today
i like 349 for the most part 359 is super wrong but i don't think its scum
Nancy Drew, are you an alt?
gin could be scum
Why are you asking me this?
No, I only have one account so far on this site. You’re probably right about the “tenuous grasp” comment. I’m not fully into the game yet and haven’t read all of the posts. I still have a bit of catching up to do.