In post 418, Chemist1422 wrote:I think whoever said second that the big hydras had a scum is probably a wolf here
Read Pine's ISO, temme what you think.
-TJ
Well shit, my new post was poorly-timed.
I was probably the second one on, but never committed to it. Besides, the scum!hydra looks like BS now anyway.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 1:42 am
by NerfedBuJ
In post 423, Pine wrote:I feel like I (regrettably) picked up a towntell from Arkham.
Also, the hydra dissonance from Binary Star comes off as contrived. That comment about “we have a stated TR and I want to be concordant” especially set off alarm bells. If you have a disagreement, you either figure it out in your PT or you outright state “we don’t agree on this.” Binary Star is hedging their bets depending on how things go.
Keeping my BS vote.
I agree with rising suspicion of DEB, but having a hard time pinpointing the problem. Tonal, maybe? Overall tactical impression? Dunno.
Okay the timing of those post can't possibly be a reaction to me mentioning Pine's name so this feels pretty genuine
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 1:43 am
by Arkham Asylum
In post 424, NerfedBuJ wrote:I would have called FL scum but it doesn't make sense why scum FL would get this many townreads without posting .. so I think there's definitely some funny business there with the TRs, and if I'm right about this theory then FL is locktown
1. Didn't know DEB was in the game till DEB said hi
2. Avoided a 1v1 I was trying to instigate
3. Not attempting to control the gamestate at all
4. Scumreading us for reasons and then admitting our identities explained our behavior later
In post 247, Chickadee wrote:If I die today, pay attention to all the flimsy jumps on this wagon.
Awww, Chickadee...are you actually scum here? This martyred attitude does not match Townadee.
In post 334, Pine wrote:The Chickadee wagon is suspicious as fuck.
I don't really like the overall disconnect between these two posts.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 1:46 am
by Arkham Asylum
In post 423, Pine wrote:I agree with rising suspicion of DEB, but having a hard time pinpointing the problem. Tonal, maybe? Overall tactical impression? Dunno.
He had around 3 serious posts amongst a ton of other fluff posts. We thought the serious posts were scummy, and his rebuttal was a non-answer (jokingly?) lying that they were fluff too.
Can you look over at just those posts in context and tell me what you think? I'm on mobile, else would've quoted them myself.
In post 424, NerfedBuJ wrote:I would have called FL scum but it doesn't make sense why scum FL would get this many townreads without posting .. so I think there's definitely some funny business there with the TRs, and if I'm right about this theory then FL is locktown
1. Didn't know DEB was in the game till DEB said hi
2. Avoided a 1v1 I was trying to instigate
3. Not attempting to control the gamestate at all
4. Scumreading us for reasons and then admitting our identities explained our behavior later
Heavily town indicative for FL.
-TJ
1 is assuming DEB is scum right?
I get it , just weird that you'd put a conditional as your number 1 reason.
In post 115, Dannflor wrote:I haven’t played with Pine before, does he usually try to have more of a presence early as scum?
Eh, I used to be tryhard as either alignment, but I’m old and regardless of alignment I usually coast through D1 until the gamestate settles a bit. I loathe the early frenzy, and really like the midgame.
The Binary Star TR on my RVS banter with Chickadee is strange. It deserves some pressure.
In post 247, Chickadee wrote:If I die today, pay attention to all the flimsy jumps on this wagon.
Awww, Chickadee...are you actually scum here? This martyred attitude does not match Townadee.
No, I'm not.
Just ~reasons~
Ok
I trust you fren
In post 334, Pine wrote:The Chickadee wagon is suspicious as fuck.
Actual progression of my modest TR on Chickadee.
Seriously, if you're going to frame me, make it harder to rebut.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 1:50 am
by Pine
In other words, Chickadee's post 293 has what I suspect to be a pretty solid Towntell in it. Fakeable? Sure. But I don't think that's Chickadee's MO here.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 1:51 am
by Pine
Besides, 242/251 were joking posts near the start of her wagon, while 334 is a serious one after a really suspect wagon formed.
In post 423, Pine wrote:I agree with rising suspicion of DEB, but having a hard time pinpointing the problem. Tonal, maybe? Overall tactical impression? Dunno.
He had around 3 serious posts amongst a ton of other fluff posts. We thought the serious posts were scummy, and his rebuttal was a non-answer (jokingly?) lying that they were fluff too.
Can you look over at just those posts in context and tell me what you think? I'm on mobile, else would've quoted them myself.
-TJ
Hard to do without you identifying which posts you're referring to, but I can do a general ISO dive to explore my new read on DEB.
In post 423, Pine wrote:I agree with rising suspicion of DEB, but having a hard time pinpointing the problem. Tonal, maybe? Overall tactical impression? Dunno.
He had around 3 serious posts amongst a ton of other fluff posts. We thought the serious posts were scummy, and his rebuttal was a non-answer (jokingly?) lying that they were fluff too.
Can you look over at just those posts in context and tell me what you think? I'm on mobile, else would've quoted them myself.
-TJ
Hard to do without you identifying which posts you're referring to, but I can do a general ISO dive to explore my new read on DEB.
In post 21, Chemist1422 wrote:I have a bad snap wolfread on Easy Bake for copying my RVS reasoning
I mean I didn’t copy you. I planned my RVS once I saw the player list. Didn’t read your reasoning till you just mentioned it.
I think you’re the one copying me by way of time travel! So you should already know my alignment!
In post 434, Pine wrote:In other words, Chickadee's post 293 has what I suspect to be a pretty solid Towntell in it. Fakeable? Sure. But I don't think that's Chickadee's MO here.
Fair
I’ve never played with either of you iirc so it’s possible I’m missing someone
In post 434, Pine wrote:In other words, Chickadee's post 293 has what I suspect to be a pretty solid Towntell in it. Fakeable? Sure. But I don't think that's Chickadee's MO here.
Fair
I’ve never played with either of you iirc so it’s possible I’m missing someone
No..?
If FL was scum I'd assume he'd have a much closer look at the playerlist, and notice that DEB -- a slot he'd prolly want to plan to pocket -- exists (in the world where FL's scum and DEB town)
-TJ
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 3:32 am
by Flavor Leaf
DEB would vote me anyways.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 3:32 am
by Flavor Leaf
im aware he's in the game.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 3:32 am
by Flavor Leaf
i commented on him real early.
Posted: Tue Jun 25, 2019 3:39 am
by Chickadee
I think I was also in Overkill2??? I can no longer remember why we were talking about that.
Anyway VOTE: Dr. Easy Bake
Flimsy reasoning on everything, with an assurance that
Yeah, this was your reaction to him voting you Which implied you didn't know at that point that he was there, which means you hadn't planned according to the playerlist before that point, which means you're likely town.
Unless you faked it? Or do you not pay attention to player lists as scum too?
Yeah, this was your reaction to him voting you Which implied you didn't know at that point that he was there, which means you hadn't planned according to the playerlist before that point, which means you're likely town.
Unless you faked it? Or do you not pay attention to player lists as scum too?
-The Joker
I don't think that's AI of me, and I could have rolled scum, and then saw he was in the game.
That's not what happened, but i dont see why that couldn't be a thing
Which implied you didn't know at that point that he was there, which means you hadn't planned according to the playerlist before that point, which means you're likely town.