Mafiascum.net

actually nvm i kinda wanna go last just in case

stuck to the plan and did icon

that was fast

Karnage your predecessor claimed nurse, please confirm that's your real role

In post 429, ObviousScum wrote:that was fast

Karnage your predecessor claimed nurse, please confirm that's your real role

Did he though?

Will start reading now. Probably won't have much to add until morning

Just confirm who you targeted last night.

In post 431, ObviousScum wrote:Just confirm who you targeted last night.

I'm not going to do anything until I've caught up.

In post 416, emps wrote:im assuming we all followed the chart thing hectic told us to? i targeted george

there was a plan?

there's always a plan

who did you target dragonboi

In post 433, Iconeum wrote:there was a plan?

In post 397, Hectic wrote:Hectic targets Noni
Noni targets emps
emps targets George
George targets Obum
Obum targets Iconeum
Iconeum targets GuiltyLion
GuiltyLion targets Amrun
Amrun targets Hectic

And yeah, I targeted Obum. I'm TD.

I targeted ObvScum

Non followed the plan and targeted emps

In post 436, Iconeum wrote:I targeted ObvScum

why obvscum?

random choice

In post 429, ObviousScum wrote:that was fast

Karnage your predecessor claimed nurse, please confirm that's your real role

What was your goal with this post?

targets Noni
Noni targets emps
emps targets George
George targets ObviousScum
ObviousScum targets Iconeum
Iconeum targets ObviousScum *not the plan*
GuiltyLion targets
targets

Is it possible to mechanically solve who scum is from this?

In post 420, emps wrote:i think it's technically optimal for scum to target whoever they were supposed to doc for nk

Then wouldn't this make GL scum?

In post 441, Karnage wrote:

Hectic

targets Noni
Noni targets emps
emps targets George
George targets ObviousScum
ObviousScum targets Iconeum
Iconeum targets ObviousScum *not the plan*
GuiltyLion targets

Amrun

Amrun

targets

Hectic

Is it possible to mechanically solve who scum is from this?

In post 420, emps wrote:i think it's technically optimal for scum to target whoever they were supposed to doc for nk

Then wouldn't this make GL scum?

but gl is also the guy im locktowning rn soooooo

In post 442, emps wrote: but gl is also the guy im locktowning rn soooooo

so scum no-killed?

wait so literally nobody is claiming Nurse rn?

I feel Nurse should claim it so they can be conftown and narrow the lynchpool, and help further resolve night actions

In post 441, Karnage wrote: Is it possible to mechanically solve who scum is from this?
Then wouldn't this make GL scum?

In post 443, Karnage wrote:

In post 442, emps wrote: but gl is also the guy im locktowning rn soooooo

so scum no-killed?

I don't think it will be possible to mechanically solve who is scum, but I think best case scenario we might be able to confirm a town or two by PoE them being the only possible [x] doctor, since we know we have one of each. For example, if we assume Amrun stuck to the plan and targeted Hectic (an assumption we also have to be careful about since she never confirmed it in thread), then she is already ruled out as the regular Doctor or the Paranoid Doctor.

I don't have time yet and I kind of want Nurse to claim to make things a lot easier, but the idea is you start from "assume scum targeted [player 1]", then try to deduce which roles of doctor each player could be from there, and which claims wouldn't fit. It'll take some time but I definitely plan on giving it a go, probably tonight or tomorrow. It might wind up being a mostly pointless exercise, but I definitely want to see if we can find any liars or conftowns

also keep in mind that since scum already know exactly who they targeted, they have a headstart on this information and can likely figure out more than we'll be able to since they won't have to operate in worlds like "if scum targeted [this other player], then these are the roles"