Mafiascum.net

In post 416, Menalque wrote:

In post 326, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 276, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 272, Menalque wrote:

In post 267, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 266, Menalque wrote:

In post 113, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 109, Ginngie wrote:How town is gobble

So town

Is this a prelude to an omgus vote

Like this was your only ginngie engagement after your vote, if you thought they were actually scummy why were you just memeing with them?

What makes you think this is a meme

By meme I mean “obviously not serious posting” because you hadn’t done anything that would put you even vaguely near the

border

of “so town” by this point

So that one comment invalidates the other comment in that very same post?

I would like this answered Menalque.

Whats ur point?

My point is that the second sentence is engaging with Ginngie. You didn’t find it odd that Ginngie’s first comment back is asking how town I am? The only person voting him? Especially when you had given another hard town read? That doesn’t look self centered to you?

Oooh another page top. You guys definitely can’t kill me now.

You Rule of Three’d Maria because again, you want Gobble to live. Kinda played into my hand there chap.

In post 347, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 338, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Mr. Turkey, I recall you not really having an issue with Mena’s plan when he first laid it out for you. So you having one now seems like a convenient way to debase his platform for being chosen as market owner.

This is the timeline.
~11pm my time I ask what strategy Menalque will have
~11pm he responds saying point 2 in his manifesto which includes memery
~11pm he says maximizing fun and not scumsiding the game
~12:30am is my last post of the night
~9am I wake up and vote myself after thinking about Menalque’s apparent strategy
~10am Menalque votes me
Menalque then goes on to post a ridiculous case that further supports my opinion that Menalque’s approach to this game is net negative. From my perspective he is so totally wrong about me that he will be so totally wrong about the correct auction items

So to be clear your read is that he’s town, but the village idiot.

What makes something antitown vs scummy to you about it

In post 427, Gamma Emerald wrote:You Rule of Three’d Maria because again, you want Gobble to live. Kinda played into my hand there chap.

Again, why do I want gobble to live if all the scumteam is vanilla and Gobble is easier to lynch than Maria right now. Either you call me scum and call gobble town, or your point makes absolutely no sense at all

@Mr. Turkey: Pre-empting an “OMGUS vote” doesn’t really feel like engaging someone to me

In post 414, Menalque wrote:

In post 357, gobbledygook wrote:So his entire read on me is based off one post. And that’s somehow okay with people.

Like a jury still convicts a murder off one piece of evidence when the evidence is video footage of him doing the murder he’s accused of

As I said earlier, the post you are using is nowhere near the equivalent of direct evidence of someone commiting a crime. Your continued attempts to push this narrative are either scum indicative or my appreciation for your skill as a player has found a new floor.

In post 429, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 427, Gamma Emerald wrote:You Rule of Three’d Maria because again, you want Gobble to live. Kinda played into my hand there chap.

Again, why do I want gobble to live if all the scumteam is vanilla and Gobble is easier to lynch than Maria right now. Either you call me scum and call gobble town, or your point makes absolutely no sense at all

It’s day 1 buddy. I’ll worry about how all the pieces fit later I’m working on the outline of this puzzle for now

Oh by the way Gamma I love you don't forget that, I was asked to play this game because I'm fun and fun I want to be but this kind of approach towards you could make it not fun for you so sorry I just think you're scum hehehehe

In post 432, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 429, Pink Ball wrote:

In post 427, Gamma Emerald wrote:You Rule of Three’d Maria because again, you want Gobble to live. Kinda played into my hand there chap.

Again, why do I want gobble to live if all the scumteam is vanilla and Gobble is easier to lynch than Maria right now. Either you call me scum and call gobble town, or your point makes absolutely no sense at all

It’s day 1 buddy. I’ll worry about how all the pieces fit later I’m working on the outline of this puzzle for now

Problem is, you're using pieces of two different puzzles. I wouldn't recommend that, stick with one for better results

In post 357, gobbledygook wrote:So his entire read on me is based off one post. And that’s somehow okay with people.

In post 368, gobbledygook wrote:Gamma, when I flip town, what is your opinion of Menalque?

Lnao the mad lad did it again

In post 433, Pink Ball wrote:Oh by the way Gamma I love you don't forget that, I was asked to play this game because I'm fun and fun I want to be but this kind of approach towards you could make it not fun for you so sorry I just think you're scum hehehehe

I actually really appreciate this. I do feel like your play overall is disingenuous, but when it comes to me specifically your play isn’t so bad. I can understand your progression on me but everything else (barring your Datisi read I guess) comes off as a bit of a front.

PB, is there any reason why your still vote isn’t on any of your scumreads?

Also for calling me scum so confidently, where’s your vote bro?

My Datisi read is not that well developed you're right

Oh because I'm scum and I want to see what everyone thinks about Gamma and not vote him until everyone else agrees with me so if no one agrees I can compromise to another town wagon I guess

Why so obsessed about not voting, I'm worried of real life interactions first, a vote finish off those interactions

Ah fuck, hate phones

Also for the above post why not

Yeah tbh i myself have a pocket of super early game tells i hunt for. My first one was Mela and he concerns me with how quick he is To declare reads in the beginning. Funny actually, Pine in this game taught me the tell. In a marathon game, he caught Ali (hilariously enough) as scum cuz Ali declared a person as town and Pine was like you’re way too confident too early. Boom. Gottem.

Tangent aside, I see Mela throwing out reads like zingers and i worry. However I’ll say I’ve lessened my doubts about Mela due to his wobble on Gobble. regardless of how it plays out i can see his progression in the read and it’s not taking any out of place turns

In post 430, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Mr. Turkey: Pre-empting an “OMGUS vote” doesn’t really feel like engaging someone to me

In post 428, Ginngie wrote:

In post 347, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 338, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Mr. Turkey, I recall you not really having an issue with Mena’s plan when he first laid it out for you. So you having one now seems like a convenient way to debase his platform for being chosen as market owner.

This is the timeline.
~11pm my time I ask what strategy Menalque will have
~11pm he responds saying point 2 in his manifesto which includes memery
~11pm he says maximizing fun and not scumsiding the game
~12:30am is my last post of the night
~9am I wake up and vote myself after thinking about Menalque’s apparent strategy
~10am Menalque votes me
Menalque then goes on to post a ridiculous case that further supports my opinion that Menalque’s approach to this game is net negative. From my perspective he is so totally wrong about me that he will be so totally wrong about the correct auction items

So to be clear your read is that he’s town, but the village idiot.

What makes something antitown vs scummy to you about it

Yes.
I don’t think Menalque as scum would be this dogged about a wrong scumread on one of his teammates from team mafia 2020.

In post 431, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 414, Menalque wrote:

In post 357, gobbledygook wrote:So his entire read on me is based off one post. And that’s somehow okay with people.

Like a jury still convicts a murder off one piece of evidence when the evidence is video footage of him doing the murder he’s accused of

As I said earlier, the post you are using is nowhere near the equivalent of direct evidence of someone commiting a crime. Your continued attempts to push this narrative are either scum indicative or my appreciation for your skill as a player has found a new floor.

this entire conversation reads so fake

PB if you could tell me how you're townreading *both* of these i'd love to hear it because atp i am actually gonna get tunnelled

In post 369, Datisi wrote:I like Maria for unexplainable reasons

No opinion on Ginnie rn

I’m a stoner now so peace bro

But if I’m mad and can’t understand something it ugly

Town points for Ginngie for calling Mena Mela, and for saying wobble gobble

In post 443, Datisi wrote:

In post 431, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 414, Menalque wrote:

In post 357, gobbledygook wrote:So his entire read on me is based off one post. And that’s somehow okay with people.

Like a jury still convicts a murder off one piece of evidence when the evidence is video footage of him doing the murder he’s accused of

As I said earlier, the post you are using is nowhere near the equivalent of direct evidence of someone commiting a crime. Your continued attempts to push this narrative are either scum indicative or my appreciation for your skill as a player has found a new floor.

this entire conversation reads so fake

PB if you could tell me how you're townreading *both* of these i'd love to hear it because atp i am actually gonna get tunnelled

If you think the conversation is fake you think they're both scum, right?

So no chance only one of them is scum and the other town? If not, then if I read the conversation as genuine, the best conclusion would be that they're both town, right?

In post 444, Ginngie wrote:

In post 369, Datisi wrote:I like Maria for unexplainable reasons

No opinion on Ginnie rn

I’m a stoner now so peace bro

But if I’m mad and can’t understand something it ugly

sorry what

In post 439, Pink Ball wrote:My Datisi read is not that well developed you're right

Not the response I expected.

For now I think I’m good to let PB play some more and try to gather more data on him naturally.

Boom