Mafiascum.net

reminds me of a younger me, which is weird because I don't age

In post 424, Peter Pan wrote:zan is town but I don't agree with his method of scum hunting

what part of it don't u agree with and why

In post 424, Peter Pan wrote:zan is town but I don't agree with his method of scum hunting

Well it's not all just looking at individual words in posts, honest.

The part where he thinks mafia is akin to a scientific proof and if he can just show that one step is wrong, then the whole thing will come crashing down around an exposed scum

but it doesn't work that way

But do you or don't you think it's really strange that Nero would say "prob xxx" and then later say that he thought he was answering a question about his own read on someone?

In post 423, Firebringer wrote:where is alchemist, I want to jam with him.

Right here.

In post 429, Zantetsu wrote:But do you or don't you think it's really strange that Nero would say "prob xxx" and then later say that he thought he was answering a question about his own read on someone?

No I don't

I think a lot of people get feelings about slots and then rationalize them when they have a need to

besides nero town is one of my stronger reads at this moment

In post 431, Peter Pan wrote:

In post 429, Zantetsu wrote:But do you or don't you think it's really strange that Nero would say "prob xxx" and then later say that he thought he was answering a question about his own read on someone?

No I don't

I think a lot of people get feelings about slots and then rationalize them when they have a need to

Well up until that moment I had a town read on Nero so ... how does that rationalize with your view on how I scum hunt?

Although I will admit it was a town read with an asterisk given my interactions with him earlier.

In post 433, Zantetsu wrote:

In post 431, Peter Pan wrote:

In post 429, Zantetsu wrote:But do you or don't you think it's really strange that Nero would say "prob xxx" and then later say that he thought he was answering a question about his own read on someone?

No I don't

I think a lot of people get feelings about slots and then rationalize them when they have a need to

Well up until that moment I had a town read on Nero so ... how does that rationalize with your view on how I scum hunt?

You're saying you had a town read on nero

and then he said probably, which didn't make sense

and now you don't have a town read on Nero?

I'd say that you found the false step in the equation that caused the proof to collapse? I think this is about as spot on an example of what I'm saying as could be hoped for ;P

In post 430, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 423, Firebringer wrote:where is alchemist, I want to jam with him.

Right here.

Where ur mind at

In post 436, Firebringer wrote:

In post 430, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 423, Firebringer wrote:where is alchemist, I want to jam with him.

Right here.

Where ur mind at

I still think Peter’s scum.

In order of confidence my Townreads are Zantetsu, Churros, Luna. I want you to be Town but I haven’t yet seen the kinds of posts I associate with Town you yet.

why u townreading churros? I am null on him.

I am also honestly null on peter. Don't like his defense but don't think its necessarily scum or town. He seems like in his own little bubble.

I actually think Peter is a power role.

In post 438, Firebringer wrote:why u townreading churros? I am null on him.

It’s mainly a toneread based on the way they’re playing around in the thread.

In post 441, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 438, Firebringer wrote:why u townreading churros? I am null on him.

It’s mainly a toneread based on the way they’re playing around in the thread.

I think that's pretty easy to do in the way he has been doing it? I think I could do the same he is doing. I think Churros is probably better player than me too.

In post 440, Firebringer wrote:I actually think Peter is a power role.

Hot take.

I think his “scum should hammer me now” was more of that fake Town mindset he’s trying to project.

In post 443, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 440, Firebringer wrote:I actually think Peter is a power role.

Hot take.

I think his “scum should hammer me now” was more of that fake Town mindset he’s trying to project.

ohh interesting I thought it was more "scum ur gonna want to hammer me cause I have a power role".

In post 442, Firebringer wrote:

In post 441, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 438, Firebringer wrote:why u townreading churros? I am null on him.

It’s mainly a toneread based on the way they’re playing around in the thread.

I think that's pretty easy to do in the way he has been doing it? I think I could do the same he is doing. I think Churros is probably better player than me too.

Like I told someone earlier, I haven’t played with Churros in that account before and don’t know who their main is so I don’t have any meta to base my read on.

town power roles often get wagonned early, fast, and give terrible defenses because they always have mindset of "town can't lynch me. They need me" and various other thoughts.

That is how I think peter is thinking and is what is driving his bad defense.

I would consider a spontaneous hammer on Peter Pan to be a scum reveal.

However, if everyone had an equal chance to hammer them, who wouldn't be scumclaiming because of it?

In post 444, Firebringer wrote:

In post 443, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 440, Firebringer wrote:I actually think Peter is a power role.

Hot take.

I think his “scum should hammer me now” was more of that fake Town mindset he’s trying to project.

ohh interesting I thought it was more "scum ur gonna want to hammer me cause I have a power role".

I think an actual Town power role has a more defensive reaction to being at L-1 than what Peter had. I read it as him trying to look Towny by calling a hammer on him a scumclaim while secretly knowing scum aren’t going to hammer him.

In post 445, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 442, Firebringer wrote:

In post 441, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 438, Firebringer wrote:why u townreading churros? I am null on him.

It’s mainly a toneread based on the way they’re playing around in the thread.

I think that's pretty easy to do in the way he has been doing it? I think I could do the same he is doing. I think Churros is probably better player than me too.

Like I told someone earlier, I haven’t played with Churros in that account before and don’t know who their main is so I don’t have any meta to base my read on.

I don't know churros main is either which is kind of embarrassing. Seems like a well rounded player to me. I think could fake this tone thing from what ive seen. I want to see some effort posting before I go town or scum.