Mafiascum.net

@MOD, NPOM is on R2R

I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

In post 422, Nauci wrote:Blair, why does Quick's surface-level-contradiction make you think that it's more important to vote Lynch All Liars than to keep pressure on votato? Can you explain why votato's interactions with his wagon reduce your scum read of him by so much? Do you no longer agree with Puppy's assessment of his "scum hunting"? What did you think of my reason for voting votato?

1. It's not just his contradiction, it's how he's handling the wagon as well.

2. Votato sounds like he genuinely believes he is scumhunting.

3. I always agreed (and still do) with Puppy that Votata looked like he was fake scumhunting. I suspect he would be doing so as either alignment, however. ("Fake" here meaning "surface level stuff that doesn't really work well as a big picture but sounds good in a vacuum" - some people genuinely argue that way for some reason)

In post 426, Quick wrote:@MOD, NPOM is on R2R

I anticipate Quick will now say "omg Blair is null reading Votato for the same reason that she is scumreading me!!!!one!!eleven!"

To which I riposte: The difference is I do not believe he is doing so on purpose.

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

That makes zero sense.

In post 430, Blair wrote:I anticipate Quick will now say "omg Blair is null reading Votato for the same reason that she is scumreading me!!!!one!!eleven!"

To which I riposte: The difference is I do not believe he is doing so on purpose.

Okay, even if I grant you that, why is what I am doing actually SCUMMY tho?

You (by your own admission, knowingly) misrepresented the premise of a case on you. Denying the town accurate information is pro-scum.

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

Are you implying that the quiet people are all scum together, or is there some other logic to your assessment?

Nauci then informed me that this is one of your top three schticks, which tells me I can expect more of this to come.

And since you told me Nauci's analysis of you was a "goldmine" I should not overlook, I have accepted the premise.

Then you suck at mafia.

In post 434, Nauci wrote:

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

Are you implying that the quiet people are all scum together, or is there some other logic to your assessment?

He is saying they are Town for voting for someone who is never getting lynched this phase.

In post 434, Nauci wrote:

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

Are you implying that the quiet people are all scum together, or is there some other logic to your assessment?

I'm saying there is more likely scum on the wagon than not.

In post 437, Quick wrote:

In post 434, Nauci wrote:

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

Are you implying that the quiet people are all scum together, or is there some other logic to your assessment?

He is saying they are Town for voting for someone who is never getting lynched this phase.

Says you.

In post 435, Blair wrote:Nauci then informed me that this is one of your top three schticks, which tells me I can expect more of this to come.

And since you told me Nauci's analysis of you was a "goldmine" I should not overlook, I have accepted the premise.

But why is that SCUMMY tho?

Or you can completely stay in your "lynch all liars" quarters by yourself and everyone else can read me as Town. Now... Pay attention to what the Puppy says about me as well because they definitely have a clue and you don't.

In post 440, Quick wrote:

In post 435, Blair wrote:Nauci then informed me that this is one of your top three schticks, which tells me I can expect more of this to come.

And since you told me Nauci's analysis of you was a "goldmine" I should not overlook, I have accepted the premise.

But why is that SCUMMY tho?

Or you can completely stay in your "lynch all liars" quarters by yourself and everyone else can read me as Town. Now... Pay attention to what the Puppy says about me as well because they definitely have a clue and you don't.

If doing things that benefit the scum team does not qualify as scummy, then nothing short of a role flip qualifies as scummy.

You are basically asking me "Are you SUUUUURE scum would want to deny the town accurate information?"

Yes, I am reasonably sure of that.

In post 438, NoPowerOverMe wrote:

In post 434, Nauci wrote:

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

Are you implying that the quiet people are all scum together, or is there some other logic to your assessment?

I'm saying there is more likely scum on the wagon than not.

The only wagon vote would be R2R who you are voting. If R2R is scum and made you switch your vote, then you believe Votato to be town, yes? What do you think about the composition of that wagon? If Votato is town, one scum would likely be on it, yes?

There is probably scum on both wagons.

Care to take a stab at who they are, NPOM?

Rtr Danny and Atari if I had to guess at this point.

In post 30, Quick wrote:

In post 29, NoPowerOverMe wrote:VOTE: nauci

Mindless comments.

Pro tip: get an avatar.

In post 32, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I'll consider it. I'm doordashing at the moment.

In post 52, Quick wrote:

In post 51, CantHateAPuppy wrote:

In post 46, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 33, CantHateAPuppy wrote:You don't understand, usually by now Blair has the class settled down and school is in session. You'll see I guess, or maybe not, don't want to poison the well here, (Sorry Blair!)

So you're saying in your past experience, Blair would be serious out of the gates? Want to make sure I'm interpreting correctly

Blair posts a lot in RVS, that's all, don't mean anything scummy implied

Quick looks like he's doing his own thing but i want him to explain his townread more so

VOTE: Quick

Sure let me try to.

As am experienced Scum he wouldn't think to take my advice seriously. That is why he "considered" doing it.

Then he said I had a good read. Make of that what you will.

Which pretty much implicates NPOM given he has experience playing as per his FoS and he never intended to get an avatar in the first place. This is Scum.

Weird reasoning, but think about it for a bit.

Plus, did you see how quickly he gave me a TR? Like, why does my tinfoil case he is TOWN a good read? Because I am pretty sure I said:

In post 54, Quick wrote:

In post 38, Quick wrote:They will, watch.

AND:

In post 179, Quick wrote:

In post 87, CantHateAPuppy wrote:Blair who's my scumbuddy? A page 4 game solution would be a new record.

NPOM -- FOS but no vote?

WTH he has no avatar.

In post 431, Quick wrote:

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

That makes zero sense.

In post 437, Quick wrote:

In post 434, Nauci wrote:

In post 427, NoPowerOverMe wrote:I think some three of the most non active people voting baltar shows that he is town

Are you implying that the quiet people are all scum together, or is there some other logic to your assessment?

He is saying they are Town for voting for someone who is never getting lynched this phase.

Plus, it means either his SR on Blair dissopated (with no progression) and that he is ignoring the VP wagon while even saying the people voting there are likely Town -1. At what point does NPOM make the "logical" choice just vote VP here? Does he TR VP or is the Town -1 mean there is no possibility of Bus or what? Cuz I am pretty sure NPOM knows Scum would for sure sit on a Scum early game if they don't intend to be active.

In post 42, NoPowerOverMe wrote:Good read.

In post 56, NoPowerOverMe wrote:Giving townreads is generally protown in my opinion as it opens yourself up to criticism

In post 98, NoPowerOverMe wrote:Why is everyone so scummy? Except Quick and Puppy.

Okay, I guess, just don't shut down Sus on yourself I guess

I know I'm town, go figure.

What does sodding mean?